What impact does the Host resolution modifier have on the injection process?

The concept of Hierarchical Dependency Injection in Angular, as explained in the guide here, invites us to view DI as a combined logical tree.

Explaining the use of the @Host() modifier, the guide mentions that it restricts the search scope to the <#VIEW> level of the logical structure. It provides an example using @Host() along with @SkipSelf and @Host.

<app-root @NgModule(AppModule)
        @Inject(FlowerService) flower=>"🌺">
  <#VIEW> <!-- end search here with null-->
    <app-child @Provide(FlowerService="🌻")> <!-- start search here -->
      <#VIEW @Inject(FlowerService, @SkipSelf, @Host, @Optional)=>null>
      </#VIEW>
      </app-parent>
  </#VIEW>
</app-root>

The guide then introduces the usage of viewProviders, which ensures that the dependency is available within the <#VIEW>. An example demonstrates successful resolution when the dependency is provided in the AppComponent through the viewProviders array.

<app-root @NgModule(AppModule)
        @Inject(AnimalService=>"🐳")>
  <#VIEW @Provide(AnimalService="🦔")
         @Inject(AnimalService, @SkipSelf, @Host, @Optional)=>"🦔">
    <!-- ^^@SkipSelf() starts here,  @Host() stops here^^ -->
    <app-child>
      <#VIEW @Provide(AnimalService="🐶")
             @Inject(AnimalService, @SkipSelf, @Host, @Optional)=>"🐶">
               <!-- Add @SkipSelf ^^-->
      </#VIEW>
      </app-child>
  </#VIEW>
</app-root>

According to the analogy presented, providing a dependency via the providers option while using the @Host modifier in the component's constructor brings us to create a logical tree like this:

<app-root>
  <#VIEW>
    <app-child @Provide(AnimalService="🐶")>
      <#VIEW @Inject(AnimalService, @Host, @Optional)=>null> <!-- start and end search here with null-->
      </#VIEW>
      </app-parent>
  </#VIEW>
</app-root>

However, there seems to be confusion on how the <app-child> is reached, given that @Host() should limit the search boundary to the <#VIEW>, preventing further injections. What might be missing from this understanding?

For a visual demonstration, refer to the StackBlitz demo.

Answer №1

Your understanding of each of these modifiers seems accurate, but in the provided OP and StackBlitz demo, you have used @Optional instead of @SkipSelf in the child component. If you switch @Optional with @SkipSelf, you will encounter the expected error. Check out the updated (forked) demo here.

Additionally, in your example/demo, you are using the providers key in the component decorator which is distinct from viewProviders. This difference will impact how your demo aligns with Angular's official documentation.

@Component({
  viewProviders: []
})

It might be surprising that a child component with @SkipSelf and @Host can still locate an element specified in the parent component, but there is a reason behind this behavior.

@Component({
  selector: 'app-root',
  template: `<app-child></app-child>`,
  viewProviders: [{ provide: AnimalService, useValue: { emoji: '🐶' } }]
})

export class AppComponent {}

@Component({
  selector: 'app-child',
  template: `<p>Emoji from AnimalService: {{animal.emoji}}</p>`
})

export class ChildComponent {
  constructor(@Host() @SkipSelf() public animal: AnimalService) {}
}

If you replace @Host with @Self, you would likely encounter an error which makes sense. For further clarification on this difference, refer to this question/answer.

Edit: The error occurs because Angular's DI cannot locate the provider specified in the component. To suppress this error, consider using @Optional along with other options as explained in Angular's docs.

Edit 2: It could be confusing due to the differentiation between viewProviders and providers in the Component API. Your XML diagrams indicate a separation between them, where VIEW sits within an app-child. Perhaps the confusion lies in which injector is being configured. I've updated my response with clarity on this distinction.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Discover the proper technique to display an error message in cases where no data is detected during the filtering process

I'm currently working on a component that involves search filtering and dropdown filtering. The filtering functionality is working fine, but I'm struggling to determine where to display an error message if no data is found during the filtering pr ...

Error: Got a SyntaxError with CrafterCMS while attempting to use TypeScript - Unexpected token 'export'

Recently, I embarked on a project using crafterCMS with TypeScript. After installing the most up-to-date packages: "@craftercms/content": "^2.0.7", "@craftercms/experience-builder": "^1.0.0-rc.3", "@craftercms/i ...

The proper way to cancel useEffect's Async in TypeScript

I'm facing an issue with this straightforward example: useEffect(() => { axios.get(...).then(...).catch(...) }, [props.foo]) warning: can't perform a react state update on an unmounted component After some investigation, I found this ...

Tips for converting each item within an array into its own separate element

https://i.sstatic.net/Dxj1W.pngI currently have an array of objects that I am utilizing to generate a table in Angular. The table is functioning properly and successfully displays the data. However, I now have a requirement to enable editing for each indiv ...

I'm looking for a sample of RadPieChart for nativescript + angular. Can anyone help me out?

I'm currently working on a multi-platform application that requires a PieChart to be displayed on the main screen. Can someone point me to a comprehensive example of how to implement this? I have tried following this guide and modifying it according ...

Angular material dialog box experiencing issues with saving multiple values

Currently, I am utilizing Anular9 and implementing mat-raised-button in the following manner: <button mat-raised-button (click)="saveClick()" color="primary"><mat-icon>check</mat-icon>&nbsp;&nbsp;Ok</butto ...

Issue with triggering (keyup.enter) in Angular 8 for readonly HTML input elements

My goal is to execute a function when the user presses Enter. By setting this input as readonly, my intention is to prevent the user from changing the value once it has been entered. The value will be populated from a popup triggered by the click attribut ...

PrimeNg element for showcasing incorrect user input similar to mat-error

Is there an equivalent of mat-error in PrimeNg like Angular Material? <mat-form-field appearance="fill"> <mat-label>Enter your email</mat-label> <input matInput placeholder="<a href="/cdn-cgi/l/email-protecti ...

The Angular service worker is running in a secure SAFE_MODE environment

My Angular PWA had a perfectly functioning service worker until I made the upgrade from Angular 5.0 to 7.2. After the upgrade, I encountered the following error in /ngsw/state Driver state: SAFE_MODE (Initialization failed due to error: Invariant violate ...

Error message: Failure to define class methods when exporting the class from a file

In my project, I have defined a class called BinarySearchTree in a file named a.js. This class has been exported and then imported into another file where it is used as the parent class for a different class called Traversal. However, I encountered an issu ...

Having trouble retrieving user attributes from the cognitoUser object following successful authentication with aws-amplify

My Angular 11 project utilizes AWS Amplify (aws-amplify v3.3.26) with Cognito user pools for user management. The hosted UI is set up without any custom attributes. All necessary permissions for read and write are configured in the user pool. The code use ...

Using TypeScript to define task invocation parameters with AWS CDK's CfnMaintenanceWindowTask

Currently, I am utilizing AWS CDK along with the library @aws-cdk/aws-ssm and TypeScript to construct CfnMaintenanceWindowTask. The code example I am working on is derived from AWS CloudFormation documentation, specifically for "Create a Run Command t ...

Angular - Error: Cannot read property 'publishLast' of undefined

My goal is to prevent multiple requests from being created when using the async pipe. I am facing an issue with a request to fetch a user from the API: getUser() { this._user = this.http.get<User>(environment.baseAPIUrl + 'user') ...

I'm curious, where does Visual Studio create the dist folder when you run an Angular Web Application?

Currently utilizing Visual Studio 2019 Community Edition, although the same situation also pertains to VS2017 and other editions of 2017/2019. While developing/running an ASP.NET Core Web Application with an Angular web project, I'm unable to locate ...

The <a> tag styled as a button with the btn-primary class is malfunctioning specifically on MacOS Safari

Trying to use an anchor tag with type button and btn-primary class on MacOS safari is causing issues, while it works perfectly on Chrome and Edge browsers <a class="btn btn-primary " style="border-radius: 25px;" type="button&qu ...

Stop non-logged-in users from accessing page content rendering

Lazy loading is being used in my application to render pages. { path: 'dashboard', loadChildren: './dashboard/dashboard.module#DashboardModule', canActivate: [AuthGuard] } The problem arises when the user types www.mydomain.com/dashbo ...

Utilize SWR in NextJS to efficiently manage API redirection duplication

When using SWR to fetch data, I encountered an error where the default path of nextjs was repeated: http://localhost:3000/127.0.0.1:8000/api/posts/get-five-post-popular?skip=0&limit=5 Here is my tsx code: 'use client' import useSWR from &quo ...

Testing Angular Reactive Forms: Synchronizing HTML and Control values mismatch

I have been diligently following the Angular reactive form unit testing tutorial here, but I continue to struggle with keeping the control value and HTML value in sync. Below is how I've implemented it; note that I am trying to use setValue along with ...

Module 'framer' missing even after removing node modules directory

While cleaning up the angular code, I decided to delete some unused custom modules. However, after doing so, I encountered an error regarding a deleted imported component in app.module.ts even though it had already been removed from the imports. To addres ...

Challenges arise when incorporating interfaces within a class structure

I created two interfaces outside of a class and then proceeded to implement them. However, when I tried to assign them to private properties of the class, something went wrong and I'm unable to pinpoint the issue. Can anyone offer assistance with thi ...