Optimal strategies for managing server-side validation/errors in Angular applications

Back in the day, I used to retrieve HTTP responses with a TypeScript object.

validateTokenHttp(token: string): Observable<User> {
    return this.http.get<User>(`${environment.api}/auth/verifyToken/${token}`);
}

Sometimes it would return a User object, or an Account Not Verified message, or an Account Not Valid response, or something else entirely.

The big question is, what is the best approach to handle these various responses?

Here are some possibilities I've been considering:

  1. Send the response with a status code of 401 or another,

    this.validateTokenHttp(token)
        .subscribe(
          (user) => {
              // perform successful operation
          },
          (error) => {
             if(error.status == 401){
                 console.log(error.error); // handle the exception
             }
          }
        );
    
    • Response
      // Status Code: 401
      {message: "Account Not Verified"}
      

    NOTE: In this scenario, we are referring to the status code 401, but there could be multiple validation scenarios on the server that don't align with 401.

  2. Include validation errors within the HTTP response with a status code of 200

    validateTokenHttp(token: string): Observable<any> {
        return this.http.get<any>(`${environment.api}/auth/verifyToken/${token}`);
    }
    
    getUser(){
        this.validateTokenHttp(token)
        .subscribe(data=>{
            if(data.success == true){
            //perform successful operation
            }
            else{
            //handle the exception
            }
        });
    }
    
    • Response 1

      //Status Code: 200
      {success: true, data: "--User details JSON object"}
      
    • Response 2

      //Status Code: 200
      {success: false, message: "Account Not Verified"}
      

If we opt for solution 2, we would need to change the return type from

validateTokenHttp(token: string): Observable<User>
to
validateTokenHttp(token: string): Observable<any>
. However, using the <any> type might not be the ideal choice.

Is there a way to expect two possible objects?

Observable<User || CustomErrorObject>

How can we ensure that we receive a User object?

Can someone please advise on the best practice for handling these types of server validations and responses?

Answer №1

There isn't just one definitive answer to this question, but I'll share my perspective on it.

If I had to choose, I would go with option 1.

Firstly, it is logical to return a 401 status code when a user is unauthorized. When developing an API, clarity and conformity to standards are essential to ensure the ease of use for others.

Secondly, I always opt to handle HTTP errors within the observable using the catchError operator. This approach ensures that errors do not disrupt the flow of the stream. By handling errors appropriately, you can keep the observable running smoothly and determine the desired outcome of the stream.

Additionally, you have the flexibility to return:

Observable<User | ErrorObject>

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Angular Pipe displays values properly, but ngFor fails to render them

I am using a pipe to filter my ngFor loop with exact matches that are passed through by clicking on the filter argument. Below is the code for my pipe: transform(values: any[], criteria: string, group): any[] { if (!values) { ...

Display an ellipsis (...) in ngx-datatable columns when the data exceeds the width

Seeking guidance on using ngx-datatable with Angular (). Currently facing an issue where text gets cut off when exceeding column width. Looking to implement ellipsis and show full details upon hovering over the truncated text or data. Any assistance ...

Searching for a working node within a document (encountering a throw err) in the context of Express and Node

Seeking a solution: I'm fairly new to node and express. When I attempt to run my server.js file, I encounter an error right away. The error message claims that I am on the incorrect path, but I believe otherwise. Referencing this screenshot for conf ...

Enhance your coding experience with Angular Apollo Codegen providing intelligent suggestions for anonymous objects

Currently, I am exploring the integration of GraphQL with Angular. So far, I have been able to scaffold the schema successfully using the @graphql-codegen package. The services generated are functional in querying the database. However, I've noticed ...

What are the reasons behind the issues encountered when enabling "Optimization" feature in Angular that affect the proper rendering of PrimeNg elements?

Angular Version : 9.x Primeng Version : 9.x We've encountered an issue with PrimeNg elements not rendering correctly in our dev/prod environments, although they work fine in the local environment. After some investigation, we found that the culprit ...

Troubleshooting Problem with Angular Material 2's Mat-Paginator [Length] Bug

Utilizing the mat-paginator component for a table, I am facing an issue where I am unable to dynamically set the length of the paginator based on the total number of results retrieved from an API call. Despite trying various methods like setting it in the ...

"I am facing issues with Nodejs $lookup as it is not producing the

I am looking to merge two document collections. The first collection, "prefix," contains an array of category IDs under the categoryId key, while the second collection, "categories," holds objects with a unique _id field. Here is my sample database structu ...

Typescript: Utilizing Index-Based Callback Parameters in Functions

I am currently working on creating a function that can handle specific data types ("resource") along with an array of arrays containing call objects and corresponding callbacks for when the calls finish ("handlers"). function useHandleResource< R exte ...

Unable to Anticipate User Input in Angular Using Scanner or Keyboard

Currently grappling with Angular 6 and facing an issue. I have a text box and a submit button, with a requirement for functionality to allow input through either manual keyboard typing or a Barcode scanner. The desired behavior is for the submit button to ...

When attempting to print a Rectangle on my webpage using JavaScript and taking user input, I encountered an error stating that 'str' is not defined

I'm trying to implement a feature where clicking on the "try it" button will prompt the user for the number of lines and then print that many lines in the form of a rectangle. However, when I run my code, nothing appears on the DOM and there is an err ...

Is there a way to configure routerLinkActive specifically for these routes?

My website has a navigation bar with the following items: Users, Categories, Products, etc. The routes are set as Main/Users, Main/Categories. I have successfully highlighted the items using routerLinkActive, however I also want to highlight the Users item ...

Tips for Shrinking Your Angular 2 App's Footprint Beyond Just Bundling and Minification

I have developed a compact Angular 2 application with a file size of approximately 28 KB (including TypeScript transpiled JS and HTML templates). This app was initially based on the angular.io quickstart, but I am currently utilizing JSPM to bundle/minify ...

Invoking a parent method from a child component in a TypeScript and React application

I'm facing an issue where I am unable to call a method from a parent component in my child component. The method in the parent element is not being triggered when the child component tries to call it. This problem is showcased in a simple example with ...

TypeScript does not pay attention to additional properties in the return type of the setState function

I'm completely lost here. I don't understand why typescript allows me to return anything in the setFormValidation call as long as I include the prevState spread in the return object. It seems to ignore all other properties that I return in the ob ...

What are some effective ways to manage repetitive HTML elements like headers and footers in Angular 4?

Within my Angular web project, I find myself using a variety of different headers on multiple pages. Is there a way to streamline this process by coding the header and footer once and having them automatically included in one or more pages? I am looking ...

Tips on utilizing boolean assignment in a ternary operator with an optional property that is an array in TypeScript

I'm trying to determine the value of an object property based on whether an optional prop is an array. Here's the scenario: const requestingMultipleDevices = Array.isArray(deviceIds); Then I have this object structure: { data: requestingM ...

I am unable to refresh the table data in Angular

Here is the code that I am currently working with: I am facing an issue where my webpage is not updating its data after performing delete or any other operations. The user list is not being displayed in the data. Despite my attempts, I have been unable to ...

Using any random function as a property value in a TypeScript React Component

I am facing a challenge in my React component where I need to define a property that can accept any arbitrary function which returns a value, regardless of the number of arguments it takes. What matters most to me is the return value of the function. Here ...

An issue arises with launching karma.js when importing node-openid-client in a TypeScript specification file

Utilizing the node-openid-client library for OpenIDConnect based authentication with an OpenID Provider. Encountering challenges while attempting to write test cases for the program. The application runs smoothly from node CLI, obtaining the code and toke ...

Tips for recognizing hyperlinks within a block of text and converting them to clickable links in Angular 2

My task is to create clickable links within a paragraph of strings. I tried using a custom pipe, but seem to be missing something essential. Here's my attempt: import { Pipe, PipeTransform } from '@angular/core'; import { DecimalPipe ...