Exploring methods to broaden the functionality of components through inheritance

My goal is to develop extensions for existing Angular 2 components without having to completely rewrite them. I want any changes made to the base component to also automatically apply to its derived components.

To illustrate my point, consider the following scenario:

We have a base component called app/base-panel.component.ts:

import {Component, Input} from 'angular2/core';

@Component({
    selector: 'base-panel',
    template: '<div class="panel" [style.background-color]="color" (click)="onClick($event)">{{content}}</div>',
    styles: [`
    .panel{
    padding: 50px;
  }
  `]
})
export class BasePanelComponent { 

  @Input() content: string;

  color: string = "red";

  onClick(event){
    console.log("Click color: " + this.color);
  }
}

Now, let's say we want to create a derivative component, app/my-panel.component.ts, where we only need to change one basic behavior of the base component, such as the color:

import {Component} from 'angular2/core';
import {BasePanelComponent} from './base-panel.component'

@Component({
    selector: 'my-panel',
    template: '<div class="panel" [style.background-color]="color" (click)="onClick($event)">{{content}}</div>',
    styles: [`
    .panel{
    padding: 50px;
  }
  `]
})
export class MyPanelComponent extends BasePanelComponent{

  constructor() {
    super();
    this.color = "blue";
  }
}

View complete working example in Plunker

This example is simplistic but highlights the challenge of inheriting components in Angular 2 effectively without excessive repetition.

In the implementation of the derivative component app/my-panel.component.ts, much of the code was duplicated, and only the class BasePanelComponent was truly inherited. The @Component decorator had to be duplicated entirely, including the parts that remained unchanged, like selector: 'my-panel'.

I'm wondering if there is a way to fully inherit a component in Angular 2, preserving the annotations like @Component without repeating them.

Edit 1 - Feature Request

I submitted a feature request on GitHub: Extend/Inherit angular2 components annotations #7968

Edit 2 - Closed Request

The request has been closed due to technical limitations, as detailed here. Unfortunately, it seems merging decorators for inheritance might not be feasible, leaving us with limited options. I shared my thoughts on this issue in the comments.

Answer №1

Another Approach:

Thierry Templier's answer provides an alternative method to solve the issue.

After discussing with Thierry Templier, I have come up with a different working example that fulfills my requirements as a substitute for the mentioned inheritance limitation:

1 - Implement a custom decorator:

export function CustomComponent(annotation: any) {
  return function (target: Function) {
    var parentTarget = Object.getPrototypeOf(target.prototype).constructor;
    var parentAnnotations = Reflect.getMetadata('annotations', parentTarget);

    var parentAnnotation = parentAnnotations[0];
    Object.keys(parentAnnotation).forEach(key => {
      if (isPresent(parentAnnotation[key])) {
        // check if annotation is typeof function
        if(typeof annotation[key] === 'function'){
          annotation[key] = annotation[key].call(this, parentAnnotation[key]);
        }else if(
        // force override in base annotation
        !isPresent(annotation[key])
        ){
          annotation[key] = parentAnnotation[key];
        }
      }
    });

    var metadata = new Component(annotation);

    Reflect.defineMetadata('annotations', [ metadata ], target);
  }
}

2 - Create a Base Component with @Component decorator:

@Component({
  // set base selector for testing property override
  selector: 'master',
  template: `
    <div>Test</div>
  `
})
export class AbstractComponent {

}

3 - Define Sub component with @CustomComponent decorator:

@CustomComponent({
  // override property annotation
  //selector: 'sub',
  selector: (parentSelector) => { return parentSelector + 'sub'}
})
export class SubComponent extends AbstractComponent {
  constructor() {
  }
}

Check out the complete example on Plunkr.

Answer №2

Recently, Angular 2 version 2.3 was launched with a noteworthy addition of native component inheritance feature. This update allows developers to inherit and override various aspects, except for templates and styles. For further information, you can refer to the following sources:

  • Exploring new features in Angular 2.3

  • Understanding Component Inheritance in Angular 2

  • Check out this Plunkr demo showcasing component inheritance

Answer №3

update

Starting from version 2.3.0-rc.0, Angular now supports component inheritance.

original

My preferred approach has been to separate the template and styles into distinct files, such as *html and *.css respectively, and then specify them using templateUrl and styleUrls for easy reusability.

@Component {
    selector: 'my-panel',
    templateUrl: 'app/components/panel.html', 
    styleUrls: ['app/components/panel.css']
}
export class MyPanelComponent extends BasePanelComponent

Answer №4

With the recent update in TypeScript 2.2 now supporting Mixins using Class expressions, there is an improved method for implementing Mixins on Components. While Component inheritance has been available since angular 2.3 (discussion) or through custom decorators as mentioned in other solutions, Mixins offer distinct advantages when it comes to reusing behavior across components:

  • Mixins provide more flexibility in composition, allowing you to mix and match them with existing components or combine multiple Mixins to create new Components.
  • The linear nature of Mixin composition makes it easier to comprehend within a class inheritance hierarchy.
  • Mixins can help avoid complications associated with decorators and annotations commonly found in component inheritance (discussion).

To fully grasp how Mixins operate, it is recommended to review the TypeScript 2.2 announcement linked above and explore the related discussions in GitHub issues pertaining to Angular.

You will need the following types defined:

export type Constructor<T> = new (...args: any[]) => T;

export class MixinRoot {
}

A practical example involves creating a Destroyable mixin that assists components in managing subscriptions that require disposal during ngOnDestroy:

export function Destroyable<T extends Constructor<{}>>(Base: T) {
  return class Mixin extends Base implements OnDestroy {
    private readonly subscriptions: Subscription[] = [];

    protected registerSubscription(sub: Subscription) {
      this.subscriptions.push(sub);
    }

    public ngOnDestroy() {
      this.subscriptions.forEach(x => x.unsubscribe());
      this.subscriptions.length = 0; // clear memory
    }
  };
}

To incorporate the Destroyable mixin into a Component, you define your component as follows:

export class DashboardComponent extends Destroyable(MixinRoot) 
    implements OnInit, OnDestroy { ... }

It's important to note that MixinRoot becomes necessary when extending a Mixin composition. You can extend multiple mixins seamlessly e.g. A extends B(C(D)). This approach exemplifies the straightforward linearization of mixins discussed earlier, essentially forming an inheritance hierarchy A -> B -> C - > D.

In scenarios where you want to apply Mixins to an existing class, you can do so like this:

const MyClassWithMixin = MyMixin(MyClass);

However, incorporating Mixins directly into Components and

Directives</code seems to work best using the first method, especially considering they also require decoration with <code>@Component
or @Directive.

Answer №5

At this point in time, Angular 2 does not support component inheritance. However, if you are using TypeScript, you can achieve class inheritance by extending one class from another with the syntax

class MyClass extends OtherClass { ... }
. To request component inheritance features in Angular 2, consider participating in the Angular 2 project on GitHub at https://github.com/angular/angular/issues.

Answer №6

After delving into the CDK and material libraries, it's evident that while they utilize inheritance, content projection reigns supreme in my opinion. Check out this resource here for more insight on why "the key problem with this design" persists.

In my view, steering clear of inheriting or extending components is the way to go. Here's why:

If an abstract class shared by multiple components houses common logic: opt for a service or craft a new TypeScript class that can be utilized across those components.

If the abstract class... consists of shared variables or onClick functionalities, it may lead to redundant code within the HTML views of the extending components. This practice should be discouraged, and any mutual HTML content should be segregated into separate Component(s). These part(s) can then be shared among the relevant components.

Have I overlooked other justifications for employing an abstract class for components?

A recent example involved components extending AutoUnsubscribe:

import { Subscription } from 'rxjs';
import { OnDestroy } from '@angular/core';
export abstract class AutoUnsubscribeComponent implements OnDestroy {
  protected infiniteSubscriptions: Array<Subscription>;

  constructor() {
    this.infiniteSubscriptions = [];
  }

  ngOnDestroy() {
    this.infiniteSubscriptions.forEach((subscription) => {
      subscription.unsubscribe();
    });
  }
}

This scenario proved problematic as across a vast codebase, infiniteSubscriptions.push() was only implemented 10 times. Furthermore, importing & extending AutoUnsubscribe actually demanded more code than simply adding mySubscription.unsubscribe() within the component's ngOnDestroy() method, which also necessitated additional logic regardless.

Answer №7

If you are in need of an updated solution, I found Fernando's answer to be incredibly helpful. The only change I made was using Component instead of the deprecated ComponentMetadata.

Here is the complete code for the Custom Decorator file named CustomDecorator.ts:

import 'zone.js';
import 'reflect-metadata';
import { Component } from '@angular/core';
import { isPresent } from "@angular/platform-browser/src/facade/lang";

export function CustomComponent(annotation: any) {
  return function (target: Function) {
    var parentTarget = Object.getPrototypeOf(target.prototype).constructor;
    var parentAnnotations = Reflect.getMetadata('annotations', parentTarget);

    var parentAnnotation = parentAnnotations[0];
    Object.keys(parentAnnotation).forEach(key => {
      if (isPresent(parentAnnotation[key])) {
        // check if annotation type is a function
        if(typeof annotation[key] === 'function'){
          annotation[key] = annotation[key].call(this, parentAnnotation[key]);
        }else if(
          // force override in annotation base
          !isPresent(annotation[key])
        ){
          annotation[key] = parentAnnotation[key];
        }
      }
    });

    var metadata = new Component(annotation);

    Reflect.defineMetadata('annotations', [ metadata ], target);
  }
}

To use this Custom Decorator, import it into your new component file named sub-component.component.ts and replace @Component with @CustomComponent like so:

import { CustomComponent } from './CustomDecorator';
import { AbstractComponent } from 'path/to/file';

...

@CustomComponent({
  selector: 'subcomponent'
})
export class SubComponent extends AbstractComponent {

  constructor() {
    super();
  }

  // Write your additional logic here!
}

Answer №8

Just like typescript class inheritance, components can be extended by overriding the selector with a new name while maintaining the functionality of Input() and Output() properties from the Parent Component.

Additional Information:

The @Component is a decorator applied during the declaration of a class, not on objects.

Decorators add metadata to the class object that cannot be accessed through inheritance. To achieve Decorator Inheritance, consider creating a custom decorator as shown in the example below.

export function CustomComponent(annotation: any) {
    return function (target: Function) {
    var parentTarget = Object.getPrototypeOf(target.prototype).constructor;

    // Retrieve metadata from parent class
    var parentAnnotations = Reflect.getMetadata('annotations', parentTarget);
    var parentParamTypes = Reflect.getMetadata('design:paramtypes', parentTarget);
    var parentPropMetadata = Reflect.getMetadata('propMetadata', parentTarget);
    var parentParameters = Reflect.getMetadata('parameters', parentTarget);

    var parentAnnotation = parentAnnotations[0];

    // Merge parent annotation with current annotation
    Object.keys(parentAnnotation).forEach(key => {
    if (isPresent(parentAnnotation[key])) {
        if (!isPresent(annotation[key])) {
        annotation[key] = parentAnnotation[key];
        }
    }
    });
    
    // Update metadata for current class
    var metadata = new ComponentMetadata(annotation);

    Reflect.defineMetadata('annotations', [ metadata ], target);
    };
};

For more information, please refer to: https://medium.com/@ttemplier/angular2-decorators-and-class-inheritance-905921dbd1b7

Answer №9

To extend functionality in Angular, you can utilize @Input, @Output, @ViewChild, and more. Take a look at this example:

@Component({
    template: ''
})
export class BaseComponent {
    @Input() someInput: any = 'something';

    @Output() someOutput: EventEmitter<void> = new EventEmitter<void>();
}

@Component({
    selector: 'app-derived',
    template: '<div (click)="someOutput.emit()">{{someInput}}</div>',
    providers: [
        { provide: BaseComponent, useExisting: DerivedComponent }
    ]
})
export class DerivedComponent {

}

Answer №10

To implement inheritance in Angular, you can extend a parent class in the child class and pass the parent class parameters in the constructor using super().

  1. Parent class:
@Component({
  selector: 'teams-players-box',
  templateUrl: '/maxweb/app/app/teams-players-box.component.html'
})
export class TeamsPlayersBoxComponent {
  public _userProfile: UserProfile;
  public _user_img: any;
  public _box_class: string = "about-team teams-blockbox";
  public fullname: string;
  public _index: any;
  public _isView: string;
  indexnumber: number;

  constructor(
    public _userProfilesSvc: UserProfiles,
    public _router: Router,
  ){}
  1. Child class:
@Component({  
  selector: '[teams-players-eligibility]',  
  templateUrl: '/maxweb/app/app/teams-players-eligibility.component.html'  
})  
export class TeamsPlayersEligibilityComponent extends TeamsPlayersBoxComponent {  
  constructor (public _userProfilesSvc: UserProfiles,
    public _router: Router) {  
      super(_userProfilesSvc,_router);  
    }  
  }

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Parsing errors occurred when using the ngFor template: Parser identified an unexpected token at a specific column

In my Angular CLI-built application, I have a component with a model named globalModel. This model is populated with user inputs from the previous page and displayed to the user in an HTML table on the current page. Here's how it's done: <inp ...

Unable to showcase the content inside the input box

I am having trouble displaying a default value in an input field. Here is how I attempted to do it: <input matInput formControlName="name" value="Ray"> Unfortunately, the value is not appearing as expected. You can view my code o ...

Tips for sending a parameter to an onClick handler function in a component generated using array.map()

I've been developing a web application that allows users to store collections. There is a dashboard page where all the user's collections are displayed in a table format, with each row representing a collection and columns showing the collection ...

Mapping a TypeScript tuple into a new tuple by leveraging Array.map

I attempted to transform a TypeScript tuple into another tuple using Array.map in the following manner: const tuple1: [number, number, number] = [1, 2, 3]; const tuple2: [number, number, number] = tuple1.map(x => x * 2); console.log(tuple2); TypeScript ...

Tips for sending arguments to translations

I am currently implementing vuejs 3 using TS. I have set up my translation files in TypeScript as shown below: index.ts: export default { 'example': 'example', } To use the translations, I simply do: {{ $t('example') }} N ...

The conversion to ObjectId was unsuccessful for the user ID

I'm looking to develop a feature where every time a user creates a new thread post, it will be linked to the User model by adding the newly created thread's ID to the threads array of the user. However, I'm running into an issue when trying ...

Learn the process of importing different types from a `.ts` file into a `.d.ts` file

In my electron project, the structure looks like this: // preload.ts import { contextBridge, ipcRenderer, IpcRendererEvent } from 'electron' import { IpcChannels } from '@shared/channelNames' contextBridge.exposeInMainWorld('api&a ...

Organize an array based on its ratio

I am attempting to organize an array based on the win and lose ratio of each player. This is how my code currently looks: const array = [{playerName: 'toto', win: 2, lose: 2}, {playerName: 'titi', win: 0, lose: 0}, {playerName: &apo ...

Tips for transferring a value from a component class to a function that is external to the class in angular

Is there a way to pass a variable value from a component class to a function outside the class? I've been struggling to make it work. Whenever I click the button, I receive an error message saying "cannot read property divide of undefined". Here' ...

Simple Steps to View Angular Logs in Terminal

Upon initializing my Angular project, I utilized the npm start command to kickstart the application. The console.log() function displays logs exclusively in the browser console window. Is there a way to view these logs in the terminal window? ...

Deploy your Angular website for absolutely no cost on Firebase by leveraging the Command Line Interface

Looking to deploy an Angular application on Firebase cloud for free using the CLI? Recently started delving into Angular 9 and exploring Firebase's cloud server capabilities, I'm interested in seeing how simple it is to deploy an app on Firebase. ...

Currently, I am working with Angular 11 and encountered some errors while trying to embark on a new project

Command: ng serve Error: Cannot find module '@angular-devkit/build-angular/package.json' View details in "/tmp/ng-lQbnUK/angular-errors.log". These errors occurred when I tried to create the project: Installing packages (npm)... npm WARN depreca ...

Generating images with HTML canvas only occurs once before stopping

I successfully implemented an image generation button using Nextjs and the HTML canvas element. The functionality works almost flawlessly - when a user clicks the "Generate Image" button, it creates an image containing smaller images with labels underneath ...

The installation process was unsuccessful due to an error in the postinstall script for [email protected]

While attempting to run npm install, an error message is displayed: Failed at the <a href="/cdn-cgi/l/email-protection" class="__cf_email__" data-cfemail="e38d8c8786ce90829090a3d7cdd6cdd3">[email protected]</a> postinstall script. I hav ...

defining data types based on specific conditions within an object {typescript}

Can someone help with implementing conditional function typing in an object? let obj = { function myfunc (input: string): number; function myfunc (input: number): string; myfunc: function (input: string|number):string|number { ... } } I've been ...

What is the best way to define the typings path for tsify?

My TypeScript sources are located in the directory: src/game/ts The configuration file tsconfig.json can be found at: src/game/ts/tsconfig.json Additionally, the typings are stored in: src/game/ts/typings When running tsc with the command: tsc --p s ...

Error: Unable to access 'match' property of an undefined value

After upgrading my Angular application from version 12 to 13, I encountered an error during unit testing. Chrome Headless 94.0.4606.61 (Windows 10) AppComponent should create the app FAILED TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading &a ...

Obtain the initial URL when initializing an Angular application

In the process of creating an Angular application for a landing page of a SaaS platform, the SaaS redirects to the Angular app using the URL http://localhost:4200/token=<token>. Shortly after, Angular switches to the home component at http://localhos ...

What happens when i18next's fallbackLng takes precedence over changeLanguage?

I am currently developing a Node.js app with support for multi-language functionality based on the URL query string. I have implemented the i18next module in my project. Below is a snippet from my main index.ts file: ... import i18next from 'i18next& ...

Troubleshooting Angular 2: Instances of Classes Not Being Updated When Retrieving Parameters

I am facing an issue with the following code snippet: testFunction() { let params = <any>{}; if (this.searchTerm) { params.search = this.searchTerm; } // change the URL this.router.navigate(['job-search'], {q ...