Making the right choice: Class vs Interface in your Angular project

Today, I find myself pondering a question regarding classes and interfaces in Angular.

In my opinion, here is my take on the matter:

Interfaces are utilized in Typescript for type-checking purposes, existing until transpilation and disappearing in production. Interfaces also cannot be used for instantiation.

Classes originating from ES6 are also used for type checking, persisting after transpilation and generating code in production. Additionally, they can be used for instantiation.

Essentially, interfaces are beneficial if they are only needed for type-checking during development and not in production. Conversely, classes are ideal for situations where instantiation is required in the final product.

Am I correct in my understanding of classes and interfaces, or have I overlooked something?

Answer №1

Yes, you're right. Interfaces are useful for type checking, while classes are beneficial when you require both type checking and additional methods or logic.

Personally, my approach is to start with an interface and then introduce a class when I need methods. I always advocate for having an interface, even if not using a class, as it allows for easier passing around or injecting without the need to instantiate the class multiple times.

For example, consider this common pattern when implementing methods in TypeScript:

interface IPerson {
    firstName: string;
    lastName: string;
    age: number;
    getFullName(): string;
}
class Person implements IPerson {
    public firstName: string;
    public lastName: string;
    public age: number;
    constructor(firstName: string, lastName: string, age: number) {
        this.firstName = firstName;
        this.lastName = lastName;
        this.age = age;
    }
    getFullName(): string {
        return `${this.firstName} ${this.lastName}`
    }
}

const person: IPerson = new Person('John', 'Doe', 44);

By following this method, I avoid the need to directly import or inject the Person class unless necessary. Instead, I can work with the IPerson interface seamlessly, accessing properties and methods as needed.

Alternatively, if I only require a data contract without methods:

interface IPerson {
    firstName: string;
    lastName: string;
    age: number;
}

const person: IPerson = <IPerson>{
    firstName: 'John',
    lastName: 'Doe',
    age: 44
};

This approach still allows for dynamic creation of variables adhering to the interface, though lacking methods like getFullName.

In practice, I often use interfaces for structured JSON returns from HTTP responses on the frontend, eliminating the need for excessive class creation. However, some prefer creating classes for each response model.

Regarding efficiency, generating models can be time-consuming but pays off in the long run. Tools like C# Models to TypeScript npm package automate this process efficiently.

Another popular solution involves using Swagger Codegen to streamline model and service generation based on your backend specifications.

In conclusion, choose between interfaces and classes based on your specific requirements. Use classes for complex models requiring methods, and interfaces for simpler type structures. Remember, interfaces are optimized out in production, adding a performance advantage.

Find an example implementation here: Example Implementation

Answer №2

Considering that you've also included Angular in your query, I thought it would be beneficial to offer an Angular-centric response.

In Angular, the Interface (or class) is utilized as a blueprint when fetching data through http requests.

export interface Item {
  id: number;
  itemName: string;
  itemCode: string;
  tags?: string[];
  price: number;
  description: string;
  imageUrl: string;
}

@Injectable({ providedIn: 'root' })
export class ItemService {
  private itemsUrl = 'api/items';

  constructor(private http: HttpClient) { }

  getItems(): Observable<Item[]> {
    return this.http.get<Item[]>(this.itemsUrl);
  }
}

The http.get method fetches the information and fills out the designated item array structure. This approach simplifies working with the data within the component significantly.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

How to disable time selection in owl-date-time picker for Angular 6 inputs

To install the ng-pick-datetime package, use the following command: npm install ng-pick-datetime --save I recently incorporated the Owl Date Time Picker into my project. You can find more information about it here. <input [owlDateTimeTrigger]="dt10" [ ...

Exploring PrimeNG's method for expanding and collapsing groups

I'm attempting to incorporate two buttons that can be used to either expand or collapse all the groups in my code utilizing primeNG. Below is the functioning code: PLUNKER <p-dataTable [value]="data" sortField="room" rowGroupMode="subheader" grou ...

How can I dynamically resize an element based on the height of its content in Ionic?

Is there a way to make my element expand conditionally? I would like it to expand on click based on the height of its content. This is what the component's HTML looks like: <div class="container" [style.height]="enlarged === true ? ...

What is the correct way to extract results from an Array of Objects in Typescript after parsing a JSON string into a JSON object? I need help troubleshooting my code

Here is my code for extracting data from an array of objects after converting it from a JSON string to a JSON object. export class FourColumnResults { constructor(private column1: string, private column2: string, private column3: string, priv ...

Angular D3 - The method 'getBoundingClientRect' is not present in the 'Window' type

Check out this StackBlitz demo I created: https://stackblitz.com/edit/ng-tootltip-ocdngb?file=src/app/bar-chart.ts In my Angular app, I have integrated a D3 chart. The bars on the chart display tooltips when hovered over. However, on smaller screens, th ...

Breaking down code with Webpack for future extensibility

We are in the process of developing a game and have successfully implemented code-splitting to separate vendor libraries and the core engine into individual bundles, as well as splitting levels into separate bundles. As we plan for future releases where t ...

Observables waiting inside one another

I've encountered an issue where I need to return an observable and at times, within that observable, I require a value from another observable. To simplify my problem, let's consider the following code snippet: public dummyStream(): Observabl ...

Clicking on the React Bootstrap Checkbox within the Nav component does not trigger a rerender of the NavItem component

Encountering an unusual issue while using a Nav and NavItem with a Checkbox from React Bootstrap. What I've noticed is that when clicking directly on the checkbox instead of the NavItem button, the checkbox does not re-render correctly even though my ...

Retrieve information from a Firestore document using the document's unique identifier

Running into some issues with my Angular 6 and Ionic 4 app while trying to retrieve specific data from Google Cloud Firestore. I've set up "cards" to display various stats retrieved from the Firestore database. You can see an example of how my cards a ...

Guide to displaying toast notifications in the upper right corner using Bootstrap 5.2 and Angular 14

I am looking to implement toast notifications using Bootstrap 5.2 and Angular 14. The toast notification must be a separate component with custom styles, utilizing toast.services.ts. My goal is to be able to call the toast component from any other compon ...

Angular JSON Format Output: A Comprehensive Overview

I have noticed that the JSON output format currently being used may lead to errors in the application. I am trying to figure out how to achieve a different format for my code below. While I can see my data, the objects are not nested under the topics as ex ...

Can someone guide me on capturing an API response error using observables?

Currently working with Angular 4, my API call is functioning properly, returning the expected JSON for successful responses. However, in case of an error response, instead of receiving a JSON response as expected, I end up with a 404 HTML page (which is no ...

Tips for fixing the TS2345 compilation error when working with React

Attempting to implement the setState method in React has resulted in a compile error. Any solutions to this issue would be greatly appreciated. Frontend: react/typescript articleApi.tsx import axios from 'axios'; import {Article} from '../ ...

Angular 7 automatically updates array values with the most recent values, replacing any previous values in the process

Currently, I'm working with arrays and utilizing the map function to modify the data. Below is an array of icons: private socialIcons:any[] = [ {"icon":"thumbs-up","operation":"like"}, {"icon":"thumbs-down","operation":"unlike"}, {" ...

Is TypeScript capable of comprehending Svelte components?

When it comes to Svelte, the final output is native JavaScript classes, which TypeScript can understand. However, before TypeScript can recognize Svelte components, they must first be compiled from their initial .html form. This can lead to a 'cannot ...

Error message encountered: Missing property status in TypeScript code

An error occurs in the refetchInterval when accessing data.status, with a message saying "property status does not exist" chatwrapper.tsx const ChatWrapper = ({ fileId }: ChatWrapperProps) => { const { data, isLoading } = trpc.getFileUploadStatus.use ...

Guide to building an interface for an object containing a nested array

While working on my Angular/TypeScript project, I encountered a challenge in processing a GET request to retrieve objects from an integration account. Here is a snippet of the response data: { "value": [ { "properties": { ...

Steps for creating a copy of an Angular component

https://i.stack.imgur.com/4RMsR.png Whenever the user clicks on the Create Copy button, I aim to replicate the content of the DashboardComponent and position the duplicated version below the original one (the DashboardComponent featuring four dark blue sq ...

Troubleshooting problem with Angular Click Outside Directive and unexpected extra click event issue

The challenge I'm facing involves implementing a custom Click Outside Directive for closing modal dialogs, notifications, popovers, and other 'popups' triggered by various actions. One specific issue is that when using the directive with pop ...

Implementing dynamic data updates for the yAxis in a chart using Highcharts and Angular 2/4

I am currently working with a spline chart: this.chart = { chart: { type: 'spline', zoomType: 'x', animation: true, marginRight: 10, renderTo ...