What is the method in AngularJS2 for using TypeScript to inject dependencies into components?

I have been encountering different methods of injecting dependencies into my component and not all of them seem to be working for me. I am curious about the advantages and disadvantages, what the recommended best practices are, and why some methods are not delivering the expected results. Here is an example:

@Component()
@Injectable()
class MyComponent {

  dependency1: Dependency1;

  constructor(dependency2: Dependency2, dependency3: Dependency3) {
    this.dependency2 = dependency2;
  }

  someFunction() {
    // Which of these will work? What is considered best practice?
    // What are the pros and cons?
    this.dependency1.get();
    this.dependency2.get();
    this.dependency3.get();
  }
}

Based on this example:

  1. Is version 1 (Dependency1) equivalent to version 2 (Dependeny2)? Or does version 1 only apply to TypeScript without any impact on injection?

  2. Regarding this line of code

    this.dependency2 = dependency2;

Is it necessary, or will it happen automatically as assumed for Dependency3?

  1. What exactly does Injectable do? How would the answers to questions 1 and 2 differ if Injectable was not used?

Thank you very much

Answer ā„–1

It appears that there is some confusion between typescript parameter properties and the Angular2 Dependency Injection (DI) mechanism.

When defining constructors in typescript, you have two options. In short:

@Component()
class MyComponent {
  constructor(
    public dependency1: Dependency1, 
    public dependency2: Dependency2, 
    public dependency3: Dependency3
  ) { }

  // [...]

This will be transformed into a longer, more verbose version that you can also use:

@Component()
class MyComponent {
  public dependency1: Dependency1;
  public dependency2: Dependency2;
  public dependency3: Dependency3;

  constructor(
    dependency1: Dependency1, 
    dependency2: Dependency2, 
    dependency3: Dependency3
  ) {
    this.dependency1 = dependency1;
    this.dependency2 = dependency2;
    this.dependency3 = dependency3;
  }

  // [...]

You can find more information about this in the Typescript Handbook. Both approaches have their advantages and disadvantages; the longer version is clearer for those new to typescript, while the shorter version saves typing but may be less clear. Choose according to your preference. :)

Note: If your class already has another decorator, you don't need to use the @Injectable() decorator. It only generates metadata for decorated classes to prevent excessive code bloat in transpiled code.


Regarding the Dependency Injection mechanic, assuming you have imported definitions for Dependency1, Dependency2, and Dependency3 (1), registered their providers (2), and angular created an instance of your component (3):

  • Within someFunction(), this.dependency1 is declared as public at the start of your class and has a defined type (Dependency1). However, its current value is undefined since it was not assigned a value in the constructor or elsewhere.

    Fix: Add dependency1: Dependency1 parameter to the constructor and assign this.dependency1 = dependency1. You can also use the typescript shorthand mentioned above. ([EDIT]

    constructor(public dependency1, ...
    ).

  • Accessing this.dependency2 inside the constructor should trigger a compile error because MyComponent does not have a property named dependency2. If this compiles/transpiles without errors, then this.dependency2 should have the correct value, although type information may be lacking (not ideal).

    Fix: Declare public dependency2: Dependency2; before the constructor. Alternatively, add the public property in front of the constructor's dependency2 parameter. [EDIT] Or use

    constructor(public dependency2, ...
    ).

  • Lastly, this.dependency3 faces both issues of lack of declaration (similar to dependency2) and having an undefined value (like dependency1).

    Fix: Refer to the previous solutions mentioned. :)

Note: Understanding the difference between declaration & definition (Even though this reference is about C++, the concept applies to typescript) is crucial for this topic. I hope I did not confuse the terms while typing. ;)


  1. This can be accomplished by:

    import { Dependency1 } from 'dependency-module-1';
    import { Dependency2 } from 'dependency-module-2';
    import { Dependency3 } from 'dependency-module-3';
    
  2. There are several ways to define providers for your dependencies:

    • During bootstrapping. This makes the modules available (via their providers) to every component in your app.

      bootstrap(AppComponent, [
        Dependency1,
        Dependency2,
        Dependency3
      ]);
      
    • Using the component decorator. This provides the modules to MyComponent and shares the same module instance with each child component. If a child component has its own provider array, a new module instance is created for it (shared with all child components). For further reading, check out the official Angular2 guide and this blog post. Here is an example:

      @Component({
        providers: [
          Dependency1,
          Dependency2,
          Dependency3
        ]
      })
      class MyComponent {
        \\ [...]
      
  3. Either MyComponent is passed as the first parameter to angular's bootstrap method, or the component's selector is used somewhere in your DOM.


For best practices, consider using tslint and custom rule plugins like codealyze which are angular-specific.

Lastly, refer to the official Angular Typescript Styleguide for additional guidance. :)

Answer ā„–2

Make sure to refer to the official Angular documentation

You may also want to check out this insightful blog post

Angular utilizes constructor-based dependency injection, where constructor parameters are injected as dependencies.

For example, in the code snippet "Car(e: Engine)", the engine would be injected into the car instance by DI.

The TypeScript way of defining a constructor is demonstrated in the following two code snippets that are essentially equivalent:

e: Engine 
   Car(e:Engine){
      this.e = e 
    }

Car(public e:Engine){ }

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Error message in Angular 8: Cannot be assigned to AsyncValidatorFn

I am currently working on implementing a custom validator function in a reactive form. Here is the code snippet: form.component.ts ... form = new FormGroup({ username: new FormControl('', [ Validators.required, ...

Unlocking Security in Angular 2

I am struggling with the issue of security in Angular 2. I am attempting to calculate the width of a span element within an ngfor loop: <span style="width:updateStyle({{ ((date | amDifference : item.startdate : 'minutes' :true)/item.duratio ...

Issue encountered when attempting to import a module within the ionic framework

I encountered an issue in my project (built with the ionic-framework 3) where I included the following line to import the dialogflow module: const dialogflow = require('dialogflow'); However, when compiling, it resulted in the error message: ...

In Typescript, a function that is declared with a type other than 'void' or 'any' is required to have a return value

I'm a beginner in Angular2/Typescript and I am encountering an error while trying to compile my project: An error is showing: A function that has a declared type other than 'void' or 'any' must return a value. Here is the code sn ...

When the session times out in Angular 5, the previous user's credentials remain on the page instead of being replaced with the current user's information

When switching from one user to another in Angular 5, I am facing an issue where the previous user's credentials are displayed instead of the current user's until I refresh the page. I have tried using the localstorage.clear() method but it doesn ...

If you're trying to work with this file type, you might require a suitable loader. Make sure you

Attempting to utilize Typescript typings for the Youtube Data API found at: https://github.com/Bolisov/typings-gapi/tree/master/gapi.client.youtube-v3 Within the Ionic framework, an error is encountered after running 'Ionic Serve' with the follo ...

Retrieving variables from JavaScript files in TypeScript

Greetings, I am in the process of upgrading an existing Angular application from version 2 to 9. My approach involves first moving it to angular 4 and then continuing with the upgrades. I have successfully updated the necessary packages, but now I'm e ...

Narrowing Down State Types

I am working on a functional component in NextJS with props passed from SSR. The component has a state inside it structured like this: const MyComponent = ({err, n}: {err?: ErrorType, n?: N})=>{ const [x, setX] = useState(n || null) ... if(e ...

What is the best way to define a signal within a class interface in Angular 17?

Iā€™m working on setting up signals for my properties in class, which has been going smoothly so far. public varName = signal(''); However, I would also like to utilize the related interface. Unfortunately, I have not come across any documentati ...

There are no HTTP methods available in the specified file path. Make sure to export a distinct named export for each HTTP method

Every time I attempt to run any code, I encounter the following error message: No HTTP methods exported in 'file path'. Export a named export for each HTTP method. Below is the content of my route.ts file: import type { NextApiRequest, NextApi ...

Resolve an "Uncaught ReferenceError" by importing an unused component to fix the error of not being able to access a variable before initialization

In my service file, where I store all other services used in the frontend, there is an import section that includes one component even though it is not being used. import { VacationComponent } from 'app/view/vacation/vacation.component'; When I ...

Utilize puppeteer and web-vitals in NextJS to retrieve the web performance metrics of a website

I'm currently working on a basic tool in NextJS that uses puppeteer to fetch web vitals data from a given URL. However, I'm facing an issue where the results are not being printed out. What could be causing this problem? const browser = await pup ...

Issue TS1112: It is not possible to declare a class member as optional

I'm currently working on creating a movie catalog using Angular and Ionic. Within the Movie class, I have properties for id, title, image, and plot. On the initial page of the app, only the id, title, and image are displayed, while the plot is omitte ...

Using Angular2 animations (specifically transform animations) on an iPhone 6s may result in unexpected behavior

I am interested in utilizing Angular2's Animation to create an animation similar to the following: transition('out => arise', [ style({ 'transform': 'translateY(-50px)', '-webkit-transform&a ...

Transitioning from MVC to Angular 2 and TypeScript: A Step-by-Step Guide

Seeking guidance as I venture into the world of Angular. My goal is to pass a string variable 'element' to my UI and utilize it. However, I am unsure about how to go about passing it inside main.js and beyond. How can I transfer a variable to a t ...

What's the best solution for preventing the infiltration of styles from other components into my web component that utilizes ShadowDom?

In my Angular project, I am utilizing web components with ShadowDom implementation. However, I have noticed that all styles from other components with default view encapsulation are being applied to these components: https://i.sstatic.net/g9d1q.png Speci ...

Sorting array of arrays in TypeScript and Node.js involves defining the arrays and then applying a sorting algorithm

Recently delved into TypeScript with limited JavaScript knowledge just a couple of weeks ago. I am attempting to scan through all the files in a particular directory, gather each file name (string) and modification time (number>), then organize them in ...

Using Angular's NgFor directive to loop through a list of items and trigger a click event

Is it possible to programmatically trigger a click event on a specific item within an ngFor loop? <ul> <li class="list" *ngFor="let ver of versions; (click)="versionView()">{{ver.name}}</li> </ul> ...

Scrolling through a list in Angular using cdk-virtual-scroll-viewport while selecting items via keyboard input

Looking to implement a customized Autocomplete feature. As the user begins typing, a small window should appear with selectable options. I want users to have the ability to navigate and select an option using their keyboard. For instance: - User types "H ...

Tips for sorting through the properties of the Record<K, T>:

Let's say we have the following data stored in a record: export const MenuData: Record<Header, HeaderInfo> = { val1: { message: 'xyz', buttonText: 'txt', buttonUrl: '/url-abc', }, val2: { messa ...