Guide to Implementing Dependency Injection in Angular 2

When working with Angular Components written in TypeScript, it is possible to declare a class member (variable) as a parameter of the constructor. I am curious about the reason for doing so.
To clarify, take a look at the examples below. Both achieve the same result.

  • The first example follows the classic approach of defining a private member using dependency injection (common in most object-oriented languages).
  • The second example, if I understand correctly, showcases a specificity of TypeScript.

export class HeroListComponent implements OnInit {
    // declaring a private member
    private heroService:HeroService;

    // constructor signature
    constructor(service:HeroService) {
        // assigning the private member
        this.heroService = service;
    }
}

export class HeroListComponent implements OnInit {
    // private member declared within the constructor signature
    constructor(private heroService:HeroService) { }
}

In my view, the first syntax is more straightforward and comprehensible for those unfamiliar with TypeScript.
Therefore, I am questioning whether there is a specific rationale, aside from brevity (which becomes negligible once minified/obfuscated), for opting for the latter syntax. Thank you.

Answer №1

Update: This response addresses the initial question that has since been edited. In the earlier version, the second example was as follows:

export class HeroListComponent implements OnInit {
    // private member declared within constructor signature
    constructor(private service:HeroService) { 
        this.heroService = service;
    }
}

In the revised example, two class properties are actually being created. Both this.service and this.heroService will be present in the object.

The revised code is comparable to the following structure:

export class HeroListComponent implements OnInit {
    private heroService: HeroService;
    private service: HeroService;

    constructor(service:HeroService) {
        this.service = service;
        this.heroService = service;
    }
}

The approach in the modified example can be beneficial if both the class property and constructor parameter share the same name. For instance, if they could both be named heroService, then simplifying it would look like this:

export class HeroListComponent implements OnInit {
    constructor(private heroService:HeroService) {  }
}

This streamlines the code by eliminating redundancy, but whether or not it enhances clarity or readability may vary from person to person.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

When I include formControlName in Angular, the select dropdown loses its default value

I seem to be facing an issue with my select element. When I include the formControlName, the placeholder "-- Select Event Type --" no longer appears (even though it is still selected in the dropdown). If I remove it, the placeholder displays but the valida ...

Issues with page loading being halted by Angular2 child routes

Recently delving into Angular2, I am working on understanding routing, especially child routing. I have started my project based on the Angular2-seed project, focusing on setting up the routing structure. My routes are organized within functional modules ...

What is the procedure for a parent component to transmit HTML to a child component within Angular?

How can a parent component pass multiple ng-templates to a child component? For example, the parent component includes multiple ng-templates: <app-childcomponent> <ng-template>Item A</ng-template> <ng-template>Item B</n ...

Issue: "The argument provided must be a specific string, not a string or an array of strings."

Currently, I am tackling a Vue project that incorporates TypeScript and axios for handling API requests. While working on the Reset Password component, the resetPassword function within the auth.ts file appears as follows: resetPassword(password1: string, ...

Updating the `link` function to target a specific DOM element within an Angular 2 component

Angular 1 uses the link function in a directive to target DOM elements. link: function (scope, element, attr) { // do something with element[0], e.g. put generated graphics // inside the node } What is the equivalent feature in Angular 2? ...

Struggling to make Typescript recognize the css prop (emotion) when styling Material-UI components

I'm on a mission to set up a Typescript project with Material-UI v4.11.4 and implement emotion for styling in anticipation of the MUI v5 release. The aim is to integrate emotion into the project so developers can transition to using the new styling in ...

How to access elements by their class name in Angular

Recently, I encountered a situation with this specific span element: <span *ngFor="let list of lists[0].question; let i = index" id="word{{ i }}" (click)="changestyle($event)" class="highlight"> {{ list}} < ...

An uncommon token was found by Jest - import (Angular CLI 6)

Struggling to get jest installed and running in an angular/cli (v6) app on Mac. Despite trying various methods to set up jest, I keep encountering the following error: Test suite failed to run Jest encountered an unexpected token This usually me ...

Sending a Post request without using XHR (non-AJAX) in Angular

To integrate an external service into our Angular Application, it is necessary to meet one requirement. The external service comes with its own User Interface, which means we must redirect to that service by sending a pure HTTP Post request to the specifie ...

Property undefined with all alert points filled

According to the console, I am facing an issue while trying to route to the dashboard after logging in because the surname property is undefined. However, when I check my alerts, I can see that it is filled correctly at all times. login(surName: string, pa ...

I am unable to locate the module 'fs': I have exhausted all possible solutions to fix this problem

Attempting to delete a file from the local system using the unlink function, but encountering an error stating that it cannot find the module 'fs'. Below are some details on the relevant files: app.component.ts import * as fs from 'fs&apos ...

Guide to including spinner in React JS with TypeScript

I need help with adding a spinner to a React component. The issue I'm facing is that the spinner does not disappear after fetching data from an API. Can someone please point out what I am doing wrong? Here is the code snippet: import React, { useSta ...

Unexpected TypeScript issue: Unable to access the 'flags' property of an undefined entity

Upon creating a new project and running the serve command, I encountered the following error: ERROR in TypeError: Cannot read property 'flags' of undefined Node version: 12.14 NPM version: 6.13 Contents of package.json: { "name": "angular-t ...

How to effectively utilize TypeScript in a team environment using both Atom and VSCode?

Our team utilizes TypeScript with both Atom and VSCode as our editors, but we are facing challenges with the tsconfig.json file. VSCode is not recognizing the typings, causing the namespace for 'ng' (for Angular 1.x) to be unknown in VSCode. Wh ...

The interface 'HTMLIonIconElement' is not able to extend both 'IonIcon' and 'HTMLStencilElement' types at the same time

After upgrading my Angular Ionic app to use Angular v13 from Angular 12 with the command ng update, I encountered errors preventing me from running the application successfully. [ng] Error: node_modules/ionicons/dist/types/components.d.ts:66:15 - error TS2 ...

Unclear on the usage of "this" in arrow functions?

After going through various discussions and articles on this topic, I find myself still perplexed about the meaning of this in arrow functions. I've been encountering run-time errors with a code snippet similar to the following: export class Foo imp ...

Using Dropbox for seamless navigation

My navigation using Dropbox is not redirecting to the selected page as expected. Below, I have provided code and a demo for your reference. App Routing Module import { NgModule } from '@angular/core'; import { CommonModule } from '@angular ...

ERROR TS1086: A declaration of an accessor within an ambient context is not allowed. Accessor for firebaseUiConfig(): NativeFirebaseUIAuthConfig

Trying to create a Single Page Application with Angular/CLI 8. Everything was running smoothly locally until I tried to add Firebase authentication to the app. Upon compiling through Visual Studio Code, I encountered the following error message: ERROR in ...

Setting up a Node.js project in your local environment and making it

I need help installing my custom project globally so I can access it from anywhere in my computer using the command line. However, I've been struggling to make it work. I attempted the following command: npm install -g . and some others that I can&ap ...

What causes the generation of an outdated object when utilizing the let and new keywords to create a new object within a service function?

Hey there, looking for a basic auth authentication service in angular2? Here's the issue I'm facing: When a user logs in for the first time, everything works smoothly. However, if they try to log in with a different account for the second time, ...