Exploring the intricacies of the let and const modifiers in ngFor loops

I encountered some unexpected behavior with the const keyword while using it in an Angular 2 *ngFor loop.

Let's consider the following base code:

interface Foo {
    name: string;
    list: string[];
}

@Component({ ... })
class FooComponent() {
    @Input foo: Foo;
    @Input list: string[];
}

Using const in the template below would work fine during compilation and runtime.

<li *ngFor="const element of list"> ... </li>

However, if we introduce the SlicePipe, using const will result in a TypeScript compiler error at the | token.

<li *ngFor="const element of list | slice:0:3"> ... </li>
                                  ^ unexpected token
<li *ngFor="let element of list | slice:0:3"><!-- completely fine --></li>

The error occurs because the pipe is applied to the element and not the list when const is used, which seems a bit strange.

Further complications arise when attempting to iterate over Foo.list using const.

<li *ngFor="const element of foo.list"> ... </li>
                                ^ unexpected token
<li *ngFor="let element of foo.list"><!-- completely fine --></li>

So, when should we use const and why do we need to use let in these scenarios?

Answer №1

When working with Angular templates, it's important to understand that the let keyword used within the *ngFor directive does not follow the same semantics as JavaScript. Instead, it is a specific syntax unique to Angular. Here's why const doesn't behave as expected:

  1. Angular's Unique Syntax: As pointed out by @pkozlowski-opensource, the code within *ngFor is not standard JavaScript or TypeScript syntax, but rather a specific micro-syntax created by Angular. The goal is not to replicate JavaScript syntax entirely within templates.

  2. Template Variables as Properties: As noted by @trotyl, all template context "variables" are treated as properties, not traditional variables. This means the distinction between JavaScript let and const semantics does not directly translate here. It's a deliberate decision by the Angular team.

In conclusion, when working with lists in Angular templates, it's best to use let as per Angular's design choices, which prioritize clarity and avoid potential confusion. Personally, I lean towards React and the more familiar JS / ES6 syntax.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Listening for keypress events on a div element using React

I'm currently struggling with implementing a keypress listener on a component. My goal is to have my listener activated whenever the "ESC" key is pressed, but I can't seem to figure it out. The function component I am working with is quite stra ...

To update the scopes for Firebase GoogleAuthProvider and remove the email scope, while adding only the youtube.readonly scope,

After experimenting with Firebase and Angular 2, I have managed to implement user validation in my app and retrieve YouTube Channel information. Below is the code snippet I am using: return new Promise((resolve, reject) => { let provider = new ...

Can you explain the distinction between the controls and get methods used with the FormGroup object?

I have encountered an interesting issue with 2 lines of code that essentially achieve the same outcome: this.data.affiliateLinkUrl = this.bookLinkForm.controls['affiliateLinkUrl'].value; this.data.affiliateLinkUrl = this.bookLinkForm.get(' ...

Unable to download tsc through the Terminal on OS X

Struggling to install tsc, encountering numerous errors upon running it. Reinstalled node and npm multiple times, adjusted npm flag to verbose, here's the output: Mitch:~ mitch$ npm install -g typescript npm info it worked if it ends with ok ... Fe ...

Having troubles with Angular 2 subscription functionality?

I am attempting to launch a modal window that has its template and logic in a separate component. My goal is to accomplish this by subscribing to an observable, but I am encountering issues. Below is my code: Method within the component where I want to tr ...

Incorporating Ionic v3 with the latest StripeJS/Stripe Elements version 7.26.0

I have encountered two separate issues while trying to integrate the new version of Stripe into my Ionic v3 app. (Please refrain from suggesting an upgrade to Ionic v5, as it is currently not feasible for our team at this time!) Within my ionDidLoad funct ...

When a webpage reload triggers a 404 error, my website's iframe with the source "videoUrl | sanitize" will display

I am attempting to retrieve a videoUrl from a database and set it to the iframe [attr.src] in order to display a YouTube video. It is imperative that the data originates from the database, as there are limitations preventing us from directly uploading and ...

Testing a function that involves multiple HTTP requests through unit testing

I am struggling with writing a unit test for a function that indirectly triggers multiple HTTP requests. The service I am testing has the following structure: /* content.service.ts */ import { Injectable } from "@angular/core" import { ApiService } from ...

What is the best way to assign an HTML string to the DOM and connect it with an object?

In my angular HTML component template, I have the following markup: <div *ngIf="htmlTemplate && jsonObj" [innerHTML]="htmlTemplate"></div> The jsonObj variable is retrieved from an endpoint and looks like this: { fi ...

Dealing with the error "Type 'date[]' is not assignable to type '[date?, date?]' in a React hook

I'm attempting to assign a date range but encountering an error that states: Type 'Date[]' is not assignable to type '[Date?, Date?]'. Types of property 'length' are incompatible. Type 'number' is not assignab ...

Issue encountered while trying to determine the Angular version due to errors in the development packages

My ng command is displaying the following version details: Angular CLI: 10.2.0 Node: 12.16.3 OS: win32 x64 Angular: <error> ... animations, cdk, common, compiler, compiler-cli, core, forms ... language-service, material, platform-browser ... platfor ...

Unable to successfully import Node, JS, or Electron library into Angular Typescript module despite numerous attempts

I'm still getting the hang of using stack overflow, so please forgive me if my question isn't formulated correctly. I've been doing a lot of research on both stack overflow and Google, but I can't seem to figure out how to import Electr ...

Unable to alter fxFlex property within Component using "setAttribute('fxFlex', '25%')" does not function properly in Angular 6

Currently, I am utilizing the flexLayout module to create responsive divs in my Angular application. You can find more information about flexLayout at https://github.com/angular/flex-layout and also at https://alligator.io/angular/flex-layout/. const nav ...

What is the best way to inform TypeScript that the output of the subscribe method should be recognized as an array containing elements of type

I'm facing a challenge understanding types while working with noImplicitAny and typescript in Angular 6. The compiler is indicating that the type of result is Object, even though I am certain it should be an array of type Manufacturer. Unable to assig ...

Encountering a type error with gatsby-plugin-dark-mode in a Typescript Gatsby setup

Issue with Layout warning in index.tsx when hovering: (alias) const Layout: ({ children }: Props) => JSX.Element import Layout Type '{ children: Element[]; }' is missing the following properties from type 'Props': theme, >toggle ...

Guide for retrieving a user object from an HTTP request

I am looking to retrieve only the user object from the request. public async getUserByHash(hash: IHash) { this.logger.log('Hash for check email accessed'); const user = await this.hashRepository.findOne({ select: ['id', ...

Managing null values in RxJS map function

I'm facing a scenario where my Angular service retrieves values from an HTTP GET request and maps them to an Observable object of a specific type. Sometimes, one of the properties has a string value, while other times it's null, which I want to d ...

Having trouble invoking the "done" function in JQuery following a POST request

I am currently working on a Typescript project that utilizes JQuery, specifically for uploading a form with a file using the JQuery Form Plugin. However, after the upload process, there seems to be an issue when trying to call the "done" function from JQue ...

When sending a Post Request in Angular to a Spring Boot backend, a status code of 500 is

Encountering a 500 status code error while making the request below: createPost(postPayload: CreatePostPayload): Observable<any> { return this.http.post('http://localhost:8080/api/posts/', postPayload); } The request is successful wh ...

Exploring the Scope of a Directive within an HTML Element's Event Handler

I devised a custom Directive for utilizing an element as a 'dropzone' with native HTML Drag & Drop functionality. Custom Directive Source Code import { Directive, ElementRef, OnInit, Output, EventEmitter, ViewChild } from '@angular/co ...