Issue accessing member value in inherited class constructor in Typescript

My situation involves a class named A, with another class named B that is inherited from it.

class A {
    constructor(){
        this.init();
    }
    init(){}
}

class B extends A {
    private myMember = {value:1};
    constructor(){
        super();
    }
    init(){
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

const x = new B();

Upon running the code, an error pops up:

Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read property 'value' of undefined

How can I address this error?

It's evident that in this JavaScript scenario, the code invokes the init method before creating myMember. However, there must be a best practice or design pattern to make it function as intended.

Answer №1

In certain programming languages (like C#), code analysis tools may flag the use of virtual members inside constructors.

For Typescript, field initializations occur in the constructor after calling the base constructor. Even though field initializations are typically written near the field for convenience, looking at the generated code reveals a potential issue:

function B() {
    var _this = _super.call(this) || this; // base call here, field not set yet, init will be called
    _this.myMember = { value: 1 }; // field initialization
    return _this;
}

One solution is to separate the initialization logic from the constructor and call it externally:

class A {
    constructor(){
    }
    init(){}
}

class B extends A {
    private myMember = {value:1};
    constructor(){
        super();
    }
    init(){
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

const x = new B();
x.init();   

Alternatively, you can modify the constructor to include a parameter that controls whether to call init, avoiding its invocation within the derived class:

class A {
    constructor()
    constructor(doInit: boolean)
    constructor(doInit?: boolean){
        if(doInit || true)this.init();
    }
    init(){}
}

class B extends A {
    private myMember = {value:1};
    constructor()
    constructor(doInit: boolean)
    constructor(doInit?: boolean){
        super(false);
        if(doInit || true)this.init();
    }
    init(){
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

const x = new B();

A more hacky approach involves using setTimeout to defer initialization until after the current frame completes. This ensures the parent constructor finishes before invoking init, although there may be a brief period where the object is not fully initialized:

class A {
    constructor(){
        setTimeout(()=> this.init(), 1);
    }
    init(){}
}

class B extends A {
    private myMember = {value:1};
    constructor(){
        super();
    }
    init(){
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

const x = new B();
// x is not yet initialized, but will be shortly 

Answer №2

Due to the fact that the myMember property is accessed in the parent constructor (the init() function is called during the super() call), it becomes impossible to define it in the child constructor without encountering a race condition.

Fortunately, there exist several alternative strategies to tackle this issue.

init Hook

The init method can be treated as a hook that should not be invoked within the class constructor. Instead, it can be explicitly called:

new B();
B.init();

Alternatively, frameworks may implicitly invoke it as a part of the application lifecycle.

Static Property

If the property is meant to be a constant, consider using a static property.

This approach is highly efficient as static members serve this purpose. However, the syntax may appear less elegant since referencing a static property in child classes requires the use of this.constructor instead of the class name:

class B extends A {
    static readonly myMember = { value: 1 };

    init() {
        console.log((this.constructor as typeof B).myMember.value);
    }
}

Property Getter/Setter

A property descriptor with get/set syntax can be defined on the class prototype. For primitive constants, a getter suffices:

class B extends A {
    get myMember() {
        return 1;
    }

    init() {
        console.log(this.myMember);
    }
}

If the property is non-constant or non-primitive, employing getters and setters may seem more convoluted:

class B extends A {
    private _myMember?: { value: number };

    get myMember() {
        if (!('_myMember' in this)) {
            this._myMember = { value: 1 }; 
        }

        return this._myMember!;
    }
    set myMember(v) {
        this._myMember = v;
    }

    init() {
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

In-Place Initialization

An intuitive solution involves initializing the property where it is first accessed. If this occurs within the init method where this can be accessed before the B class constructor, initialization should take place there:

class B extends A {
    private myMember?: { value: number };

    init() {
        this.myMember = { value: 1 }; 
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}

Asynchronous Initialization

If the init method transitions to an asynchronous operation, the class must implement an API to manage initialization state, for instance, through promises:

class A {
    initialization = Promise.resolve();
    constructor(){
        this.init();
    }
    init(){}
}

class B extends A {
    private myMember = {value:1};

    init(){
        this.initialization = this.initialization.then(() => {
            console.log(this.myMember.value);
        });
    }
}

const x = new B();
x.initialization.then(() => {
    // class is initialized
})

While this approach may not be ideal for synchronous initializations like in this case, it proves beneficial for managing asynchronous routines.

Desugared Class

To work around limitations involving this prior to super in ES6 classes, converting the child class to a function may provide a solution:

interface B extends A {}
interface BPrivate extends B {
    myMember: { value: number };
}
interface BStatic extends A {
    new(): B;
}
const B = <BStatic><Function>function B(this: BPrivate) {
    this.myMember = { value: 1 };
    return A.call(this); 
}

B.prototype.init = function () {
    console.log(this.myMember.value);
}

This method is rarely recommended as additional typing is required in TypeScript. Moreover, it does not support native parent classes (TypeScript es6 and esnext target).

Answer №3

To avoid the issue of undefined, one possible solution is to utilize a getter/setter for myMember and handle the default value within the getter function. By doing so, you can maintain the existing structure with minimal modifications. Here's an example implementation:

class A {
    constructor() {
        this.setup();
    }
    setup() {}
}

class B extends A {
    private _myMember;
    
    constructor() {
        super();        
    }

    setup() {
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }

    get myMember() {
        return this._myMember || { value: 1 };
    }

    set myMember(val) {
        this._myMember = val;
    }
}

const instance = new B();

Answer №4

Consider this solution:

class A {
    constructor() {
        this.setup();
    }
    setup() { }
}

class B extends A {
    private myProperty = { 'number': 5 };
    constructor() {
        super();
        this.equip();
    }
    equip() {
        this.myProperty = { 'number': 5 };
        console.log(this.myProperty.number);
    }
}

const obj = new B();

Answer №5

One must always remember that the first command in any code should be 'super'. TypeScript can be thought of as more of a "javascript with documentation of types" rather than its own standalone language.

If you examine the transpiled code into .js, it becomes evident:

class A {
    constructor() {
        this.init();
    }
    init() {
    }
}
class B extends A {
    constructor() {
        super();
        this.myMember = { value: 1 };
    }
    init() {
        console.log(this.myMember.value);
    }
}
const x = new B();

Answer №6

Do you need to include init in class A?

While this approach works well, it is worth considering whether there are any specific requirements that may influence your decision:

class A {
  constructor(){}
  init(){}
}

class B extends A {
  private myMember = {value:1};
  constructor(){
      super();
      this.init();
  }
  init(){
      console.log(this.myMember.value);
  }
}

const x = new B();

Answer №7

It is common to delay the execution of the init() method until right before it is required by leveraging one of your getter methods.

Consider this example:

class FoodieParent {
  public init() {
    favoriteFood = "Salad";
  }

  public _favoriteFood: string;
  public set favoriteFood(val) { this._favoriteFood = val; }
  public get favoriteFood() {
    if (!this._favoriteFood) {
      this.init();
    }
    return this._favoriteFood;
  }

  public talkAboutFood() {
    // The init function is triggered just in time, thanks to "favoriteFood" being a getter
    console.log(`I love ${this.favoriteFood}`);
  }
}

// You can customize the init function without needing to manually call `init()` afterwards
class FoodieChild extends FoodieParent {
  public init() {
    this.favoriteFood = "Pizza"
  }
}

Answer №8

Here is an example code snippet:

 class Animal
{
     animalSound; 
    constructor() {

    }

    makeSound() {
        alert(this.animalSound.value);
    }
}

class Dog extends Animal {
    public animalSound = {value: "Bark"};

    constructor() {
        super();
    }
}

const myDog = new Dog;
myDog.makeSound();

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

The HTML slideshow is not automatically showing up as intended

I need to make a few adjustments to the picture slideshow on my website. Currently, all the pictures are displayed at once when you first visit the site, and it only turns into a slideshow when you click the scroll arrows. I want it to start as a slideshow ...

How can jQuery retrieve a string from a URL?

If I have a URL like http://www.mysite.com/index.php?=332, can jQuery be used to extract the string after ?=? I've searched on Google but only found information about Ajax and URL variables that hasn't been helpful. if (url.indexOf("?=") > 0) ...

Options for validating data in the igGrid component within igniteui-angular

I am currently working with an igniteui-angluar <ig-grid> and I am interested in validating cells using the checkValue event within the validatorOptions framework. Below is my configuration for the features section: HTML: <features> < ...

Tips for refining search criteria with a combination of checkbox and range slider in Angular 2

In an attempt to refine the results for the array "db," I have implemented three filters: price, duration, and category. I have experimented with using the filter() method to apply these filters. You can find the code I have worked on here: https://stack ...

When attempting to upload multiple images to my backend, I am consistently receiving an empty array as a result

I have developed an API on the backend that is designed to store images in the database. I have implemented a function for uploading these images, but unfortunately, I am encountering an issue where my database receives an empty array. Interestingly, when ...

Global Path in Helmet Content Security Policy is not functioning as expected

I recently implemented Helmet to establish content security policies for my web application using Express in the backend. The specific policies are as follows: const express = require("express"); const app = express(); const helmet = require('helmet&a ...

Vue.js - The table updates successfully, however, the data for the selected checkboxes remains unchanged

Encountered a persistent bug that is giving me some trouble. I have a table with rows that can be selected, and when a checkbox is checked, the total amount in the column should be calculated. However, whenever there is a change in the table data through ...

Easily done! Using JavaScript to generate a blinking cursor on a table

Working on a project to develop a dynamic version of the classic game Tic-Tac-Toe... However... Every table cell is displaying an irritating flashing cursor, almost like it's behaving as an input field. Any insights into why this is happening...? O ...

State values in React are found to be empty when accessed within a callback function triggered by

I have the following component structure: const [username, setUsername] = useState(''); const [password, setPassword] = useState(''); const handleUserKeyPress = useCallback((event) => { if (event.keyCode === 13) { doLogin( ...

Testing Material-UI's autocomplete with React Testing Library: a step-by-step guide

I am currently using the material-ui autocomplete component and attempting to test it with react-testing-library. Component: /* eslint-disable no-use-before-define */ import TextField from '@material-ui/core/TextField'; import Autocomplete from ...

While in the process of developing a React application, I have encountered the following challenge

PS F:\Programming Tutorials Videos\R Practice> npx create-react-app custom-hook npm ERR! code ENOTFOUND npm ERR! syscall getaddrinfo npm ERR! errno ENOTFOUND npm ERR! network request to https://registry.npmjs.org/create-react-app failed, reaso ...

The property 'innerHTML' cannot be assigned to null, as stated in Vue

I am dealing with two components that allow for editing JSON objects. Additionally, I have a button that toggles between these two components. Below is the HTML code snippet: <v-btn @click="switchConfigClicked">Switch config</v-btn> <h4 cla ...

Successive pressing actions

I am struggling to grasp a unique Javascript event scenario. To see an example of this, please visit http://jsfiddle.net/UFL7X/ Upon clicking the yellow box for the first time, I expected only the first click event handler to be called and turn the large ...

Unable to trigger dispatchEvent on an input element for the Tab key in Angular 5

In my pursuit of a solution to move from one input to another on the press of the Enter key, I came across various posts suggesting custom directives. However, I prefer a solution that works without having to implement a directive on every component. My a ...

Implementing Bootstrap in Angular 2 using vanilla JavaScript/ES6: A step-by-step guide

Currently, I am in the process of developing an Angular 2 application without TypeScript and facing difficulties with bootstrapping it as I cannot find any relevant examples. My app, which does not include the bootstrap() function, starts off like this: ...

There are occasional instances in Angular 6 when gapi is not defined

I am currently developing an app with Angular 6 that allows users to log in using the Google API. Although everything is working smoothly, I encounter a problem at times when the 'client' library fails to load and displays an error stating gapi i ...

adjust time in jQuery AJAX request when a button is clicked

I have the following code snippet that triggers when a button is clicked. When a user clicks on a button, I want to show a progress bar or waiting image in the browser for 5 seconds. How can I set a timeout and display the progress bar or waiting image wh ...

What causes the "node: bad option" error to occur when I include a custom flag in the nodejs command line within an Angular 9 application?

Seeking assistance with adding a custom flag to the npm start command in an Angular 9 project. The goal is to intercept proxy requests within the local server and manipulate data. However, encountering the "node: bad option" error consistently. Looking for ...

Next.js encounters an error when importing web3

Currently, I am utilizing next js and material ui to create a demo dapp for educational purposes. With metamask installed, I have successfully implemented a "connect to wallet" button. My issue arises when attempting to import the Web3 constructor. This i ...

What is the best way to showcase a user's input in a webpage using vanilla javascript

Struggling with creating functionalities for a simple calculator using vanilla.js. Able to display numbers on click but facing issues with multiple clicks and deletion of values. Trying to use addeventlistener but encountering a Type Error "addeventliste ...