My experience with DebugElement in Angular testing has been frustrating due to unexpected behavior

I have been experimenting with integrating test codes into my Angular project.

Within the PostFormComponent, there are input bindings and an output event emitter.

@Component({
  selector: 'app-post-form',
  templateUrl: './post-form.component.html',
  styleUrls: ['./post-form.component.css']
})
export class PostFormComponent implements OnInit, OnDestroy {
  @Input() post: Post = { title: '', content: '' };
  @Output() saved: EventEmitter<boolean> = new EventEmitter<boolean>();
  sub: Subscription;

  constructor(private postService: PostService) {}

  submit() {
    const _body = { title: this.post.title, content: this.post.content };

    if (this.post.id) {
      this.postService.updatePost(this.post.id, _body).subscribe(
        data => {
          this.saved.emit(true);
        },
        error => {
          this.saved.emit(false);
        }
      );
    } else {
      this.postService.savePost(_body).subscribe(
        data => {
          this.saved.emit(true);
        },
        error => {
          this.saved.emit(false);
        }
      );
    }
  }

  ngOnInit() {
    console.log('calling ngOnInit::PostFormComponent...');
  }

  ngOnDestroy() {
    console.log('calling ngOnDestroy::PostFormComponent...');
    if (this.sub) {
      this.sub.unsubscribe();
    }
  }
}

The component's template:

<form id="form" #f="ngForm" name="form" class="form" (ngSubmit)="submit()">
   <p>
      <mat-form-field fxFlex>
          <input matInput
           id="title"
           name="title"
           #title="ngModel"
           [(ngModel)]="post.title"
           required/>
          <mat-error align="start" *ngIf="title.hasError('required')">
            Post Title is required
          </mat-error>
        </mat-form-field>
   </p>
  <p>
      <mat-form-field fxFlex>
          <textarea  matInput
            #content="ngModel"
            name="content"
            id="content"
            [(ngModel)]="post.content"
            rows="8"
            required
            minlength="10">
          </textarea>
          <mat-error align="start" *ngIf="content.hasError('required')">
              Post Content is required
          </mat-error>
          <mat-error align="start" *ngIf="content.hasError('minlength')">
            At least 10 chars
          </mat-error>
      </mat-form-field>
  </p>
  <p>
      <button mat-button mat-raised-button color="primary" type="submit" [disabled]="f.invalid || f.pending">  {{'save'}}</button>
  </p>

</form>

In my attempt to incorporate tests for this component, I encountered an issue.

describe('Component: PostFormComponent(input & output)', () => {
  let component: PostFormComponent;
  let fixture: ComponentFixture<PostFormComponent>;
  let componentDe: DebugElement;
  let savePostSpy: jasmine.Spy;
  // Create a fake service object with spies
  const postServiceSpy = jasmine.createSpyObj('PostService', [
    'savePost',
    'updatePost'
  ]);

  beforeEach(() => {
    TestBed.configureTestingModule({
      imports: [BrowserAnimationsModule, SharedModule],
      declarations: [PostFormComponent],
      // provide the component-under-test and dependent service
      providers: [
        //   { provide: ComponentFixtureAutoDetect, useValue: true },
        { provide: PostService, useValue: postServiceSpy }
      ]
    }).compileComponents();

    fixture = TestBed.createComponent(PostFormComponent);
    component = fixture.componentInstance;
    componentDe = fixture.debugElement;
    fixture.detectChanges();
  });

  it('should raise `saved` event when the form is submitted (triggerEventHandler)', fakeAsync(() => {
    const formData = { title: 'Test title', content: 'Test content' };
    // trigger initial data binding
    component.post = formData;
    let saved = false;
    savePostSpy = postServiceSpy.savePost
      .withArgs(formData)
      .and.returnValue(of({}));
    // Make the spy return a synchronous Observable with the test data
    component.saved.subscribe((data: boolean) => (saved = data));

    // componentDe.triggerEventHandler('submit', null);
    component.submit();
    tick();
    fixture.detectChanges();

    expect(saved).toBeTruthy();
    expect(savePostSpy.calls.count()).toBe(1, 'savePost called');
  }));
});

An observation I made was that using

componentDe.triggerEventHandler('submit', null)
led to test failure, whereas calling component.submit() worked without issues.

Answer №1

To ensure that the submit event is only triggered on the form itself, rather than the entire component, you should start by narrowing down to the form element using a query:

const formElement = componentDe.query(By.css('form#form'));
formElement.triggerEventHandler('submit', null);

Answer №2

It is advisable to initiate the event by clicking the submit button

const submitButtonElement: DebugElement = fixture.debugElement.query(By.css('button'));
submitButtonElement.nativeElement.click()

Directly triggering the submit event of the form using

form.triggerEventHandler('submit', null);
does not always ensure that there is a user interface method to trigger the event. Writing a test that clicks on the submit button and verifies if the submit event has been triggered provides a more reliable approach.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Is it possible to enable password authentication on Firebase even if the user is currently using passwordless sign-on?

In my frontend JS project, I have integrated Firebase for web and am utilizing the passwordless (email link) authentication method for users. I am now interested in implementing password sign-on for an existing user who is currently using passwordless si ...

Encountering an issue when attempting to integrate material-ui into the jhipster project

After creating a jhipster application which utilizes Angular as the front end UI framework, I am encountering issues with the versions of jhipster and node as specified below: jhipster: 7.9.3, npm: '9.6.5', node: '18.16.0', My objectiv ...

How can I ensure a function only runs after all imports have been successfully loaded in Vue 3?

Encountering an issue with importing a large quantitative variable in Vue 3. Upon running onMounted, it seems that the import process is not yet complete, resulting in an error indicating that the variable tesvar is "uninitialized". The code snippet prov ...

What is the best way to implement custom serialization for Date types in JSON.stringify()?

class MyClass { myString: string; myDate: Date; } function foo() { const myClassArray: MyClass[] = .... return JSON.stringify(myClassArray); // or expressApp.status(200).json(myClassArray); } foo will generate a JSON string with the date format o ...

What is the method for reaching a static member of a class within a decorator for a method of the same class?

Upon the release of TypeScript 5.0, the new decorator APIs have been introduced and I am eager to utilize them for automatically providing parameters to a method from a static property within the same class. The decorator parameters and factory are defined ...

Utilize Promise.race() in Playwright Typescript to anticipate the appearance of one of two locators

Recently, I've delved into the world of Typescript while exploring Playwright for Test Automation. There's a scenario where two elements - Validated and Failed - can appear after some loading. In Selenium, my go-to method is to use WebDriverWait ...

Form control identifier and input field name

I am currently developing a custom input feature for my application. One of the functionalities I want to include is auto-completion, and in my research, I found out that certain conditions need to be met for it to work: In order to enable auto-completi ...

Waiting for completion of two observables in RxJS/Angular 11 while also managing errors

Currently, I am facing the challenge of waiting for two requests to complete (observables) and performing certain actions. Here is what I need: Wait for both requests (observables) to finish If one of them fails - show one error message If both of them f ...

Tips for preventing the overwriting of a JSON object in a React application

I'm trying to compare two JSON objects and identify the differing values in the second JSON object based on a specific key. My goal is to store these mismatched values in a new JSON object. The current issue I'm facing is that when there are mult ...

Strategies for eliminating the 'hoek' vulnerabilities

I recently uploaded an Angular CLI 5 project to GitHub and received the following security alert: A security vulnerability was found in one of the dependencies used in net-incident/package-lock.json. It is recommended to update this dependency to address ...

What is the best way to pinpoint and eliminate a Subject from an Observable?

Currently, I am utilizing a service to gather user responses from a questionnaire. The sequence of events is outlined below: questionnaire.component.ts : serves as the main container that receives data from question.service.ts question-shell.component.ts ...

How to iterate through the elements of an object within an array using Vue.js and TypeScript

There was an issue with rendering the form due to a TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading '0'). This error occurred at line 190 in the code for form1.vue. The error is also caught as a promise rejection. Error Occurred <inpu ...

Steps for activating the HTML select option menu with an external button click

I'm currently in the process of building a React website and I'm faced with the challenge of customizing select options to align with my design in Figma. Check out this image for reference Here's how I've set it up in my code: const C ...

The comparison between importing and requiring mutable values for export

I'm exploring the distinction between import and require in relation to exporting and importing mutable values. Picture a file a.ts: export let a = 1; export function f() { a = 2; } Next, we have three versions of a main file, index1.ts: import { ...

Press the second form submit button after the completion of another Observable

Below is the unique process we aim to accomplish using solely RXJS Observables: Press Login button (form with username & password). We bind Observable.fromEvent with our form. Upon submitting the form, call loginUser() to send an http request to serv ...

Prevent Angular from performing change detection on specific @Input properties

Within my Angular component, there are extensive calculations that take place when changes are detected. @Component ( selector: 'my-table', ... 400+ lines of angular template ... ) class MyTable implements OnDestroy, AfterContentInit, On ...

The subscriber continues to run repeatedly, even after we have removed its subscription

The file brief-component.ts contains the following code where the drawer service is being called: this.assignDrawerService.showDrawer(parameter); In the file drawer-service.ts: private drawerSubject = new BehaviorSubject<boolean>(false); public ...

Steps for ensuring a prop is required in TypeScript React based on a condition

interface IPerson { name: string; gender: string; vaccinated: 'yes'|'no'; vaccineName?: string } In this interface, the property vaccineName is optional while other properties are required. If the property vaccinated is yes ...

Exploring steps to secure routes without authentication using the amplify authenticator component in Angular

As indicated by the title, the documentation for the amplify authenticator component suggests wrapping it around the app-component. However, I have a need for routes that are not authenticated, and I don't want to prompt users to log in unless they vi ...