Angular: Granting an external module access to a provider

One of the modules I imported provides a service with an optional dependency. Although it being optional didn't affect my application, as it just prevented any errors from occurring when not present. Here's an example:

import { FooModule } from './foo.module';
import { BarService } from './bar.service';

// other imports and logic omitted...

@NgModule({
  declarations: [
    AppComponent,
  ],
  imports: [
    BrowserModule,
    FooModule.forRoot(options),
  ],
  providers: [
    BarService,
  ],
  bootstrap: [AppComponent],
})
export class AppModule { }

In the code snippet above, the FooModule includes a FooService that can be utilized in different parts of the app. The FooService has an optional dependency:

export interface IBarService {
  bar: (x: string) => string;
}

export const BarService = new InjectionToken<IBarService>('any compatible bar service provider');

@Injectable()
export class FooService {

  constructor(
    @Optional() @Inject(BarService) private barService?: IBarService,
  ) {
    console.log(barService)
  }
}

I have provided the optional dependency (BarService) in the initial code block. However, I noticed that it wasn't being passed to the FooService within the FooModule.

Both services share the same injection name: BarService.

Despite this, when running the app, the console shows the barService as null.

Answer №1

While crafting this question, I suddenly recollected the useExisting feature of a provider. It prompted me to import the token (under a different variable name) and then establish a provider.

import { FooModule, BarService as BarServiceForFoo } from './foo.module';
import { BarService } from './bar.service';

// other imports and logic omitted...

@NgModule({
  declarations: [
    AppComponent,
  ],
  imports: [
    BrowserModule,
    FooModule.forRoot(options),
  ],
  providers: [
    BarService,
    { provide: BarServiceForFoo, useExisting: BarService }
  ],
  bootstrap: [AppComponent],
})
export class AppModule { }

Answer №2

The commonality between them is the injection name: BarService

It may be misleading as the exact name of the InjectionToken doesn't hold significance beyond debugging purposes.

While they are distinct tokens with different characteristics, they align based on the developer's intent. The useExisting option can alleviate some issues but necessitates dependencies on parent and other modules which rely on BarService or implement it to also depend on the Foo module.

One potential approach is employing a string token, although this could potentially create loose coupling and introduce global namespace concerns (hence why token classes were introduced). However, in this particular scenario, it might be a suitable fit:

...
{ provide: 'vendorNamespace.BarService', useExisting: BarService }
...

...
constructor(
  @Optional() @Inject('appNamespace.BarService') private barService?: IBarService
) {}
...

Another strategy involves incorporating a common module that encompasses both the provider token and an interface, which in this case would be represented by an abstract class:

export abstract class BarService {
  abstract bar(x: string): string;
}

import { BarService as AbstractBarService } from 'common';
export class BarService implements AbstractBarService { ... }

import { BarService as AbstractBarService } from 'common';
import { BarService } from './bar.service';

...
{ provide: AbstractBarService, useClass: BarService }
...

This structure naturally enables injecting a provider with type annotation:

import { BarService } from 'common';

...
constructor(
  @Optional() private barService?: BarService
) {}
...

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Encounter a Issue Setting up Angular 4 with git Bash

Hey, I was in the midst of installing Angular when suddenly after 11 hours of waiting, my internet slowed down and I received an error message. npm ERR! code ENOTFOUND npm ERR! errno ENOTFOUND npm ERR! network request to https://registry.npmjs.org/resolve ...

Unable to retrieve data from the array

I am encountering an issue while trying to fetch data from an array, as I keep receiving undefined Please refer to the image for a visual representation of my problem. I'm not sure what I might be overlooking, so any help would be greatly appreciate ...

Utilizing Typescript Decorators to dynamically assign instance fields within a class for internal use

I am interested in delving into Typescript Decorators to enhance my coding skills. My primary objective is to emulate the functionality of @Slf4J from Project Lombok in Java using Typescript. The concept involves annotating/decorating a class with somethin ...

JavaScript Enigma: Instantiate 2 Date variables with identical values, yet they ultimately display distinct dates on the calendar

I need some help understanding something in my screenshot. Although both tmpStart and itemDate have been assigned the same numeric value, they display different calendar dates. start = 1490683782833 -> tmpStart = "Sun Mar 26 2017 16:51:55 GMT+ ...

What is the process of loading data into mdbCharts following an API call?

I am currently having an issue with loading a PieGraph using mdbChart after making an API call. The problem is that I am getting errors while trying to load the data. Here is my code: public chartType: string = 'pie'; public chartDatasets: Array ...

Issues arise when attempting to utilize Node.js Socket.io on localhost, as the calls are ineffective in performing logging, emitting, generating errors, or executing any other actions. It has been noted that

I am in the process of developing a real-time socket.io application using Angular and Node, following the instructions provided here. I have set up the server and client connection, but unfortunately, the connection is not being established. Server Code: ...

Adding a datepicker popup to an input field in angular2 with the format of YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss is as simple as following

Can someone help me with adding a datepicker popup to an input field in Angular, using the format YYYY-MM-DD hh:mm:ss? I have tried the following code in my .html file but it doesn't seem to be working. <input [(ngModel)]="date2" ngui-datetime-pi ...

Using the decorator in VueJS Typescript allows you to easily define dynamic computed properties

On my hands is a component structured like this: @Component({ computed: { [this.stateModel]: { get() { return this.$store[this.stateModel]; } } } }) class Component extends Vue{ @Prop({ de ...

Utilizing Next.js and React to interact with Open AI through API requests

I'm currently experimenting with the OpenAI API to develop a chatbot using React, TypeScript, and Next.js. I am facing an issue where clicking the send button in the UI does not trigger any action. Even after adding console.log statements, nothing sho ...

Experiencing difficulties implementing a Sign in with Google feature with .NET Core 2.1 and Angular 2

Currently, my tech stack consists of Angular 2, Net Core 2.1, and Identity. I've been exploring the option of enabling Google authentication, but have encountered some limitations while using client side gapi libraries - particularly when dealing with ...

Calculating the sum of values in a JSON array using a specific parameter in Typescript

A flat JSON array contains repetitive identifier, categoryId, and category: data: [ { "identifier": "data", "categoryId": "1", "category": "Baked goods", "product": "Aunt Hattie's", "price": "375" } ...

The workspace does not have the 'development' configuration set for Angular 12 Universal

After creating a new Angular 11 project called "client", I updated the Angular version to 12 and installed Universal by running the command: ng add @nguniversal/express-engine. However, when attempting to run my Universal Angular project using the command ...

Capturing a center mouse click event in a directive for Angular 6

I created a unique custom directive where I aim to capture middle mouse button click events. Initially, I thought it would be a straightforward process by setting the normal click event and working from there. However, I noticed that it only triggers when ...

Typescript error: Import statement not allowed here

Recently delving into the world of TypeScript, I encountered an issue when attempting to build for production. My first step was running tsc Although this step passed without any errors, I faced import errors when trying to execute the build file with ...

Implementing debounceTime in Angular can be done by using the debounceTime operator

I am currently working on implementing the debounceTime functionality in an autocomplete feature. My goal is to use debounceTime to minimize the number of server calls. After researching, I found 3 possible solutions which I have included snippets of belo ...

Define an object in TypeScript without including a specific field type in the definition

Let's consider a scenario where there is an interface called Book: interface Book { id: number info: { name: string, } } Next, a list named bookList is defined: const bookList: Book[] = [ { id: 1, info: { ...

What is preventing me from running UNIT Tests in VSCode when I have both 2 windows and 2 different projects open simultaneously?

I have taken on a new project that involves working with existing unit tests. While I recently completed a course on Angular testing, I am still struggling to make the tests run smoothly. To aid in my task, I created a project filled with basic examples f ...

Emphasize x-axis heading in a Highcharts graph

In my Highcharts bar graph, I am looking for a way to dynamically highlight the x-axis label of a specific bar based on an external event trigger. This event is not a standard click interaction within the Highcharts graph. Currently, I have been able to r ...

Supply type Parameters<T> to a function with a variable number of arguments

I am interested in utilizing the following function: declare function foo(...args: any): Promise<string>; The function foo is a pre-defined javascript 3rd party API call that can accept a wide range of parameters. The objective is to present a coll ...

collection of assurances and the Promise.all() method

Currently, I am dealing with an array of Promises that looks like this: let promisesArray = [ service1.load('blabla'), service2.load(), // throws an error ]; My goal is to execute all these Promises and handle any errors that occur, as ...