Differences between Object and Typecasted Literal Object in TypeScript

I'm currently grappling with the decision of whether to use an interface or a class in my TypeScript code. Coming from a background in C#, I find the strictness of classes appealing, but there is also a certain allure to the flexibility offered by interfaces.

interface IFoo
{
   bar: string;
}

...

let array: IFoo[];

array.push(<IFoo>{ bar: "test" });

Alternatively,

class Foo
{
   bar: string;
}

...

let array: Foo[];
let obj = new Foo();

obj.bar = "test";

array.push(obj);

I've searched online for information on the pros and cons of both approaches, but haven't been able to find a clear answer. At this point, I feel torn between the two options and unsure of which one to choose. Any advice or insights would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you.

Answer №1

When working with JavaScript, we do not have traditional classes. Instead, we use plain objects that have prototype functionality, similar to "hash-tables". Functions in JavaScript are treated as objects, with some added syntax sugar on top.

Although this explanation is not entirely academic and omits certain details, you can explore the concept further by trying out the example below in a browser's debugger:

var parent = {
   method1: function() { return 1 } ,
   method2: function() { return 2 }
}
var child = Object.create(parent)
child.method2 = function() { return '2a' }

// More examples and explanations provided in the original text.

In ES2015, classes were introduced to simplify object-oriented programming in JavaScript by abstracting away some of the complexity involved in working with objects and prototypes.

Turning our attention back to TypeScript...

var a : { b : string }
a.b = '4'

The notation { b : string } in TypeScript serves as a type annotation for variables and does not impact the generated JavaScript code directly. When using interfaces or type annotations, no additional code is added to the final JS output.

However, when utilizing class, TypeScript generates both concrete JS code (prototype object) and adds elements to the type realm for assistance and linting purposes.

In conclusion, there is no significant issue with either approach, but favoring interfaces over classes aligns more closely with common JavaScript coding practices. Some schools of thought even discourage heavy reliance on classes in favor of alternative patterns.

Answer №2

It is crucial to initialize the value of array in both examples, not just declare a type for it. To do so, consider implementing it like this:

let array : Array<IFoo> = [];
array.push( {bar: "test" } );

The true advantage of using a class will only be evident when you incorporate additional members such as methods or calculated properties. In such cases, employing new Foo(...) would be recommended.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

What is the approach to constructing an observable that triggers numerous observables depending on the preceding outcome?

One of my endpoints returns { ids: [1, 2, 3, 45] }, while the other endpoint provides values for a given id like { id: 3, value: 30, active: true }. I am currently attempting to create an observable that will call the first endpoint and then, for each id r ...

Unable to import the Node.js array in the import() file

I have encountered an issue while building an array path for the Router.group function. The parameter passed to Router.group is added to the end of the this.groupPath array, but when I check the array data within an import(), it appears to be empty. What c ...

Is there a way to verify if a component contains a child node with the tag <template></template>?

Consider the scenario with MyComponent: <div [my-component]="'text'"></div> Within the code, I have access to this.viewContainerRef, which refers to the DOM node itself (<div>). However, for customization purposes, a user mig ...

Setting up Typescript for a Node.js project configuration

I am facing an issue with my simple class class Blob { } After compiling it with TypeScript, I encountered the following error message: ../../../usr/lib/node_modules/typescript/lib/lib.dom.d.ts:2537:11 2537 interface Blob { ~~~~ ...

What is the best method for obtaining XML within typescript react in the bpmn-js/lib/Modeler?

After importing my BPMN XML in Model using importXML and setting bpmnModeler to bpmnModelerClone, I now need to retrieve the BPMN from bpmnModelerClone. How can I achieve this? Below is the code snippet showing how I imported XML and set bpmnModeler to bp ...

What is the best way to mock an internal function within my route using sinon?

Currently, I have my own internal function defined in the greatRoute.ts file: //in greatRoute.ts async function _secretString(param: string): Promise<string> { ... } router .route('/foo/bar/:secret') .get( async (...) => { ...

When additional lines are drawn elsewhere on the HTML5 Canvas, the diagonal lines will gradually appear thicker and more pronounced

For horizontal and vertical lines, using a translation of 0.5 for odd stroke widths results in crisper and sharper lines. But what about diagonal lines? Link to jsfiddle <!DOCTYPE html> <html lang="en"> <body style="background: black"& ...

What methods can TypeScript employ to comprehend this situation?

There's an interesting scenario when it comes to assigning a variable of type unknown to another variable. TypeScript requires us to perform type checking on the unknown variable, but how does TypeScript handle this specific situation? It appears that ...

Call a function within a stateless component in a React application

I have a question regarding my React component. I am attempting to call the function ButtonAppBar within my stateless component, but the TypeScript compiler is throwing an error stating '{' expected. I'm unsure whether I need to pass it to m ...

Tips for showing a DialogBox when a blur event occurs and avoiding the re-firing of onBlur when using the DialogBox

Using React and Material UI: In the code snippet provided below, there is a table with TextFields in one of its columns. When a TextField triggers an onBlur/focusOut event, it calls the validateItem() method that sends a server request to validate the ite ...

Placing options and a clickable element within a collapsible navigation bar

Within my angular project, there are 4 input fields where users need to enter information, along with a button labeled Set All which will populate them. https://i.sstatic.net/1GGh1.png I am wondering how I can organize these input fields and the button i ...

tips for accessing the useState value once it has been initialized

When using the state hook in my code, I have: const [features, setFeatures] = useState([]) const [medicalProblem, setMedicalProblem] = useState([]) The medicalProblem variable will be initially populated with a response from an API call: useEf ...

Struggling with making updates to an interface through declaration merging

I am encountering challenges with implementing declaration merging on an interface from a library that I created. An example illustrating the issue using StackBlitz can be viewed here: https://stackblitz.com/edit/typescript-qxvrte (issues persist in both ...

Tips for sending a file rather than a json object in nextjs

Is there a way to send a file from either route.ts or page.ts, regardless of its location in the file-system? Currently, I am using the following code in my back-end python + flask... @app.route("/thumbnail/<string:filename>") def get_file ...

I'm having trouble with Angular pipes in certain areas... but I must say, Stackblitz is truly incredible

Encountering this issue: ERROR in src\app\shopping-cart-summary\shopping-cart-summary.component.html(15,42): : Property '$' does not exist on type 'ShoppingCartSummaryComponent'. The error disappears when I remove the c ...

Steps for confirming whether each element in the array includes the specified search string using Typescript and protractor

How can I verify if each element in an array contains a specific search string in Typescript/Protractor? The issue I faced was that the console statements were returning false because they searched for exact matches instead of the search string. Any sugg ...

The correlation between a TypeScript class and an interface bearing an identical name

I have been struggling to find clear documentation or explanation for the unique relationship between a TypeScript class and an interface that share the same name. What is the significance of having an interface with the same name as a class? Why does a ...

Difficulty encountered while trying to link an abstract class with Redux state using redux-thunk

My approach to using redux-thunk and class components in React follows a basic pattern. The code below shows how a class definition MyClass is exported, correctly connected to state through mapStateToProps, and has access to actions from mapDispatchToProps ...

Receiving JSON data in TypeScript and displaying it in a structured table format

I am just starting to learn TypeScript, I need to be able to handle JSON data of varying sizes... Once I receive the data, I want to display it in a table format... The structure of my JSON data will resemble this: [{"regionID":1 "regionname":"Can"}, ...

The 'import type' declaration cannot be parsed by the Babel parser

Whenever I attempt to utilize parser.parse("import type {Element} from 'react-devtools-shared/src/frontend/types';", {sourceType: "unambiguous"}); for parsing the statement, I come across an error stating Unexpected token, exp ...