Differences Between Angular 2 Reactive Forms and Template Forms

We are embarking on a new Angular 2 project and are deliberating on whether to opt for Reactive Forms or Template Forms. If you want to learn more, you can refer to this article: https://angular.io/guide/reactive-forms

From what I understand, the main advantage of Reactive Forms is that they are synchronous. However, since we are dealing with straightforward forms, I don't foresee any issues with using asynchronicity. At first glance, Reactive Forms seem to involve more overhead, requiring more code to achieve the same outcomes.

Could someone present a compelling scenario where using Reactive Forms would be preferable over the more straightforward Template Forms?

Answer №1

https://i.sstatic.net/HZQlS.png

I recently curated this slide in my Forms course on Pluralsight. While some points may spark debate, it's worth noting that I collaborated with a member of the Angular team who played a key role in developing Forms.

Answer №2

One of the main benefits of template driven design lies in its simplicity. With a minimal amount of code in the controller, most of the logic is handled within the template. This approach is particularly well-suited for straightforward forms that don't require extensive programming behind the scenes.

However, every form comes with its own set of state variables that can be modified by various user interactions. It falls to the developer to carefully manage and safeguard this state to prevent any potential corruption, which can become quite challenging with larger forms and can lead to the introduction of bugs.

Alternatively, when additional logic is necessary, particularly if testing is on the agenda, the reactive model driven design offers a more robust solution. By unit testing the form validation logic, developers can instantiate the class, manipulate the form controls, and run a series of tests. This becomes essential for the design and upkeep of complex software. On the downside, the reactive model driven design can be more complex to implement.

While it is possible to blend aspects of both design types, doing so may bring about the drawbacks associated with each approach.

For further insight and practical examples showcasing both design methodologies, check out the following resource: Introduction to Angular Forms - Template Driven vs Model Driven or Reactive Forms

Answer №3

These two methods may seem different from the outside. However, when looking closely at reactive forms, the setup is quite similar. In app.module.ts, reactive forms are initialized as follows:

import { ReactiveFormsModule } from '@angular/forms';

imports: [BrowserModule, ReactiveFormsModule],

Then, in your parent.component.ts file:

import { FormGroup, FormControl, Validators } from '@angular/forms';

cardForm = new FormGroup({
  name: new FormControl('', [
    Validators.required,
    Validators.minLength(3),
    Validators.maxLength(5),
  ]), 

});

cardForm represents an instance of FormGroup. This form needs to be connected to the form itself.

<form [formGroup]="cardForm" (ngSubmit)="onSubmit()"></form>

This specifies that the form will be managed by "cardForm". Inside each input element of the form, a controller is added to listen for any changes and pass those changes to "cardForm".

<form [formGroup]="cardForm" (ngSubmit)="onSubmit()">
      <app-input label="Name" [control]="cardForm.get('name')"> </app-input>
 </form>


 cardForm.get('name')=  new FormControl('initValue', [
                           Validators.required,
                           Validators.minLength(3),
                           Validators.maxLength(5),
                           ]), 

In essence, FormControl instances are placed within the input elements. They listen for all changes and report them to the FormGroup instance. The setup of FormGroup and FormControl is explicitly done in the class component.

On the other hand, when working with template forms, there is no need to set up anything in the parent.component.ts file. The code is written inside the parent.component.html file. Angular still creates a FormGroup and handles the form through it behind the scenes. In app.module.ts:

  import { FormsModule } from '@angular/forms';

  imports: [BrowserModule, FormsModule],

No code is written for the FormGroup and FormControl. The setup happens in the template file:

 <form (ngSubmit)="onSubmit()" #emailForm="ngForm">

#emailForm creates a reference to the "FormGroup" that is created behind the scenes. This allows access to properties like "touched" and "valid". Input elements are then placed inside the form:

  <input
    type="email"
    required
    name="email"
    [(ngModel)]="email"
    #emailControl="ngModel"
  />
  • ngModel is a directive that instructs Angular to track the value in this input. It adds event handlers to the input element.

  • [(ngModel)] represents two-way binding, combining property binding and event handling syntax. If the value of "email" in the class changes, the input value is updated, and vice versa. The "email" property is defined in the class component.

        export class AppComponent {
        email: string; // [(ngModel)] communicates with this
        onSubmit() {
        console.log(this.email);
      }
     } 
    
  • #emailControl serves as a reference to the input control. The name can be customized as needed.

    emailControl===emailForm.controls.email
    

In the template form, #emailForm represents the FormGroup, while #emailControl represents the FormControl.

  • In reactive forms, validation logic is explicitly set within the FormControl. In template forms, the inclusion of "required" in the input element automatically assigns it to Validator.required.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Scale the cylinder in Three.js from a specific point

Can a cylinder be resized along the Y-axis starting from a particular point? Instead of the cylinder expanding from its center in both directions to the new scale, is it possible for it to grow upwards/downwards only like a bar chart? Current code : fu ...

Any tips on loading all KML files from a folder with geoXML3?

In my JavaScript code, I am using geoXML3 to successfully load, parse, and display the KML file below. var geoXml = new geoXML3.parser({map: map, singleInfoWindow: true}); geoXml.parse('/myapp/resources/kml/fileone.kml'); However, the / ...

Experiencing excessive delay in loading data into the DOM following a successful response from a service in AngularJS

I am facing a challenge in loading a large set of data into an HTML table. To begin, you need to click on a button: <a ng-click="get_product()">load data</a> This button triggers a function called get_product: $scope.get_product = func ...

Unlock real-time alerts with the power of JavaScript and PHP!

I am currently working on enhancing my skills in javascript. I have a basic idea of what I want to achieve. My goal is to create an automated javascript function that accesses a php page. This php page will create an array of new notifications for the ja ...

Troubleshooting the ngcc error in StackBlitz when using MatTableModule from Material Design

Upon comparing my project config with this sample, I am puzzled by the error message that keeps popping up: An error in turbo_modules/@angular/[email protected]/table/table-module.d.ts (8:22) It seems that MaterialModule is trying to export something ...

JavaScript - Uncaught ReferenceError: WebSocket is undefined

Looking at just the client side API (since each server side language has its own API), this code snippet demonstrates opening a connection, setting up event listeners for connect, disconnect, and message events, sending a message to the server, and closing ...

What is the best way to ensure uniform height for all div elements using JavaScript?

I'm working on creating a tool that can find the tallest element among a group of elements and then adjust the height of all elements to match the tallest one. Within this tool, I'm attempting to pass a selector to a JQuery method that is locate ...

Utilizing JavaScript to assign class names to dynamically created elements from objects

I specialize in javascript and am working on adding the CSS class .is-slideUp to each card__item element created from a data object, in order to achieve a sliding-up animation effect. Although the .is-slideUp class name appears in the console, it does not ...

Establish an enumeration using universally recognized identifiers

I have a JavaScript function that requires a numerical input, as well as some predefined constants at the top level: var FOO = 1; var BAR = 2; The function should only be called using one of these constants. To ensure type safety in TypeScript, I am att ...

Setting the color of an element using CSS based on another element's style

I currently have several html elements embedded within my webpage, such as: <section id="top-bar"> <!-- html content --> </section> <section id="header"> <!-- html content --> </section> <div id="left"> &l ...

What are the alternative methods to execute a React.js application without using react-scripts?

After creating my React.js app using the command below: npx create-react-app my-app I'm now looking to modify the package.json script section to run the app without react-scripts. How can I achieve this? "scripts": { "start&quo ...

Changing a 64-bit Steam ID to a 32-bit account ID

Is there a way to convert a 64-bit Steam ID to a 32-bit account ID in Node.js? According to Steam, you should take the first 32 bits of the number, but how exactly can this be done in Node? Would using BigNumber be necessary to handle the 64-bit integer? ...

Step-by-step guide on creating a login functionality in Node using the Mean.io stack

I'm currently working on a web app using the MEAN.io stack. I have completed the frontend part with HTML, CSS, and AngularJS along with some logic. Now, I am looking to implement server-side login functionality, but I'm unsure where to begin sinc ...

Leveraging x-template in VueJS to create a sub-component within a larger component

I'm having trouble understanding how to properly use x-template for a subcomponent within a VueJS component. My component, CategoryNav.vue, has a template that uses an x-template to display a list. However, when I render the page, the component creat ...

Establishing fixed values in an angular2 component

Is it possible in angular 2 to initialize values within the HTML view of a component that has already been rendered in PHP? //html page: <dropdown [(options)]="['Available', 'Busy', 'Away', 'Offline']"></dr ...

Can someone guide me on finding my staticwebapp.config.json within Azure Devops for deploying Azure Static Web Apps during a release?

After setting up a pipeline to build the artifact for my Angular application, I encountered an issue with deployment where specific URLs would redirect me to a 404 error page. This problem seems to be related to the configuration in staticwebapp.config.jso ...

Using Jasmine to simulate an if/else statement in Angular/Typescript unit testing

After making a minor change to an existing function, it has been flagged as new code during our quality checks. This means I need to create a unit test specifically for the new 4 lines of code. The challenge is that there was never a unit test in place for ...

The getelementbyid function is unable to locate the specified button identifier

As I dive into the world of Javascript, I wanted to create a simple input form with a corresponding response field on my website. However, I encountered an issue where using a basic submit button caused the page to refresh and erase the textfields before ...

Angular UI-Grid encountering difficulties in rendering secure HTML content

I'm having trouble displaying server-generated HTML in UI-Grid. Specifically, I want to show HTML content in my column header tooltips, but no matter what I try, the HTML is always encoded. Here's an example to illustrate the issue: var app = an ...

Typescript error: The value "X" cannot be assigned to this type, as the properties of "Y" are not compatible

Disclaimer: I am relatively new to Angular2 and typescript, so please bear with me for any errors. The Challenge: My current task involves subtracting a start date/time from an end date/time, using the result in a formula for my calculation displayed as " ...