A guide to adding a delay in the RxJS retry function

I am currently implementing the retry function with a delay in my code. My expectation is that the function will be called after a 1000ms delay, but for some reason it's not happening. Can anyone help me identify the error here? When I check the console output, I notice that the timestamps are all the same, at 16:22:48.

What I actually expect to see is timestamps like 16:22:48, 16:22:59...

canCreate: boolean;
getSomeFunction(): Observable<boolean> {
        return new Observable<boolean>(
            observer => {
                const canCreate = null; // initially set as null
                if (canCreate == null) {
                    observer.error('error');
                } else {
                    observer.next(true);
                }
                observer.complete();
            }
        )
    }


this.getSomeFunction()
      .do((value) => {
        this.cCreate = value;
      }, (error) => {
         console.log(error + new Date().toTimeString());
      })
      .delay(1000)
      .retry(10)
      .subscribe(
        value => this.cCreate = value,
        error => {
          this.cCreate = false;
        },
        () => {}
      );
  }

The console displays the following result:

Answer №1

delay() function is designed to create a time gap between events emitted by the observable. However, in this case, the observable does not emit any event and simply throws an immediate error.

If you are seeking to control when the retry should occur, then retryWhen() is what you need:

RxJS 5:

  .retryWhen(errors => errors.delay(1000).take(10))

RxJS 6:

import { retryWhen, delay, take } from 'rxjs/operators'
someFunction().pipe(
  // ...
  retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(delay(1000), take(10)))
)

This code snippet will complete the entire observable after 10 attempts. If you wish to terminate the observable with an error after 10 attempts, the callback within retryWhen must throw an error:

RxJS 5:

  .retryWhen(errors => errors.delay(1000).take(10).concat(Observable.throw()))

RxJS 6:

import { retryWhen, delay, take, concatMap, throwError } from 'rxjs/operators'
someFunction().pipe(
  // ...
  retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(delay(1000), take(10), concatMap(throwError)))
)

Answer №2

Previously, using retryWhen() as suggested in the accepted answer was considered a good practice. However, it has come to light that this operator is now deprecated and will be removed from RxJS versions 9 or 10. Therefore, all solutions involving retryWhen() are also considered deprecated.

Instead, the recommended approach by the RxJS development team and documentation is to utilize the retry() operator, which serves as an error handling operator with the addition of a retryConfig parameter.

To implement the same functionality with reduced code complexity, you can follow this method:

// Custom function to determine if a request should be retried
shouldRetry(error: HttpErrorResponse) {
    // Example for handling specific error codes
    if (error.status === 503) {
      return timer(1000); // Introducing a delay using the RxJS timer function.
    }

    throw error;
  }

// Implementing the retry operator in your code
retry({ count: 2, delay: this.shouldRetry })

By observing the provided example above, it is evident that achieving the desired logic requires fewer lines of code and RxJS operators compared to the previous use of retryWhen(). This highlights the reason behind deprecating the outdated operator, as similar functionality can now be accomplished using the retry() operator along with its config options.

Please adjust the code snippet according to your specific requirements, but consider this an illustration of migrating from retryWhen() to the retry() operator.

Answer №3

In continuation of @JB Nizet's response. If you are working with rxjs version 5 or above and using lettable operators, format it as:

retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(delay(1000), take(5)))

Answer №4

Attempt the operation 5 times with a delay of 500ms:

RxJS version 6 and above

  • Keep track of attempts using an index
  • Modify the error Observable in retryWhen to either use timer or throwError
retryWhen(concatMap((err, index) => index < 5 ? timer(500) : throwError(err)))

RxJS version 6.3 and above

  • Utilize index for counting attempts
  • In the error Observable of retryWhen, apply delayWhen to pause using timer or trigger throwError
retryWhen(delayWhen((err, index) => index < 5 ? timer(500) : throwError(err)))

Alternatively, you could also do this:

const delayFn = (delay = 0, count = Infinity) => {
    return (err, index) => index < count ? timer(delay) : throwError(err);
};
retryWhen(concatMap(delayFn(500, 5))) // RxJS version 6 and above
retryWhen(delayWhen(delayFn(500, 5))) // RxJS version 6.3 and above

RxJS version 7.3 and above

  • Simplify by just using retry
retry({ count: 5, delay: 500 })

Answer №5

Everything discussed here pertains to RxJS 6+


In Summary

If you prefer, you can utilize the extensively tested operator from this package. Alternatively, feel free to check out the source code below :)

npm i rxjs-boost
import { retryWithDelay } from 'rxjs-boost/operators';

obs$.pipe(
  // will retry 4 times with a 1s delay before each try:
  retryWithDelay(1000, 4)
);

Requirements

Given that most (or perhaps none) of the other solutions met all my requirements, I'll outline my approach here. Objectives:

  • Regular emissions and completion if no errors occur. ✅
  • Retry x times in case of an error. ✅
  • A time delay of y before each retry. ✅
  • Returning the last emitted error. (Many other responses struggled with this.) ✅
  • Correct typing with strict: true – although it's unlikely to mess up. ✅

The Plan

Similar to other answers, we will use the retryWhen operator to handle errors. To keep track of retries, the scan operator comes into play. For limiting retries, simply throw an error within a map operator.

In the original code, throwIf was used, but we can opt for retryWithDelay from rxjs-boost instead.

Lastly, employ the delay operator to introduce delays between executions:

import { MonoTypeOperatorFunction } from 'rxjs';
import { delay as delayOperator, map, retryWhen, scan } from 'rxjs/operators';

export function retryWithDelay<T>(
  delay: number,
  count = 1
): MonoTypeOperatorFunction<T> {
  return (input) =>
    input.pipe(
      retryWhen((errors) =>
        errors.pipe(
          scan((acc, error) => ({ count: acc.count + 1, error }), {
            count: 0,
            error: undefined as any,
          }),
          map((current) => {
            if (current.count > count) {
              throw current.error;
            }
            return current;
          }),
          delayOperator(delay)
        )
      )
    );
}

References

Answer №6

After careful consideration, I have reached the decision to attempt other operations in the http pipeline.

import {delay as _delay, map, retryWhen} from 'rxjs/operators';

export const delayedRetry = (delay, retries = 1) => retryWhen(result => {
    let _retries = 0;
    return result.pipe(
      _delay(delay),
      map(error => {
        if (_retries++ === retries) {
          throw error;
        }
        return error;
      }),
    );
  },
);

How to Use:

    http.pipe(
      delayedRetry(1500, 2),
      catchError((err) => {
        this.toasterService.error($localize`:@@not-saved:Could not save`);
        return of(false);
      }),
      finalize(() => this.sending = false),
    ).subscribe((success: boolean) => {
        if (success === true) {
           this.toasterService.success($localize`:@@saved:Saved`);
        }
      }
    });

Answer №7

To adapt ngrx5+ we have the option of developing a custom operator:


function retryRequest(constructor: () => Observable, count: number, delayTime: number) {
  let index = 0;
  return of(1) // Rather than repeating the result of constructor(), repeat the call itself
    .pipe(
      switchMap(constructor),
      retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(
        delay(delayTime),
        mergeMap(error => {
          if (++index > count) {
            return throwError(error);
          }
          return of(error);
        })
      ))
    );
}

Answer №8

Recently encountering a similar issue, I discovered room for improvement in the proposed solution.

Observable.pipe(
     retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(
      delay(1000),
      take(10))),
    first(v => true),
    timeout(10000))

This code essentially retries with specified intervals, but abruptly ends without adding any erroneous value using the 'first' operator.

If no value is found within the established timeout period, an error will be triggered.

Answer №9

Compatible with rxjs version 6.3.3

Check out the code on StackBlitz

Open the Console to view retry attempts

Example Code snippet:

import { map, catchError, retryWhen, take, delay, concat } from 'rxjs/operators';
import { throwError } from 'rxjs';


export class ApiEXT {

    static get apiURL(): string { return 'http://localhost:57886/api'; };
    static httpCLIENT: HttpClient;

 static POST(postOBJ: any, retryCOUNT: number = 0, retryINTERVAL: number = 1000) {
        return this.httpCLIENT
            .post(this.apiURL, JSON.stringify(postOBJ))
            .pipe(
                map(this.handleSUCCESS),
                retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(delay(retryINTERVAL), take(retryCOUNT), concat(throwError("Giving up Retry.!")))),
                catchError(this.handleERROR));
    }


  private static handleSUCCESS(json_response: string): any {
        //TODO: cast_and_return    
        return JSON.parse(json_response);

    }

 private static handleERROR(error: Response) {
        let errorMSG: string;
        switch (error.status) {
            case -1: errorMSG = "(" + error.status + "/" + error.statusText + ")" + " Server Not Reachable.!"; break;
            default: errorMSG = "(" + error.status + "/" + error.statusText + ")" + " Unknown Error while connecting with server.!"; break;
        }
        console.error(errorMSG);
        return throwError(errorMSG);
    }

}

Answer №10

Here is a helpful code snippet for you:

let values$ = Rx.Observable.interval(1000).take(5);
let errorFixed = false;

values$
.map((val) => {
   if(errorFixed) { return val; }
   else if( val > 0 && val % 2 === 0) {
      errorFixed = true;
      throw { error : 'error' };

   } else {
      return val;
   }
})
.retryWhen((err) => {
    console.log('retrying again');
    return err.delay(1000).take(3); // Retrying 3 times
})
.subscribe((val) => { console.log('value',val) });

Answer №11

When working with RxJS, you have access to the retry operator which allows you to resubscribe to an Observable a specified number of times when an error occurs. This can be particularly useful when dealing with network requests, as sometimes a URL may not return data successfully on the first try due to issues like network bandwidth. By using the retry operator, you give the Observable multiple chances to retrieve the data before ultimately throwing an error if unsuccessful. In situations where retries still result in errors, you can utilize the catchError method to handle the error and return the Observable with user-defined default data.

getBook(id: number): Observable<Book> {
  return this.http.get<Book>(this.bookUrl + "/" + id).pipe(
     retry(3),
     catchError(err => {
      console.log(err);
      return of(null);
     })
  );
}

Answer №12

After discovering that the accepted answer rethrow method didn't work in my case, I came up with a different solution:

Attempt to retry 3 times with a 2-second delay, and if no success is achieved, throw an error.

Observable.pipe(
  retryWhen(errors => errors.pipe(
    mergeMap((error, i) =>
      iif(() => i >= 3, throwError(() => error), timer(2000))
    )
  ))
);

Answer №13

After some experimentation, I was able to devise a solution that utilizes retryWhen along with Observable.Interval. However, one issue I encountered with this approach is that the error function within the subscribe method never actually gets triggered.

this.branchService.getCanCreate()
  .do((value) => {
    this.cCreate = value;
  }, (error) => {
    console.log('do', error + new Date().toTimeString());
  })
  .retryWhen(errors => {
    return Observable.interval(1000).take(3).concat(Observable.throw('error')));
  })
  .subscribe(
    value => {
      this.cCreate = !!value
      console.log('success', new Date().toTimeString());
    },
    error => {
      console.log('subscribe', error + new Date().toTimeString());
      this.cCreate = false;
    },
    () => {
      console.log('finally', new Date().toTimeString());
    }
  );

Answer №14

1. Utilizing Concat Method

retrievePosts()
      {
        return this.httpClient
        .get<any[]>('https://jsonplaceholder.typicode.com/postss')
        .pipe(
          retryWhen(errors =>{
            return concat(
              errors.pipe(
                delay(2000),
                take(2),
              ),
              throwError("Max Retries Exceeded!")
            )
          }),
          catchError(()=>of(["Angular","Rxjs"])))
      }

2. Leveraging ConcatMap Function

return this.httpClient
    .get<any[]>('https://jsonplaceholder.typicode.com/postss')
    .pipe(
      retryWhen(errors =>{
        return errors.pipe(
          concatMap((error,index)=> {
            if(index>=2) return throwError(error);
            else return of(error).pipe(delay(2000))
          })
        )
      }),
      catchError(()=>of("Angular","Rxjs"])))

3. Applying Scan Technique

return this.httpClient
    .get<any[]>('https://jsonplaceholder.typicode.com/postss')
    .pipe(
      retryWhen(errors =>{
        return errors.pipe(
         scan( (acc, error) => {
           if(acc>2) throw error;
           return acc+1;
         }, 1),
          delayWhen(val => timer(val * 1000)),
        )
      }),
      catchError(()=>of("Angular","Rxjs"])))
    }

Answer №15

After some investigation, I managed to come up with a solution to filter out certain errors, implement a waiting period before retrying, and set a limit on the number of retries.

Additionally, it is simple to incrementally increase the time-out duration.

import {
  HttpErrorResponse,
  HttpEvent,
  HttpHandlerFn,
  HttpRequest,
} from '@angular/common/http';
import { Observable, retry, throwError, timer } from 'rxjs';

const count = 2;
const timeout = 1000;
const resetOnSuccess = false;

function delay(error: HttpErrorResponse, retries: number): Observable<number> {
  const canRetryStatus = error.status === 0 || error.status >= 500;
  const canRetryCounter = retries < count;
  const shouldRetry = canRetryStatus && canRetryCounter;
  return shouldRetry ? timer(timeout) : throwError(() => error);
}

export function ErrorInterceptor(
  req: HttpRequest<unknown>,
  next: HttpHandlerFn
): Observable<HttpEvent<unknown>> {
  return next(req).pipe(retry({ count, delay, resetOnSuccess }));
}

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Group Hover by StyleX

I recently experimented with the innovative StyleX library and encountered a particular challenge. Can a group hover effect be achieved for a component solely using this library? For instance, let's assume we have the following component in Tailwind ...

Utilizing a React hook to render and map elements in a function

Can the hook return function be assigned to a render map in React? In this example, we have the socialAuthMethodsMap map with the onClick parameter. I tried to assign the signInWithApple function from the useFirebaseAuth hook, but it violates React's ...

Error message: "Angular 2 encountered an issue while attempting to access the property 'nativeElement' of an

Hello, I'm having issues retrieving data (which has been extracted after using ngFor) from the HTML using viewChildren and elementRef. I keep receiving the error message: Cannot read property 'nativeElement' of undefined Can someone please ...

The current context for type 'this' cannot be assigned to the method's 'this' of type '...'

Currently, I am in the process of defining type definitions (.d.ts) for a JavaScript library. In this specific library, one of the methods accepts an object of functions as input, internally utilizes Function.prototype.bind on each function, and then expos ...

Tips for enabling custom object properties in Chrome DevTools

In my typescript class, I am utilizing a Proxy to intercept and dispatch on get and set operations. The functionality is working smoothly and I have successfully enabled auto-completion in vscode for these properties. However, when I switch to the chrome d ...

Obtain an instance tuple from tuple classes using TypeScript 3.0 generic rest tuples type

When it comes to retrieving the correct instance type from a class type, the process typically involves using the following code: type Constructor<T = {}> = new (...args: any[]) => T class Foo {} function getInstanceFromClass<T>(Klass: Co ...

What is the best way to update properties in a child component using React hooks?

Looking to update the props using react hooks, I came across a method of passing setState function as props to the child component. MainContainer.tsx const MainContainer: React.FC = () => { const [count, setCount] = useState(0); return <Counter ...

Unable to retrieve data following a promise in Ionic 3

Hello, I'm currently working on an Ionic application that needs to display data in a Form Group after retrieving it with a SOAP ReadData request. Although I call my function and try to display the data in the form, there seems to be an issue as the f ...

Dynamically incorporating validation to an ngModel input

Utilizing NgForm, I dynamically added a validator to the input field. In my first example, everything works perfectly when I use the button setValidation to validate the input. However, in the second example where I add formGroup, I encounter an error whe ...

Utilizing External Libraries in Angular Full Stack Development

Currently, I am delving into the realm of Angular Full stack which incorporates Angular 2. As a newcomer to this technology, I have noticed that the setup and structure between pure Angular 2 and the Full stack can be quite distinct. This has led me to enc ...

Guide on utilizing external namespaces to define types in TypeScript and TSX

In my current project, I am working with scripts from Google and Facebook (as well as other external scripts like Intercom) in TypeScript by loading them through a script tag. However, I have encountered issues with most of them because I do not have acces ...

Creating a TypeScript interface where the type of one property is based on the type of another property

One of my Interfaces has the following structure: export enum SortValueType { String = 'string', Number = 'number', Date = 'date', } export interface SortConfig { key: string; direction: SortDirection; type: Sort ...

Storing service data within Angular2 components

As I work on creating a login service called AuthService for my Angular 2 application, I'm facing unexpected challenges. My main goal is to have a single user object that remains consistent throughout the entire application after a user logs in. This ...

Continue looping in Javascript until an empty array is identified

Currently, I am in search of a solution to create a loop in Javascript that continues until the array of objects is empty. The object I am working with looks like this: "chain": { "evolves_to": [{ "evolves_to": [{ ...

What are the best practices for utilizing the Express router efficiently?

When building a TypeScript REST API, is there any difference between router.get(); router.post(); router.patch(); router.delete(); ---------------- app.use(); app.use(); app.set(); and router .get() .post() .patch() .delete(); ---------- ...

What is the best way to pass a state within a route component in react-router?

... import { useNavigate, NavigateFunction } from "react-router"; ... function Form(): JSX.Element { const navigateToCountry = (country: string) => { // Code to navigate to country page with the given country } const [selectedCount ...

How can I implement a recursive nested template call in Angular 2?

Hopefully the title isn't too misleading, but here's my dilemma: I am in the process of building an Angular 2 app and utilizing nested templates in multiple instances. The problem I am facing involves "widgets" within my app that can contain oth ...

The element is inferred to have an 'any' type due to the inability to use a 'string' type expression to index the 'Palette' type

Encountering an issue: Element implicitly has an 'any' type because expression of type 'string' can't be used to index type 'Palette'. No index signature with a parameter of type 'string' was found on type &ap ...

What causes Gun.js to generate duplicate messages within a ReactJs environment?

I need assistance with my React application where gun.js is implemented. The issue I am facing is that messages are being duplicated on every render and update. Can someone please review my code and help me figure out what's wrong? Here is the code s ...

Experimenting with Angular component that dynamically updates based on observable service

For my Angular 4 project, I am currently testing the login() method within a component. This method relies on an Observable called authService, which can return either a success or an error: Here is the code that needs to be tested: login() { this.lo ...