Can you explain the distinction, if one exists, between a field value and a property within the context of TypeScript and Angular?

For this example, I am exploring two scenarios of a service that exposes an observable named test$. One case utilizes a getter to access the observable, while the other makes it available as a public field.

Do these approaches have any practical distinctions?

I have come across many instances of declarative programming using the field method. Is utilizing a getter not considered declarative in this context?

In the component:

@Component()
export const TestComp {
    private test$ = this.testService.test$; 
    constructor(private testService: TestService){}
}

Case 1: Service with field value:

@Injectable()
export const TestService {
    public test$ = of('test');
}

Case 2: Service with property/getter:

@Injectable()
export const TestService {

    private _test$ = of('test');
    public get test$() {
        return this._test$;
    }
}

Answer №1

Here are the benefits that I believe come with utilizing getters and setters:

  1. Implementing appropriate access specifiers and validation logic before retrieving an object's property.

  2. Avoiding an Anemic domain model, ensuring that classes defining the domain have their own logic and validations rather than relying on external services for all business logic.

To learn more about Anemic domain models, check out this link

Answer №2

In my opinion, the choice comes down to convenience and reducing repetitive code.

Take this scenario for instance:

interface Product{
  readonly name:String;
}

class ProductA implements Product {
  constructor(public readonly name:string){
  }
}

class ProductB implements Product {
  private _name:string;
  get name():string{
    return this.name;
  }
// + some way to set/mutate name internally - constructor/method
}

Both implementations correctly adhere to the Product interface, so from a consumer perspective, it doesn't matter which implementation is used. Therefore, in your situation, it ultimately boils down to the preference of the developer.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Do parallel awaits in JS/TS work only on Chrome browsers exclusively?

Encountering a strange issue with promise resolution behavior in JS/TS. Using Node LTS. It seems that the difference lies in whether the promise resolves to a value that is later read in the code or if it's simply fire-and-forget (void response type). ...

The React Hook Form's useFieldArray feature is causing conflicts with my custom id assignments

My schema includes an id property, but when I implement useFieldArray, it automatically overrides that id. I'm utilizing shadcn-ui Version of react-hook-form: 7.45.0 const { fields, append, remove, update } = useFieldArray<{ id?: string, test?: n ...

Turning off @Output as Observable: A step-by-step guide

I have a query regarding unsubscribing Outputs in Angular. While I am aware that EventEmitter is automatically cleaned up, there was a time when I needed to use an Observable as my Output. Specifically, I wanted to take an Output that emitted events at mos ...

The functionality of verifying the type of an item in a list using Typescript is not functioning

In my TypeScript code, I am working with a type called NameValue and another one called MixedStuff. type NameValue = { name: string; value: string }; type MixedStuff = NameValue | string; function stripTwoChars(stuffs: MixedStuff[]): string { let st ...

Discover the data type of the subfield within an interface or type in Typescript

Check out the interface and type declarations provided below: interface Foo { bar: { a: number b: string } } type Foo = { bar: { a: number b: string } } Is it possible to obtain the type definitions for "baz"? This will allow us ...

Tips for incorporating external AMD modules with Angular2 using WebPack

In my current project using Angular2, TypeScript, and WebPack, I am looking to incorporate the Esri ArcGIS JavaScript API. The API can be accessed from the following URL: By importing Map from 'esri/Map';, I aim to import the corresponding modul ...

Supporting right-to-left (RTL) localization in Angular 2 and later versions

When it comes to incorporating right-to-left (RTL) support into a localized Angular 2+ application, particularly for languages like Hebrew and Arabic, what is considered the best approach? I have explored various tutorials, including Internationalization ...

A more efficient method for querying documents based on ids that are not in a given list and then sorting them by a specific publish date

After implementing the code provided below, I noticed that the performance tests indicate each request takes a second or longer to complete. My goal is to enhance this speed by at least 10 times. The bottleneck seems to be caused by the NOT operator resu ...

Utilizing TypeScript with Vue3 to Pass a Pinia Store as a Prop

My current stack includes Typescript, Pinia, and Vue3. I have a MenuButton component that I want to be able to pass a Pinia store for managing the menu open state and related actions. There are multiple menus in the application, each using the same store f ...

Encountering the "ExpressionChangedAfterItHasBeenCheckedError" in Angular 2

As I try to fill in multiple rows within a table that I've created, the table gets populated successfully. However, an error message pops up: "ExpressionChangedAfterItHasBeenCheckedError: Expression has changed after it was checked. Previous valu ...

When attempting to retrieve information from the API, an error occurred stating that property 'subscribe' is not found in type 'void'

I've attempted to use this code for fetching data from an API. Below is the content of my product.service.ts file: import { Injectable } from '@angular/core'; import { HttpClient } from '@angular/common/http'; import { map, Observ ...

What is the method for accessing an anonymous function within a JavaScript Object?

Currently facing an issue with a Node.js package called Telegraf, which is a bot framework. The problem arises when trying to create typings for it in TypeScript. The package exports the following: module.exports = Object.assign(Telegraf, { Composer, ...

What is the process for launching the application directly to a specific component?

Hello everyone, I'm currently developing my app using Angular and have just started implementing routing. My question is, how can I ensure that the HomeComponent loads automatically when the site is opened? ...

Is there a way to set an antd checkbox as checked even when its value is falsy within an antd formItem?

I'm currently looking to "invert" the behavior of the antd checkbox component. I am seeking to have the checkbox unchecked when the value/initialValue of the antD formItem is false. Below is my existing code: <FormItem label="Include skills list ...

Jest throws an error: require function is not defined

I've been struggling with an issue in Angular for the past 3 days. I'm using [email protected] and [email protected]. I even tried downgrading and testing with LTS versions of node and npm, but I keep encountering the same error. Here ...

Limit the parameter of a TypeScript method decorator based on the method's type

Is it possible to generically restrict the argument of a method decorator based on the type of the method it is applied to? I attempted to obtain the method's type that the decorator is applied to using TypedPropertyDescriptor<Method>. However, ...

cycle through options of radio buttons

How can I display items of radio buttons, with the values of these items coming from a backend api? <div class="input-group col-md-9 input-group-sm"> <label>gender</label> </div> <!-- TO CORRECT ...

Is it possible for the NativeScript CLI to generate spec files automatically?

As I delved into NativeScript today, I couldn't help but notice that the tabbed template app it generated didn't come with spec files like those generated by Angular CLI. Is there a way to incorporate Karma and Jasmine into the app creation proce ...

Issue Detected: The function this.route.params.flatMap is not recognized

Seeking guidance on transitioning to id, or a similar concept that's hard to articulate. Upon clicking a button to navigate to a specific user, encountering the following error: ERROR TypeError: this.route.params.flatMap is not a function at UserSho ...

Error Alert: Next.js TypeScript is reporting that the necessary packages are missing from your setup

As I work on developing a basic Next.js website using their TypeScript starter, everything was going smoothly with the 'yarn dev' command. However, out of nowhere, I started encountering an error message whenever I tried to run 'yarn dev&apo ...