What makes it still feasible to convert any type of variable to "any" in TypeScript?

As I continue to improve my coding skills with TypeScript, I find myself in the shoes of a full stack developer experienced in C#, an object-oriented programming language. Personally, I have a strong distaste for dynamically typed languages and fortunately, I haven't had to work with any yet.

The issue that has recently dawned on me is the use of "any" casting, especially problematic for beginners and those unfamiliar with OOP concepts. While it's understandable for generic methods like fetching data from various sources such as axios, rxjs, or local storage to return any type of value due to their variable nature, there are instances where improper casting can lead to errors.

For example, the following code snippet is deemed illegal in TypeScript:

class C1 {id: string}
class C2 {num: number}

const c1 = new C1()
const c2: C2 = c1;

In contrast, TypeScript permits the following scenario using the "any" keyword:

class C1 {/*...*/}
class C2 {/*...*/}

const c1 = new C1();
const c2: C2 = c1 as any;

My current project involves numerous instances of such castings, which complicate refactoring and often introduce bugs. It feels haphazard, akin to resorting to "any" casting whenever faced with an error, regardless of consequences.

I'm left wondering if there is a legitimate use case for this feature in TypeScript.

In line with OOP principles, setting specific types when creating generic methods is crucial. Although C# offers the object type as a workaround, it's generally discouraged. Fortunately, TypeScript provides similar functionality:

// C# Example:
public T GenericMethod<T>() {
  //...
}

var c1 = GenericMethod<C1>();

// TypeScript Example:
genericMethod<T>() {}
// or even
genericMethod = <T>() => ({} as T);

This standardized approach proves beneficial for interacting with databases, handling data retrieval from various sources, and efficiently managing potential exceptions.

Answer №1

Just had an epiphany about how detrimental "any" casting can be.

I feel the same way. I've earned the nickname "The Any Police" because I always scrutinize and reject any instance of it during code reviews.

any serves a specific purpose: easing the transition to TypeScript. In the early stages, many codebases start out in JavaScript and gradually switch over to TypeScript. As the default type for plain JavaScript variables, any bypasses type checking unless explicitly specified. The idea is for projects to initially rely on any and eventually swap them out with proper types as development progresses.

However, once a project is primarily in TypeScript, excessive use of any becomes counterproductive. It hinders typechecking (by design), allowing errors to slip through unnoticed, such as those you pointed out. While there are rare instances where any can be necessary to inform TypeScript to "trust me, I've got this under control," they should generally be avoided. Unfortunately, it seems like the codebase you're dealing with lacks someone like The Any Police to enforce best practices.


On a side note, while using as X may be commonly referred to as "type casting," it's more accurate to view it as a "type assertion." By asserting to TypeScript, "Trust me, this is the correct type," no runtime changes occur. If the assertion proves incorrect, TypeScript cannot provide assistance.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Storing a variable in Cypress with Typescript for use in the afterEach teardown step

Throughout my test cases, I store data in a variable to be used consistently. The variable maintains its value until the very end of the test, but when trying to access it in the @afterEach teardown function for global clean up, it appears empty. It seems ...

Error: The Angular test bed is unable to locate the mixpanel definition

Is there a way to test the functionality of the form without considering Mixpanel? I am encountering an error as follows. login.component.ts ngOnInit() { Mixpanel.trackEvent("View Screen", { "Screen Name": "Login" }); this.createForm(); } cr ...

Using TypeScript TSX with type parameters

Is it possible to define type parameters in TypeScript TSX syntax? For instance, if I have a class Table<T>, can I use something like <Table<Person> data={...} /> ...

Utilizing an observer to encapsulate a custom React hook- a comprehensive guide

As part of my project, I have developed a unique custom react hook that relies on observable state from the store for its dependencies within useEffect: Here is an example of my custom hook: const useFoo = (() => { const { count } = store; useEff ...

The SpinButton object has an undefined public property called 'value' and the public method 'focus()' is not available

Recently, I've delved into using reactjs, typescript, and Office UI Fabric. However, I'm facing a challenge with one of the components from fabric. In this scenario, I have a simple Product component containing a SpinButton and a DefaultButton. M ...

Closing ngx-bootstrap modal post unit tests

After enabling the CSS style in the unit tests of my Angular app, I noticed that every time a component displaying a modal from ngx-bootstrap appears, it remains visible in the browser even after the unit tests for that component have completed running. T ...

How does the Paginate Pipe effectively retrieve the array length in an Angular 2 application?

I find myself in an interesting situation where I have a piece of code that is functioning within my Angular 2 application - it's generating the correct value, but the method behind its success is unclear to me. Specifically, I am using ng2-paginatio ...

Unit tests in Jasmine disable dispatchers when NGXS store.reset is invoked

I am facing a challenge with an unusual behavior during the unit testing of my NGXS store using Jasmine. Specifically, I am encountering issues when trying to test the DeleteAlerts action : @Action(DeleteAlerts) deleteAlerts(ctx: StateContext<Alert ...

What is the best way to showcase a variable from a typescript file in an HTML file with Angular?

In my TypeScript file, I have the following function: ngOnInit() { if (sessionStorage['loyalPage']) { this.page = Number(sessionStorage['loyalPage']); } this.webService.getLoyalPlayers(this.pag ...

What is the best way to display a loading screen while simultaneously making calls to multiple APIs?

I'm currently working with Angular 8 to develop an application that retrieves responses from various APIs for users. The application is designed to simultaneously call multiple APIs and I require a loading indicator that stops once each API delivers a ...

The deployment of my Node application on Heroku is causing an error message: node-waf is not

I've been trying to deploy my Node.js application on Heroku by linking it to my Github repository and deploying the master branch. Despite experimenting with various methods, I keep encountering the same error every time. You can view the detailed b ...

Transitioning from Webpack to Vite: Resolving Path Alias and Ensuring Proper Imports

Recently, I decided to transition my project from Webpack to Vite with "vite": "^4.3.9",. However, upon running npm start, I encountered the following error: Error: The dependencies imported could not be resolved: In my React Typesc ...

Angular Material Popup - Interactive Map from AGM

I am in the process of developing a material dialog to collect user location information using AGM (angular google maps). I have successfully implemented a map on my main page, but when the dialog is opened, it only shows a blank space instead of the map. ...

In TypeScript, what is the format in which the final type result of a generic utility type is shown?

After utilizing the provided code, I have encountered an issue with retrieving the ultimate type of type A in the editor. Despite my efforts, the editor persistently showcases the composite form of the generic utility, complicating the process of verifyi ...

Tips for retrieving the corresponding second array of objects in ES6

I am working with two arrays of objects and need to find a better solution. array1= [{id:1,name:"samsung"},{id:2,name:"nokia"},{id:3,name:"Lg"}]; array2 = [{id:5,name:"samsung"},{id:2,name:"panasonics"},{id:7,name:"Lg"}]; The expected output should be: W ...

Dealing with server-side errors while utilizing react-query and formik

This login page utilizes formik and I am encountering some issues: const handleLogin = () => { const login = useLoginMutation(); return ( <div> <Formik initialValues={{ email: "", password: "" }} ...

Having trouble with importing GeoJSON from @types/ol package

I am currently working with the following files: tsconfig.json { "compilerOptions": { "lib": [ "es2019", "dom" ], "target": "es5", "module": "system", "allowSyntheticDefaultImports": tru ...

Incorporating a class element within an Angular 2 directive

When working with Angular 2 directives, one way to add an element is by using the following code: this._renderer.createElement(this._el.nativeElement.parentNode, 'div'); After adding the element, how can I set its class and keep a reference to ...

Trouble with Typescript in VSCode made easy

Setting up a VSCode environment for working with TypeScript v2.03 has been challenging. Beginning with a simple vanilla javascript snippet that can be tested in node via the integrated terminal. function Person() { this.name = ""; } Person.prototy ...

What is the best way to pause function execution until a user action is completed within a separate Modal?

I'm currently working on a drink tracking application. Users have the ability to add drinks, but there is also a drink limit feature in place to alert them when they reach their set limit. A modal will pop up with options to cancel or continue adding ...