Creating a service instance within the constructor in Angular 2

I'm new to Angular 2 and Typescript and I'm trying to wrap my head around DI. One thing that has been tripping me up is the way variables referring to a service are typed into the constructor in all the code examples I've come across. Why is this necessary? Can't we declare them outside of the constructor but still inside the class?

Take for example the code snippet from the Tour of Heroes on the Angular website:

import { Component, OnInit } from '@angular/core';
import { Hero } from './hero';
import { HeroService } from './hero.service';

@Component({
    moduleId: module.id,
    selector: 'my-dashboard',
    templateUrl: `dashboard.component.html`,
    styleUrls: ['dashboard.component.css']
})
export class DashboardComponent implements OnInit {

    heroes: Hero[] = [];

    constructor(private heroService: HeroService) { }

    ngOnInit(): void {
        this.heroService.getHeroes()
            .then(heroes => this.heroes = heroes.slice(1, 5));
    }
}

If I try to declare heroService outside of the constructor like this, the app throws numerous errors.

export class DashboardComponent implements OnInit {

    heroes: Hero[] = [];

    constructor() { }

    private heroService: HeroService;

    ngOnInit(): void {
        this.heroService.getHeroes()
            .then(heroes => this.heroes = heroes.slice(1, 5));
    }
}

From what I can gather, declaring it outside of the constructor does not instantiate an instance of the service class HeroService, but why is that? (Is it something specific to Angular or TypeScript?) In this example, Hero is also a class (albeit not a service class, but still a class!), and we have declared heroes: Hero[] = []; outside the constructor without any issues.

Answer №1

Angular's Dependency Injection system examines the constructor parameters to determine which providers should be passed when creating a new instance of a class (whether it be a service, component, directive, or pipe).

This means that:

  • Dependency injection is only applicable to classes instantiated by DI

  • Only constructor parameters are taken into account for injection

Answer №2

The method you are describing involves property (setter) injection, which is technically feasible but generally discouraged and viewed as a poor practice.

To gain a better understanding, it is recommended to explore constructor injection and why it is favored over alternative injection methods like property injection.

Angular appears to limit the use of other injection types in order to promote best practices, hence restricting usage outside of constructors.

You can refer to this document by Angular 1 for further insights on this topic. Although it pertains to an earlier version, the concepts discussed are fundamental and not specific to any particular framework or language.

Additionally, keep in mind that defining a variable with private in Typescript's constructor automatically generates a corresponding property. Therefore, when declared in the constructor, Angular injects it accordingly and Typescript creates a field as demonstrated in your recent snippet, initializing it from the constructor parameter.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Display HTML tags on an HTML page using TypeScript

In my angular application, I encountered an issue where I needed to call one component inside another component. Initially, I was able to achieve this by simply using the second component's selector in the HTML of the first component: html: <div&g ...

How to set an attribute within ngFor in Angular 2

Encountering an issue trying to dynamically set the selected attribute within an ngFor loop. The current code is not working as expected due to browser quirks where even checked=false would still be considered as checked... Hence, the return value must be ...

How does the Rx subscribe function maintain its context without the need to explicitly pass it along

Currently, I am utilizing Rx with Angular2 and making use of the Subscribe method. What intrigues me is that the callbacks of the method are able to retain the context of the component (or class) that initiated it without needing any explicit reference pas ...

Error: In Angular and Typescript, the function this.$resource is not recognized

I keep encountering a TypeError: this.$resource is not a function. Below is the code snippet causing the issue: export class DataAccessService implements IDataAccessService { static $inject = ["$resource"]; constructor(private $resource: ng ...

Display the concealed mat-option once all other options have been filtered out

My current task involves dynamically creating multiple <mat-select> elements based on the number of "tag types" retrieved from the backend. These <mat-select> elements are then filled with tag data. Users have the ability to add new "tag types, ...

What is the best way to see if a variable is present in TypeScript?

I am facing an issue with my code that involves a looping mechanism. Specifically, I need to initialize a variable called 'one' within the loop. In order to achieve this, I first check if the variable exists and only then proceed to initialize it ...

What is the best way to generate an index.ts file in an Angular 14 shared library that exports all contents from a specific directory?

Utilizing Angular 14 for my shared library project, the structure looks like this: + projects + my-lib - package.json + src - public-api.ts + lib + helpers - index.ts ...

Error in Jest Testing: An unexpected character '@' was encountered

Encountering issues with NuxtJS Jest tests and attempting to build a Nuxt app to test URL's due to route name errors in some components. Here is the code snippet I tried: beforeAll(async () => { nuxt = new Nuxt({ ...config, server: { port: 3001 } ...

Looking for a specific string within all attributes of an object using Angular 2

How can I search for a specific string in all properties of an object using Angular 2 with TypeScript? I have a table displaying an array of customers and I want to implement a search feature where the user can input a value and find a customer that match ...

Encountering a 500 Error in an Angular 6 application on a .NET Core 2.1.1 framework when deployed

After upgrading my project from the old Visual Studio SPA Angular template to the latest version, including moving from Angular 5 to Angular 6 and webpack to angular-cli, I encountered an issue. While everything works fine in development, I'm facing a ...

Various types of generics within an object

Is there a way to achieve different types for the nested K type within a type like MyType? Here's an example: type Config<K> = { value: K; onUpdate: (value: K) => void; } type MyType<F extends string> = { [K in F]: <V>() =& ...

Attempting to deploy an Angular 9 web project within Visual Studio

Starting my first Angular project has been a smooth process so far. After successfully running "npm start" without any errors, I encountered some issues when launching the application from Visual Studio. Despite sending the same commands, I consistently ...

The concept of Nested TypeScript Map Value Type

Similar to Nested Typescript Map Type, this case involves nesting on the "value" side. Typescript Playground const mapObjectObject: Map<string, string | Map<string, string>> = new Map(Object.entries({ "a": "b", &quo ...

Typescript: The type 'T' fails to meet the requirement of being an 'object'

Ever since I installed a package along with its @types package, I've been encountering an issue with the following code: https://i.stack.imgur.com/rrRhW.png This is the error message that I'm receiving: https://i.stack.imgur.com/BfNmP.png The ...

Angular's reactive form feature does not have built-in support for ngIf

I am facing an issue with a form group where I need to display one of the required inputs using ngIf. However, even if this input does not exist, the form control still checks it and returns that the form is not valid. Here is my code: HTML: <form [form ...

Having trouble retrieving an object property in HTML or TypeScript within an Angular framework?

export class ComponentOne { array_all_items: Array<{ page_details: any }> = []; array_page_details: Array<{ identifier: number, title: string }> = []; initial_item: Array<{ identifier: number, title: string }> = [ { ...

Ways to update the component's state externally

I'm new to Next.js (and React) and I'm attempting to update the state of a component from outside the component. Essentially, I am conditionally rendering HTML in the component and have a button inside the component that triggers a function to se ...

issue with duplicating DOM element using function

My situation is unique from the one described in this post. The code mentioned there is not functioning as expected when clicking the clone button. I have even provided a video explanation of how that code works. Unfortunately, I haven't received any ...

Customize the size of data points on your Angular 2 chart with variable

In my Angular 2 application, I am utilizing ng2-charts to create a line chart. The chart functions properly, showing a change in color when hovering over a point with the mouse. However, I want to replicate this behavior manually through code. Upon clicki ...

I'm attempting to transfer information from a "blog" to "blogs", but encountering a hiccup in the process

I encountered the following issue: **Error1:** Cannot find a differ supporting object '[object Object]' of type 'object'. NgFor only supports binding to Iterables, such as Arrays. Did you mean to use the keyvalue pipe? **Error2:** this ...