What is the rationale behind TypeScript's decision to implement two checks for its optional chaining and null-coalescing operators during compilation?

What is the reason behind the way the TypeScript compiler translates its optional chaining and null-coalescing operators, found here, from:

// x?.y
x === null || x === void 0 ? void 0 : x.y;

// x ?? y
x !== null && x !== void 0 ? x : y

as opposed to:

// x?.y
x == null ? void 0 : x.y

// x ?? y
x != null ? x : y

It seems like a single check would have sufficed for both cases, potentially making the code cleaner. Additionally, shouldn't optional chaining compile to:

x == null ? x : x.y

in order to maintain the distinction between null and undefined? There is further discussion on this topic in: Why does JavaScript's optional chaining use undefined instead of preserving null?

Answer №1

If you're seeking an authoritative response, take a look at microsoft/TypeScript#16 (an older thread) which provides detailed clarification in this particular comment:

The reason behind this is related to the usage of document.all [...], a peculiar feature that receives unique treatment within the language for compatibility purposes.

document.all == null // true
document.all === null || document.all === undefined // false

In the proposal for optional chaining

document.all?.foo === document.all.foo

however

document.all == null ? void 0 : document.all.foo
would incorrectly yield void 0.

This showcases a unique idiosyncratic deprecated unusual legacy pseudo-property scenario pertaining to type HTMLAllCollection, rarely utilized and loosely equivalent to null but not strictly equal to either undefined or null. Quite fascinating!

No major consideration appears to have been given to simply "breaking" things for document.all. As the

xxx === null || xxx === undefined
approach works universally, it likely remains the most concise method of generating backward-compatible JS code that aligns with the specifications.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Organize Dates in React Table

I need help with sorting the Date column in my code. Currently, the sorting is being done alphabetically. Here is the JSON data and code snippet: JSON [ { "date": "Jun-2022" }, { "date": "Jul-2022" } ...

Ensure that TypeScript compiled files are set to read-only mode

There is a suggestion on GitHub to implement a feature in tsc that would mark compiled files as readonly. However, it has been deemed not feasible and will not be pursued. As someone who tends to accidentally modify compiled files instead of the source fil ...

Crafting a recursive Typescript Immutable.js Record through typing

I am currently working on representing a tree-like data structure using immutable js and typescript. At the moment, I am utilizing regular vanilla js objects to depict the nodes within the tree. Below is the type signature. type NodeType = { value: str ...

Looking for a JavaScript (Angular) event listener to trigger when closing pages and tabs

I am looking for an event that will only work when closing a page or tab, but should not be triggered when the page is refreshed. I am aware of the "beforeunload" event, but it also gets activated on page refresh. Below is the code snippet I am currently ...

I am encountering issues with the TypeScript repository build on my local machine, but it successfully passes when

I am encountering an issue with a TypeScript repository failing to build on my local machine. The error message I receive is as follows: $ tsc --pretty -p tsconfig.json ../../../../../../node_modules/@types/graphql/subscription/subscribe.d.ts:17:12 - erro ...

The attribute 'status' is not found in the 'ServerResponse' type (TS2339)

I've attempted to develop an interface and install React types, but the only way it seems to work is when I write the code in JavaScript. However, within a TypeScript project, I encounter this error: Property 'status' does not exist on typ ...

Struggled to incorporate Typescript function overload's implementation

After reviewing the previous question: Typescript: exclude undefined/null properties from type In my TypeScript project, I attempted to create an overload for a function called request, which can optionally accept a payload. The function is defined by the ...

Execution issue with Typescript function

In my Nativescript project, I have the following TypeScript file: import { Observable } from 'tns-core-modules/data/observable'; import { isIOS } from "tns-core-modules/platform"; import { Color } from "tns-core-modules/color"; import { request, ...

Is it necessary for a TypeScript Library's repository to include the JavaScript version?

Is it necessary to include a JavaScript version of the library along with the Typescript repository for consumers? Or is it best to let consumers handle the compilation process themselves? Or should I consider another approach altogether? ...

How to retrieve the value of a variable accessible to all users in Angular?

In my code, I am working with a service variable called Users. Service: Users:BehaviorSubject<Array<any>> = new BehaviorSubject([]); I am updating the values in the component using this code: this.Service.Users.next([...this.Service.User ...

The TypeScript factory design pattern is throwing an error stating that the property does not

While working with TypeScript, I encountered an issue when trying to implement the factory pattern. Specifically, I am unable to access child functions that do not exist in the super class without encountering a compiler error. Here is the structure of my ...

Running pre-commit eslint autofix but encountering errors that do not exist

Encountering an issue with committing changes to a file due to a failed pre-commit eslint --fix task, displaying the following errors: × eslint --fix: C:\Users\user\source\repos\project\project-frontend\src\compone ...

There seems to be a contradiction in my code - I am returning a Promise but TypeScript is throwing an error saying that the

I currently have a function that retrieves a bot's inventory on the Frontend fetchBotInventory() { this.socket.emit('fetch bot inv'); this.socket.on('bot inv', (botInventory) => { return new Promise((resolve, re ...

Warning: The TypeScript version in use may not support all features. The current language level is set to XX in Visual Studio 2019

After installing VS 2019, I noticed that Microsoft.TypeScript.MSBuild 4.2.3 was added. On my Windows 10 OS, I also installed it using NPM in the following way: However, upon opening VS 2019, I encountered the warning below: TypeScript 3.4 feature Curre ...

Sharing parameters between pages in Angular IonicPassing parameters between pages within an Angular Ionic application

Is there a way to pass parameters from the signup page to the signupotp page successfully? I am facing an issue where the OTP on the signupotp page is not being recognized because the parameters (email and mobile) are not getting passed properly. In my bac ...

An unusual problem encountered while working with NextJS and NextAuth

In my NextJS authentication setup, I am using a custom token provider/service as outlined in this guide. The code structure is as follows: async function refreshAccessToken(authToken: AuthToken) { try { const tokenResponse = await AuthApi.refre ...

DeActivation only occurs once per route

Having an issue with the CanDeActivate() function in Angular2. The problem arises when a user tries to leave a page while in edit mode, triggering a popup with Yes, No, and Cancel options. If the user clicks on Cancel, the popup closes. If they click on No ...

Issue: (SystemJS) Unable to find solutions for all parameters in $WebSocket: ([object Object], [object Object], ?)

Upon running the code snippet below, an error is thrown: Error: (SystemJS) Can't resolve all parameters for $WebSocket: ([object Object], [object Object], ?). app.component.ts import { Component } from '@angular/core'; import {$WebSocket} ...

Improving the process of class initialization in Angular 4 using TypeScript

Is there a more efficient method to initialize an inner class within an outer class in Angular 4? Suppose we have an outer class named ProductsModel that includes ProductsListModel. We need to send the ProductId string array as part of a server-side reque ...

The function is trying to access a property that has not been defined, resulting in

Here is a sample code that illustrates the concept I'm working on. Click here to run this code. An error occurred: "Cannot read property 'myValue' of undefined" class Foo { myValue = 'test123'; boo: Boo; constructor(b ...