Contrasting Compositions with Generics

Let's consider a scenario where we have an abstract class A and three concrete classes that inherit from it: A1, A2, and A3. There is also another hierarchy tree with an abstract class B and three concrete classes B1, B2, and B3. Each concrete class A needs to hold a list of objects of the corresponding B class. For example, A1 holds a list of B1 objects. What would be the optimal solution for this situation:

  1. One approach could be to make A a generic class and have it hold a generic list of T which extends B, like so:

    abstract class A<T extends B> {
        protected arr: Array<T extends B>
    }
    

    This way, we can declare each A class as follows:

    class A1 extends A<B1>
    
  2. Alternatively, we can use composition in the following manner:

    class A1 extends A {
        private arr: Array<B1>
    }
    

Answer №1

If you find yourself with multiple classes containing similar code but differing only in the type of object they use, generics may be the way to go. For example, if classes A1, A2, A3 all share functionality but vary in the type of B object, generics could streamline your code. If this isn't the case, consider using composition instead as there may not be a strong reason for utilizing generics.

Answer №2

The second option is my preference! Utilizing generic classes becomes necessary when you want certain methods and functionalities to be implemented on various objects regardless of their specific type. However, it wouldn't be considered good design to declare a class as generic solely to address a composition issue!

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Iterating over an object and inserting values into a JavaScript object using the ascending count as the identifier

Illustration: { Are you a coffee drinker?: yes, Do you like to exercise regularly?: no, How often do you eat out at restaurants?: 3 times a week, What is your favorite type of cuisine?: Italian } Results: {yes: 1, no: 1, 3 time ...

Guide on transforming an array containing indexed objects into a simple object

Can anyone help me with converting an array of this specific type? place: [ { "_id": "xxxxx", "loc": [ 0: "xxx", 1: "xxx" ] } ] Into something ...

Display or conceal elements within a Component with the help of a Service

After developing a custom Tabs component, I have implemented it in the following way (StackBlitz example): <tabs> <tab title="Tab 1"> <div toolbar> <message><span>Message 1: </span></message> &l ...

Creating a TypeScript shell command that can be installed globally and used portably

I am looking to create a command-line tool using TypeScript that can be accessed in the system's $PATH once installed. Here are my criteria: I should be able to run and test it from the project directory (e.g., yarn command, npm run command) It must ...

The expected input should be either an HTMLElement or an SVGElement, but the received input is currently null

Below is the code for a component: function SignUpPage() { return ( <> <h1>Sign Up</h1> <input name="userName" /> </> ); } export default SignUpPage; Testing the component: it("should c ...

Configuring the tsconfig outDir will specify where the output files will be stored

What am I missing in the tsconfig settings if I only want to output files in the root directory? If I set it as "rootDir":"src" "outDir":"build", or "rootDir":"src" "outDir":"&q ...

Eliminate the alert message that appears when dynamically rendering a React styled component

When checking the browser console, I noticed a warning that reads as follows: react_devtools_backend.js:3973 The component styled.div with the id of "sc-dmRaPn" has been created dynamically. You may see this warning because you've called sty ...

What is the rationale behind permitting surplus properties in Typescript interfaces even though all properties are declared as optional?

Exploring the code snippet... interface Options { allowed?: string; } function test(options: Options) { return options; } const options = { allowed: 'allowed', notAllowed: 'notAllowed', }; test(options); // no error thrown ...

I obtained the binary tree output in the form of an object. How can I extract the values from this object and store them in an array to continue working on

Issue Statement In this scenario, you have been presented with a tree consisting of N nodes that are rooted at 1. Each node in the tree is associated with a special number, Se. Moreover, each node possesses a certain Power, which is determined by the count ...

What is the method for creating a new array of objects in Typescript with no initial elements?

After retrieving a collection of data documents, I am iterating through them to form an object named 'Item'; each Item comprises keys for 'amount' and 'id'. My goal is to add each created Item object to an array called ' ...

Data can be retrieved in a React/Next.js application when a button is clicked, even if the button is located in a separate

Whenever the button is clicked, my function fetches weather data for the current location. I am trying to figure out how to transfer this data from the Location component to the pages/index.tsx. This is where another component will display the data. This ...

What is the best way to make the SPA load with the tab displaying the highest value?

I have a React single-page application using Typescript and Material UI. One challenge I'm facing is creating a tab menu with the current month and all previous months, where the last month should be active when the page loads. Despite researching on ...

Is it possible to effortlessly associate a personalized string with an identifier within an HTML element utilizing Angular2?

Check out this cool plunker import {Component} from 'angular2/core' @Component({ selector: 'my-app', template: ` <div *ngFor="#option of myHashMap"> <input type="radio" name="myRadio" id="{{generateId(option[& ...

Transform a JSON array into an array of objects using typescript

I have a JSON array that I need to convert into an object type array JSON array [ 0:{code: "00125", scheme: "0001", plotNumber: "125", propType: "001", plotType: "001"} 1:{code: "190", scheme: "0001", plotNumber: "NA 190", propType: "001", plotType: "0 ...

Merge two RxJS Observables/Subscriptions and loop through their data

Working with Angular (Version 7) and RxJS, I am making two API calls which return observables that I subscribe to. Now, the challenge is combining these subscriptions as the data from both observables are interdependent. This is necessary to implement cer ...

NestJS: Specify the data type for @Body()

Consider the code snippet below: @Post() public async createPet(@Body() petDetails: PostPetDto): Promise<any> { } In this scenario, the type of @Bod() petDetails defaults to plain/any instead of the declared type of PostPetDto. What is the recommen ...

I am struggling to understand the significance of the $ symbol in this particular context

I came across the following snippet in a book I've been reading: `images/${Date.now()}.jpg` The curly brackets used here signify 'out of string', but I'm unsure about the meaning of $... P.S. Honestly, I didn't want to ask a que ...

Ways to eliminate additional data points on the x-axis in Highcharts

I'm currently using Highcharts to plot data for specific ID's, but I'm experiencing a display issue where extra data points are showing up on the x-axis. I only want to show certain data points on the x-axis and am not sure how to remove the ...

What is the correct way to specify the data type for the useState hook when I intend to store an array of objects?

My dilemma involves storing an array of objects using the useState hook, but I am struggling with the syntax required to describe the expected type. The type that I want to store is Array<Updates>. Below is the code I have: const [messages, setMessa ...

What is the best way to implement a late-binding clone method in TypeScript classes?

Creating a simple Cloneable interface for all my data classes in JavaScript is a straightforward task. However, when it comes to typing it properly in TypeScript, things get a bit more complex. Currently, I am putting together a solution like this: class ...