Failure in retrieving values from AngularFire2 Subscribe

Question

Failure in retrieving values from AngularFire2 Subscribe

I am encountering an issue with the code in my authService

    constructor(
    private afAuth: AngularFireAuth,
    private db: AngularFireDatabase,
    private router: Router
  ) {
    this.authState = afAuth.authState;
    this.authState.subscribe((user: firebase.User) => {
        this.authState = user;
    });
    if ( this.authenticated ) {
      // this.router.navigate([`/content`]);
    }
  }

  // Returns true if user is logged in
  get authenticated(): any {
    return this.authState;
  }

When I call the get authenticated method, it returns undefined:

COMPONENT

    constructor(
    private auth: AuthService
  ) {
      this.currentUser = this.auth.authenticated;
  }
showUser() {
    console.log(this.currentUser.uid);
  }

I am looking for assistance on resolving this issue, any suggestions?

angular typescript firebase rxjs observable

Answer 1

Answer №1

Typically, what occurs is considered normal. The console.log function operates synchronously, while the content within the subscription runs asynchronously. Therefore, even though the console.log appears after the .subscribe method, it may be executed faster in reality. This explains why

console.log( this.authState.uid );

outputs undefined.

In addition, it is recommended to refrain from including any logic in the contructor.

It would be more beneficial to have the .subscribe in OnInit() and attempt to access the this.authState in the AfterViewInit() lifecycle.

One last point to mention, you can also store the subscription created in OnInit and utilize .unsubscribe in OnDestroy :)

Answer 2

Typically, what occurs is considered normal. The console.log function operates synchronously, while the content within the subscription runs asynchronously. Therefore, even though the console.log appears after the .subscribe method, it may be executed faster in reality. This explains why

console.log( this.authState.uid );

outputs undefined.

In addition, it is recommended to refrain from including any logic in the contructor.

It would be more beneficial to have the .subscribe in OnInit() and attempt to access the this.authState in the AfterViewInit() lifecycle.

One last point to mention, you can also store the subscription created in OnInit and utilize .unsubscribe in OnDestroy :)

Answer 3

Answer №2

What is your goal? What are you looking for and why?

I am still uncertain about the rationale behind this requirement. However, it appears to be related to a lifecycle hook issue (you can refer to the documentation here).

Try implementing it in the following manner with your component:

export class *YOUR_COMPONENT* implements OnInit {

   private authenticatedUser$: Subscription; // import rxjs/Subscription
   private authenticatedUser: User; // import firebase/app

   constructor(private auth: AuthService) {
     this.authenticatedUser$ = this.auth.getAuthenticatedUser().subscribe((user: User) => {
      // Save the Firebase user in the 'authenticatedUser' variable here
      this.authenticatedUser = user;
   });

   ngOnInit() {
      // Check if the user is logged in..
      if(this.authenticatedUser) {
        // Write your logic here when user is logged in
      }
   }

   ....}

Here is an example of your authService:

export class AuthService {

     constructor(private afAuth: AngularFireAuth) { //import angularfire2/auth/auth
       // Constructor is empty
     });

     getAuthenticatedUser() {
       return this.auth.authState;
     }

   ....}

This approach should resolve the issue.

Answer 4

What is your goal? What are you looking for and why?

I am still uncertain about the rationale behind this requirement. However, it appears to be related to a lifecycle hook issue (you can refer to the documentation here).

Try implementing it in the following manner with your component:

export class *YOUR_COMPONENT* implements OnInit {

   private authenticatedUser$: Subscription; // import rxjs/Subscription
   private authenticatedUser: User; // import firebase/app

   constructor(private auth: AuthService) {
     this.authenticatedUser$ = this.auth.getAuthenticatedUser().subscribe((user: User) => {
      // Save the Firebase user in the 'authenticatedUser' variable here
      this.authenticatedUser = user;
   });

   ngOnInit() {
      // Check if the user is logged in..
      if(this.authenticatedUser) {
        // Write your logic here when user is logged in
      }
   }

   ....}

Here is an example of your authService:

export class AuthService {

     constructor(private afAuth: AngularFireAuth) { //import angularfire2/auth/auth
       // Constructor is empty
     });

     getAuthenticatedUser() {
       return this.auth.authState;
     }

   ....}

This approach should resolve the issue.

Answer 5

Answer №3

When working with AngularFireAuth.authState

, it's important to understand that it operates asynchronously as an Observable. If you're unfamiliar with Observables, you can learn more about them on the ReactiveX site.

In essence, the authState observable represents a sequence of values that unfold over time. It works asynchronously, meaning there is a delay in resolving its value, and it's lazy - requiring subscription to retrieve a value (which explains why your console.log isn't functioning outside).

If you find yourself needing access to the "current" value without being inside a subscribe block, I suggest using a BehaviorSubject. For further insight into subjects, refer to the ReactiveX documentation:

currentAuthState: BehaviorSubject<firebase.User|null|undefined>;

constructor(afAuth: AngularFireAuth) {
  this.currentAuthState = new BehaviorSubject(undefined);
  afAuth.authState.subscribe(this.currentAuthState);
}

With this setup, you can utilize this.currentAuthState.getValue() to check the current value, .subscribe for monitoring changes, employ various RxJS operators like map, do, switchMap, etc., and integrate async pipes in your view with

{{ (currentAuthState | async)?.email }}

.

The value will be undefined during loading, null when no user is logged in, and a firebase.User object when a user is authenticated.

Answer 6

When working with AngularFireAuth.authState

, it's important to understand that it operates asynchronously as an Observable. If you're unfamiliar with Observables, you can learn more about them on the ReactiveX site.

In essence, the authState observable represents a sequence of values that unfold over time. It works asynchronously, meaning there is a delay in resolving its value, and it's lazy - requiring subscription to retrieve a value (which explains why your console.log isn't functioning outside).

If you find yourself needing access to the "current" value without being inside a subscribe block, I suggest using a BehaviorSubject. For further insight into subjects, refer to the ReactiveX documentation:

currentAuthState: BehaviorSubject<firebase.User|null|undefined>;

constructor(afAuth: AngularFireAuth) {
  this.currentAuthState = new BehaviorSubject(undefined);
  afAuth.authState.subscribe(this.currentAuthState);
}

With this setup, you can utilize this.currentAuthState.getValue() to check the current value, .subscribe for monitoring changes, employ various RxJS operators like map, do, switchMap, etc., and integrate async pipes in your view with

{{ (currentAuthState | async)?.email }}

.

The value will be undefined during loading, null when no user is logged in, and a firebase.User object when a user is authenticated.

Failure in retrieving values from AngularFire2 Subscribe

Answer №1

Answer №2

Answer №3

Similar questions

What steps can be taken to avoid an abundance of JS event handlers in React?

Developing a custom camera system for a top-down RPG game using Javascript Canvas

Unable to inject basic service into component

When trying to access a property in Typescript that may not exist on the object

Retrieve a specific attribute from a collection of JSON objects and transfer it to a separate object

Is there a way to dynamically change the options in a dropdown menu using Angular?

How can a Vuejs front-end web application coexist on the same host/domain as my server?

Tips for refreshing the modified toggle in angular2

Retrieve the input type corresponding to the name and return it as a string using string template literals

Angular 6 - configuring HTTP requests, creating authentication services, implementing request interceptors

When trying to access the key value of a dynamically generated object, it returns as undefined

How can you programmatically toggle the visibility of a material table footer?

Utilizing React forwardRef with a functional component

Steps for updating the clientId and authority values in MSAL configuration after they have already been read

Divide the enhanced document into sections using TypeScript

When attempting to run the command 'ng serve', an error occurs stating "Permission denied"

Unable to pass a parameter through an Angular http.get request

"In the realm of RxJS, there are two potent events that hold the power to

Converting <reference path/> directive to ESM import: A step-by-step guide

Is it possible to define data types for the global context in cucumber?