What exactly is the task of the Angular compiler?

Someone asked me this question today and I couldn't come up with a proper response.

When it comes to deploying, Typescript transpiles to JS and then there is tree shaking, "less" (optional), and various optimizations involved. However, is any of this truly considered "compiling"? Yes, everything is bundled and optimized, but is it actually being compiled?

There is also an "ahead of time" compiler that plays a significant role. What am I overlooking here?

Despite all of this, isn't it true that Javascript is still ultimately interpreted?

Answer №1

When it comes to compiling, many people assume it involves taking source code and producing machine code or low-level codes. However, compiling simply means transforming one source code into another. Therefore, it can be argued that converting Typescript into JavaScript is a type of compiling, similar to how c# is compiled into IL language.

Instead of referring to it as compiling, a more fitting term may be "Transpiling." The Typescript compiler could be more accurately described as a Transpiler.

Although the distinction between the two is subtle, a transpiler can be considered a type of compiler. However, a compiled language typically translates a high-level language into a lower level language, approaching machine code, like in the case of C#. On the other hand, a transpiler converts a high-level language into a similar level language, both being high level.

The outcome of compiled code is usually a language that one would not manually write. In contrast, a transpiler produces another high-level language. For instance, while you could technically write IL, it is primarily generated by compiling C#/vb.net. In contrast, JavaScript is a functional programming language on its own.

*It's important to note that the definitions of these terms and their usage can be quite ambiguous.

Answer №2

It appears that you are inquiring about three distinct questions:

  • How do compilers and transpilers differ?
  • Do Angular and TypeScript utilize compilers or transpilers?
  • Does Angular have a dedicated compiler, and if so, what does it compile?

What sets a compiler apart from a transpiler?

@JörgWMittag provided an insightful response to this query. You can check it out here.

Do Angular and TypeScript employ compilers or transpilers?

Both TypeScript and Angular utilize actual compilers. They undergo lexical analysis, parsing, semantic analysis, and code generation similar to C/C++ compilers that produce assembly code. The classes/folders within both Angular and TypeScript are named "compiler," indicating their function. You can explore this further in Angular and TypeScript.

The Angular compiler is distinct from the TypeScript compiler, as they serve different purposes.

Is there a specific Angular compiler, and what is its function?

Angular features two compilers:

  • View Compiler
  • Module Compiler

The view compiler transforms the specified component template into a view factory, used to instantiate a view instance. Additionally, it compiles metadata information such as decorators like @HostBinding and @ViewChild.

For more detailed information and examples, it is recommended to read the following articles:

  • Here is what you need to know about dynamic components in Angular
  • Here is why you will not find components inside Angular

Furthermore, you may find the answer to What is the difference between Angular AOT and JIT compiler useful.

The module compiler's role is to generate a module factory containing merged provider definitions.

For additional insights, consider reading:

  • Avoiding common confusions with modules in Angular

Answer №3

When moving from Typescript to JavaScript, processes like tree shaking, optional "less", and optimization take place during deployment. However, these processes do not involve traditional compilation. The result is a bundled and highly optimized code, but not compiled in the traditional sense, right?

Compilation refers to the transformation of a program from language A to language B, ensuring that executing the compiled program in language B produces the same results and side-effects as the original program in language A. Simply put, compilation is language translation from A to B, with various specialized terms for different scenarios.

  • Assemblers translate from assembly to machine language.
  • Disassemblers convert machine language back to assembly.
  • Decompilers handle translations from lower-level to higher-level languages.
  • Optimizers create faster or lighter code in the same language.
  • Minifiers reduce code size in the same language.
  • Obfuscators make code less readable in the same language.
  • Transpilers convert languages at similar abstraction levels.
  • Re-engineering tools maintain code formatting and intent during translation.

It's important to note that while JavaScript is often interpreted, languages themselves are not inherently interpreted or compiled; these traits are characteristics of compilers and interpreters. Every language can be implemented with either or both, with varying levels of optimization for execution.

So, JavaScript is still interpreted, correct?

Languages like JavaScript can be implemented with compilers, interpreters, or both. Ultimately, all code must be interpreted at some point for execution. For example, V8 and SpiderMonkey JavaScript engines use a combination of interpreters and compilers for performance optimization.

Language definitions can blur the line between interpreted and compiled code, showcasing the complexity of execution processes. The variety of tools and technologies available further challenges traditional notions of compilation and interpretation.

Answer №4

To get your code running in a browser, you need to tackle two key tasks:

1) You must transpile your Typescript into JavaScript, typically done using tools like webpack.

2) Next, you'll need to compile the angular abstractions into JavaScript, which includes components, pipes, directives, and templates. This aspect is handled by the angular core team.

If you're curious about the angular compiler, you can check out this talk by Tobias Bosch at AngularConnect 2016.

There's sometimes confusion between transpiling and compilation, but ultimately they are both just ways to transform code. In my understanding, transpilation involves converting code between languages at a similar level of abstraction (such as typescript to javascript), while compilation involves a decrease in the level of abstraction. Moving from templates, components, pipes, directives to plain javascript represents this shift, hence the term compiler.

Answer №5

Enhancements in Angular Compiler

Transitioning from Angular 4 to 5 brought about significant improvements in the compiler. The Angular compiler underwent a complete rewrite to enhance its speed and efficiency. Previously, Angular applications utilized Just-in-Time (JIT) compilation, which meant the app was compiled at runtime in the browser before execution. With the upgrades in Angular 5, the shift towards Ahead-of-Time (AOT) compilation was accelerated, resulting in faster app performance by reducing the amount of compilation needed during runtime. AOT compilation now comes enabled by default in all production builds starting from version 1.5 of the Angular CLI.

When preparing an application for deployment, executing the following command is pivotal:

ng build --prod

Several optimizations take place, including the generation of a production version, minification, bundling assets, filename hashing, tree shaking, AOT compilation, among others (toggle functionalities with flags like aot=false). Essentially, the --prod flag produces an optimized bundle of the application through AOT compilation utilizing the ngc (Angular compiler), resulting in streamlined code tailored for the browser (Yes, it pre-compiles templates).

Evolution of TypeScript Compiler

The TypeScript compiler, tsc, is responsible for transpiling TypeScript files and implementing TypeScript features, such as static types, into pure JavaScript devoid of TypeScript-specific keywords and expressions.

The TypeScript compiler encompasses two primary functions: transpilation and type checking. It transforms TypeScript code into JavaScript by:

  • Removing all type annotations.
  • Compiling new JavaScript features for older versions.
  • Converting TypeScript-specific features into standard JavaScript.

During invocation, the compiler references configurations outlined in tsconfig.json (Detailed compiler options with default values can be found here).

While the TypeScript compiler operates like most compilers, there's a notable distinction – it continues emitting JavaScript code even when it encounters errors by default. To counter this, set the noEmitOnError configuration to true in the tsconfig.json file.

Important Note: tsc and ngc serve distinct purposes, and it's not a matter of choosing one over the other. For further clarity, refer to this insightful answer.

This response was formulated based on information from the following resources:

  • Cloe, M. (2018). "Angular 5 Projects: Learn to Build Single Page Web Applications Using 70+ Projects".

  • Dewey, B., Grossnicklaus, K., Japikse, P. (2017). "Building Web Applications with Visual Studio 2017: Using .NET Core and Modern JavaScript Frameworks".

  • Freeman, A. (2019). "Essential TypeScript: From Beginner to Pro".

  • Ghiya, P. (2018). "TypeScript Microservices".

  • Iskandar, A., Chivukulu, S. (2019). "Web Development with Angular and Bootstrap - Third Edition".

  • Hennessy, K., Arora, C. (2018). "Angular 6 by Example".

  • Jansen, R., Wolf, I., Vane, V. (2016). "TypeScript: Modern JavaScript Development".

  • Mohammed, Z. (2019). "Angular Projects".

  • Seshadri, S. (2018). "Angular: Up and Running".

  • Wilken, J. (2018). "Angular in Action".

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Devextreme experiences the submission of multiple forms simultaneously

While working with Devextreme forms in Angular 2, I encountered an issue with two separate forms. Whenever I click the submit button on either the first or second form, both forms undergo validation. Why is this happening? https://i.sstatic.net/1orrY.png ...

An unexpected error occurred while running ng lint in an Angular project

I've encountered an issue while trying to run ng lint on my Angular project. After migrating from TSLint to ESLint, I'm getting the following error message when running ng lint: An unhandled exception occurred: Invalid lint configuration. Nothing ...

Formatting in Cx framework: Configuring right alignment and decimal precision on NumberField

Currently, I am involved in a project that involves UI development using Cx, a new FrontEnd framework based on React. You can find more information about Cx at One of the tasks in my project involves creating a Grid with filter fields located at the top ...

Console.log is displaying array as [object Object] when utilizing Typescript

When working with an object in typescript called "obj," I encountered a strange behavior. Initially, when I ran the console.log(obj); command, the output in the terminal console was displayed as [object Object]. However, after wrapping it in JSON.stringify ...

What is the best way to neatly import multiple images in Next.js?

I have a dilemma involving 10 images located in my public directory that I need to use in a component. Instead of individually importing each image like this: import imgurl1 from "../../public/celsius.gif"; import imgurl2 from "../../public/ ...

When the onInput event is triggered, React renders components and console.log() displays different values

When I type in the input field, it triggers the onInputChange() function. This function updates the state of inputValue, and then calls the getValue() function which retrieves the current state of inputValue and logs it to the console. However, the value d ...

Tips for handling an incorrect date entry when a field loses focus in AngularJS

If I have an <input> field with the type='date' attribute in its untouched state, it displays mm/dd/yyyy as the date format. I am looking to see if there is a way to utilize AngularJS ng-blur directive to reset the field to this original fo ...

The Subscribe function in Angular's Auth Guard allows for dynamic authorization

Is there a way to check if a user has access by making an API call within an authentication guard in Angular? I'm not sure how to handle the asynchronous nature of the call and return a value based on its result. The goal is to retrieve the user ID, ...

Tips for sending data from Jade to a Node.js endpoint function

I am unfamiliar with Express and I am trying to figure out how to pass the user's username from a Jade file to an endpoint function in my JavaScript file. Below is the code for the endpoint function in index.js: router.get('/userdetail', fu ...

Using React and TypeScript to pass member variables

My component Child has a member variable that can change dynamically. While I am aware of passing props and states, is there a more elegant solution than passing member variables through props or other parameters? class Child extends React.Component< ...

Tips on obtaining data from ion-select and presenting it in a label

I'm having a problem with dynamic binding in my drop-down. I can't seem to display the default selected value in the label, and when I change the selection, the new value isn't showing up either. Take a look at my code below: <p>{{l ...

Triggering a JavaScript function upon the alteration of a Dojo auto-complete widget's value

I'm encountering an issue with calling a javascript function when the value of a Dojo auto completer changes. Despite trying to call the function through the "onChange" attribute, it doesn't work as expected. Within the javascript function, my ...

Develop a unique method for loading AngularJS templates

When working with AngularJS, there are various ways to provide an external template, such as using a script tag or a separate HTML file on the web server. However, I am faced with a situation where I need to implement a custom logic for retrieving these ...

extract elements from dataset

Attempting to splice an array but encountering index issues var kode_pelayanan = []; function deleteKodePelayanan(index){ kode_pelayanan.splice(index, 1); console.log(kode_pelayanan); } Experimented in the console with an array for kode_pelayanan ...

Turning an array of strings into a multidimensional array

I have a JavaScript string array that I need to convert into a multidimensional array: const names = [ "local://john/doe/blog", "local://jane/smith/portfolio", "as://alexander/wong/resume" ]; The desired output sh ...

When a function is included in an object, it transforms into something other than a function

In my model, it looks like this: export default class UserObject { name: string; id: string; validateInsert() { } } If I interact with the model in this way: const modelUser: UserModel = new UserModel(); modelUser.ID = 1; modelUser ...

Issues with retrieving data from nested nodes while parsing NOAA weather information using Javascript XML

Seeking assistance with my Javascript code, which is designed to extract weather data from NOAA xml files (obtained from this link: ). Currently, I have included a snippet of the XML as a string: var xmlDoc = $.parseXML("<data>\ <weather tim ...

Preventing a scroll handler from executing once an element has been clicked

When a user scrolls to the video, it will automatically start playing. Similarly, when the user scrolls away from the video, it will stop playing and display the poster image. However, I encountered an issue where I don't want this functionality to tr ...

Tips for populating array values in an Angular9 template using forms

.html page <pre> <div *ngFor="let data of data;let i=index" class="row_wrap"> <div class="row_inner_wrap"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-md-12"> <div class="col-md- ...

Are the features of emulation mode in IE11 identical to implementing the meta EmulateIE7 tag?

When using the IE11 browser, I encountered an interesting message on the console: “HTML1122: Internet Explorer is running in Enterprise Mode emulating IE8.” Upon researching this error code on this link, I found out that it is a mode configured by IT ...