Error message in Visual Studio 2017: Identical name 'URLs' declared twice in

In our Visual Studio 2017 project, we have multiple TypeScript files that define a URLs class. Each file contains different implementations of the class to change site URLs based on the specific use case:

customer/urls.ts

namespace Portal {
    export class URLs {
        static homePage(): string { return "/customer"; }
    }
}

supplier/urls.ts

namespace Portal {
    export class URLs {
        static homePage(): string { return "/supplier"; }
    }
}

This approach leads to a "Duplicate identifier 'URLs'" error in Visual Studio 2017. The IDE assumes that all TypeScript files will be included in the webpage, causing the conflict. However, since only one file is pulled in for any given page, there is no actual duplicate identifier in the browser. How can this error be resolved in Visual Studio or is there a valid reason behind it?

Answer №1

This situation arises from a combination of factors:

  1. Typescript namespaces, also known as "internal modules," contribute to the global namespace. Starting a file with a non-exported namespace declaration makes that identifier available globally. In contrast, modules (or "external modules") require explicit importing and exporting. Refer to this explanation for more details.

  2. If specific files are not explicitly included or excluded in your tsconfig.json, both definitions for Portal.URLs will be included. According to the tsconfig.json documentation:

In scenarios where "files" and "include" are not defined, the compiler includes all TypeScript (.ts, .d.ts, and .tsx) files within the directory and subdirectories unless specified otherwise using the "exclude" property.

Hence, the duplicate identifier error is caused by the compiler attempting to add the same declaration to the global namespace twice.

The appropriate solution depends on how the class is used and how the decision is made regarding which implementation to utilize.

One possible solution is to avoid namespaces entirely. Instead, you could define a URLs interface, import it where necessary, and then choose between a CustomerURLs or SupplierURLs implementation based on environmental variables or build configurations.

Alternatively, you could create a base tsconfig.json and use extends to generate separate configuration files like tsconfig.customer.json or tsconfig.supplier.json. In each individual file, exclude all **/urls.ts files except for the relevant one. However, this approach may not be very scalable, and its impact on VS's intellisense functionality is unclear.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Is it possible to transform a ReadonlyArray<any> into a standard mutable array []?

At times, when working with Angular functions and callbacks, they may return a ReadonlyArray. However, I prefer using arrays in the traditional way and don't want to use immutable structures like those in Redux. So, what is the best way to convert a ...

create an endless loop to animate in angular2

Is there a way to add iterations, or something similar to the ccs3 animation-iteration-count in Angular 2 animations? I've looked but can't find anything related. How can we apply an infinite play to the animation? Where should we include that o ...

React Component not displaying properly when used inside a map iteration

I am currently working on rendering multiple components using the .map method on an array with specific content. Although I can't find any errors in the console, the component is not appearing in the DOM as expected. I attempted to set subHeader to nu ...

What causes the error message "Expected ':' when utilizing null conditional in TypeScript?"

UPDATE: After receiving CodeCaster's comment, I realized the issue was due to me using TypeScript version 3.5 instead of 3.7+. It was surprising because these checks seemed to be working fine with other Angular elements, such as <div *ngIf="pa ...

Requiring Additional d3 Plugins in d3 v4 Extension: A guide

I am currently working on developing a d3 v4 plugin by following the guidelines provided at . My main objective is to be able to npm install the plugin and seamlessly use it within an Angular 2/4 component. The repository for my project can be found here: ...

Creating a specialized Typescript deep partial type for specific attributes

I have a challenge in writing a utility type that takes an object as a generic parameter and a union of strings to recursively make specific properties optional. While it may sound simple, I encountered an issue that I need assistance with. Here is the uti ...

Select a random class from an array of classes in JavaScript

I have a collection of Classes: possibleEnemies: [ Slime, (currently only one available) ], I am trying to randomly pick one of them and assign it to a variable like this (all classes are derived from the Enemy class): this.enemy = new this.possibleEn ...

What could be the reason behind the for loop not running within a typescript function?

My confusion lies in the for loop within this function that seems to never run. Each console log is set up to return a specific value, but the looping action doesn't trigger. Can someone provide insight into what might be causing this issue? export fu ...

Typescript typings for child model/collection structures

I have encountered an issue while trying to implement a Model/Collection pattern with various typings. Both the Model and Collection classes have a method called serialize(). When this method is called on the Collection, it serializes all the Model(s) with ...

Issue with Angular ngFor not updating radio button value when ngModel is set

Hello, I am fairly new to working with Angular and could really use some assistance with a problem I've run into. Essentially, I am receiving an array of objects from an API like this: [{name: "abc", score: 2},{name: ""def, score: ...

Problem with extending a legacy JavaScript library using TypeScript

Can someone assist me with importing files? I am currently utilizing @types/leaflet which defines a specific type. export namespace Icon { interface DefaultIconOptions extends BaseIconOptions { imagePath?: string; } class Default exte ...

Using React MUI Select in combination with react-hook-form does not seem to be compatible with Cypress testing

Within my React application, I have implemented a form that includes a dropdown select. Depending on the option selected from the dropdown, different input fields are rendered. const [templateType, setTemplateType] = useState(""); const { regi ...

Angular Custom Validator Error (Validation function must either return a Promise or an Observable)

I created a personalized validator for the phone field but I'm encountering an issue The validator should be returning either a Promise or an Observable. Basically, I just want to check if the phone number is less than 10 characters. HTML Cod ...

Angular's Validator directive offers powerful validation capabilities for reactive forms

Referenced from: This is the approach I have experimented with: custom-validator.directive.ts import { Directive } from '@angular/core'; import { AbstractControl, FormControl, ValidationErrors } from '@angular/forms'; @Directive({ ...

Why is my React component not being updated with Routes?

I'm new to using react-router and I'm struggling with it for the first time. Here is the code snippet: App.tsx import React from 'react'; logo = require('./logo.svg'); const { BrowserRouter as Router, Link, Route } = require ...

Encountered a Solana Error while handling Instruction 2: custom program error with code 0x1000078

While attempting to create an AMM Pool using the 'ammCreatePool.ts' script from the raydium-sdk repository, I encountered the following error message. I executed the script directly with ts-node src/ammCreatePool.ts and made modifications so that ...

Book of Tales displaying Emotion Styling upon initial load only

I'm currently working with the styled api provided by emotion in order to create a custom styled button. const StyledButton = styled(Button)` background-color: ${theme.palette.grey['800']}; width: 50; height: 50; &:hover { ba ...

Develop a novel object framework by merging correlated data with identical keys

I am trying to organize the related data IOrderData by grouping them based on the productId and brandId. This will help create a new array of objects called IOrderTypeData, where the only difference between the objects is the delivery type. Each product id ...

Resolving issues with Typescript declarations for React Component

Currently utilizing React 16.4.1 and Typescript 2.9.2, I am attempting to use the reaptcha library from here. The library is imported like so: import * as Reaptcha from 'reaptcha'; Since there are no type definitions provided, building results ...

How can the service receive the return value from a subscribed subject?

I have a question about whether it is possible to retrieve the value from a call to Subject.next(). Can you suggest any other approaches on how to receive a response in the given scenario? My current situation involves a notify service that is used throug ...