Guide on simulating rxjs/Websocket in angular for performing Unit Testing

I have developed a service that manages websocket communication with a server and I am looking to create unit tests for it. However, I am facing challenges in mocking rxjs/Websocket.

While searching for a solution, I came across a similar question here, but it does not seem to work with the latest version of rxjs. Any assistance on this matter would be greatly appreciated.

One approach I considered was injecting WebSocket as a service and then mocking the service in my test. However, this feels like a workaround and I am hoping for a more efficient solution.

Below is my code snippet:

socket.service.ts

//imports 

@Injectable()
export class SocketService {
  private baseUrl = ENV.WS_WORKSPACES_URL;

  socket$: WebSocketSubject<any>;

  constructor(
    private userService: UserService
  ) { }

  initSocket(): void {
    this.socket$ = webSocket(`${this.baseUrl}clusters`);
    const user = this.userService.getUser();

    if (user) {
      this.send({token: user.token});
    }
  }

  send(data: any): void {
    this.socket$.next(data);
  }
}

socket.service.spec.ts

//imports

describe("SocketService", () => {
  let service: SocketService;
  let userServiceSpy;
  let socket;
  const token = "whatever";

  beforeEach(() => {
    userServiceSpy = jasmine.createSpyObj("UserService", ["getUser"]);
    userServiceSpy.getUser.and.returnValue(null);
    socket = {next: jasmine.createSpy()};
    TestBed.configureTestingModule({
      providers: [
        {provide: UserService, useValue: userServiceSpy},
        SocketService
      ]
    });

    service = TestBed.inject(SocketService);

    socket = {} //this should be my mock
  });

  it("should be created", () => {
    expect(service).toBeTruthy();
  });

  it("should open connection", () => {
    service.initSocket();

    expect(socket.next).not.toHaveBeenCalled();
    expect(service.socket$).toBeDefined();
  });

  it("should open connection with auth", () => {
    const user = {token};
    userServiceSpy.getUser.and.returnValue(user);

    service.initSocket();
    expect(socket.next).toHaveBeenCalledWith(user);
  });

  it("should send a message", () => {
    service.initSocket();

    const message = {};
    service.send(message);

    expect(socket.next).toHaveBeenCalledWith(message);
  });
});

Answer №1

This puzzle was quite challenging to crack, but the key solution lies in making the mock injectable.

It might seem like a workaround initially, as it involves unnecessary work. Most Angular-specific libraries offer a service that serves as a factory for decoupling, which is excellent. However, rxjs, despite its heavy use in the Angular framework, is not an Angular library.

In short, you need to encapsulate `webSocket` within something injectable.

A Brief Overview of the Core Issue

The general unmockability of the `webSocket` constructor stems from how modules function. While there are some workarounds depending on the module types used and control over exporting modules, they are temporary fixes. The trend towards read-only imports has gradually rendered most existing workarounds ineffective. This issue on Jasmine's GitHub discusses the workarounds and eventually outlines why finding a universal solution remains elusive.

So, What's the Game Plan?

Jasmine offers official guidance in its FAQ:

  1. Utilize dependency injection for components requiring mocking, allowing you to inject a spy or mock object from the spec. This method often leads to improved maintainability in both specs and test code. The need to mock modules typically indicates tightly coupled code, urging developers to address the root cause rather than rely on testing tools as solutions.

Solid advice indeed! It highlights the dependency nature of the issue, with the desired functionality closely intertwined with the constructor. On another note, faulting the rxjs team proves challenging, given the situation at hand. Solving this problem demands a solution tailored to the framework.

You have two viable options at your disposal:

  1. Create a service.
  2. Formulate a factory function.

Developing a Service

While straightforward, this approach surprisingly wasn't my initial attempt. Simply create a new service with a single public method sporting the same signature:

@Injectable()
export class WebSocketFactoryService {

  constructor(){}

  public makeSocket<T>(urlConfigOrSource: string | WebSocketSubjectConfig<T>): WebSocketSubject<T> {
    return webSocket<T>(urlConfigOrSource);
  }
}

Using Constructor Injection

This method may appear a bit messy, but it eliminates the need to craft a separate file for the factory service. Having multiple tools in your arsenal always proves beneficial:

Check out the StackBlitz link featuring a test suite for an application necessitating websocket creation within a service and subsequent injection into a component (no more "missing core-js" woes either). Interestingly, Angular.io provides a guide for this specific scenario, albeit locating it took some effort.

Start by defining an InjectionToken since this isn't a class:

// I opted for 'rxjsWebsocket' import naming solely for webSocket usage in my service
import { webSocket as rxjsWebsocket, WebSocketSubject } from 'rxjs/webSocket';

// Fascinatingly, utilizing 'typeof rxjsWebsocket' accurately denotes 'whatever that thing is'
export const WEBSOCKET_CTOR = new InjectionToken<typeof rxjsWebsocket>(
  'rxjs/webSocket.webSocket', // Error indicator if missing
  {
    providedIn: 'root',
    factory: () => rxjsWebsocket, // Default creation mechanism unless a custom provider is designated, as we'll do in the spec
  }
);

Subsequently, instruct your Service to treat it as any other dependency for injection:

@Injectable({
  providedIn: 'root',
})
export class SocketService {
  socket$: WebSocketSubject<any>;

  constructor(
    @Inject(WEBSOCKET_CTOR) private _webSocket: typeof rxjsWebsocket
  ) {
    this.socket$ = this._webSocket<any>('https://stackoverflow.com/');
  }

  messages(): Observable<any> {
    return this.socket$.asObservable();
  }

  send(data: any): void {
    this.socket$.next(data);
  }
}

Problem solved!

Tackling Test Scenarios

Oh wait, the tests! Initially, you must devise a mock replica. Various methods exist, but I employed the following setup for my injection token version:

// Simulating the websocket activity
let fakeSocket: Subject<any>; // Exposed for spying purposes and emulating server interactions
const fakeSocketCtor = jasmine
  .createSpy('WEBSOCKET_CTOR')
  .and.callFake(() => fakeSocket); // Fake invocation required for continuous reassignment to fakeSocket

If you opted for a service instead, consider leveraging a spy object:

const fakeSocketFactory = jasmine.createSpyObj(WebSocketFactoryService, 'makeSocket');
fakeSocketFactory.makeSocket.and.callFake(() => fakeSocket);

Regardless of your choice, having an openly accessible subject simplifies resetting efforts.

Creating the service entails using the constructor provided!

  beforeEach(() => {
    // Instantiate a fresh socket to prevent lingering values across tests
    fakeSocket = new Subject<any>();
    // Apply spying tactics to avoid subscription requirements for verification purposes

    spyOn(fakeSocket, 'next').and.callThrough();

    // Reset your spies
    fakeSocketCtor.calls.reset();

    // Employ the ctor to establish the service
    service = new SocketService(fakeSocketCtor);
    // Alternatively, leverage 'fakeSocketFactory' for different approach
  });

Now you're ready to delve into the realm of testing Observables, just as you intended hours ago!

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Troubleshooting a Missing Call Display Issue in Angular2 API

Greetings, I am a new web developer and I have been tasked with creating a prototype Inventory Page using Angular2. Please bear with me as my code may not be perfect. In the snippet below, you'll notice that we are calling our base back-end API (&apo ...

Definition of type instantiation in TypeScript

When utilizing the mynew function with a specified array of classes, I am encountering an error related to defining unknown. How can I modify this definition in order to eliminate the error? export interface Type<T> extends Function { new (...arg ...

Navigating using ViewChild in Ionic 2 Beta

I recently updated my Ionic 2 app to use Angular 2 RC1, which has been a great improvement. However, I am facing some challenges with the routing implementation. Despite following the update guide, I still encounter issues with my navigation component bein ...

"In the realm of RxJS, there are two potent events that hold the power to

In my current situation, I encountered the following scenario: I have a service that makes Http calls to an API and requires access to user data to set the authentication header. Below is the function that returns the observable used in the template: get ...

The 'locale' parameter is inherently assigned the type of 'any' in this context

I have been using i18n to translate a Vue3 project with TypeScript, and I am stuck on getting the change locale button to work. Whenever I try, it returns an error regarding the question title. Does anyone have any insights on how to resolve this issue? ...

Angular-cli does not come with the Bootstrap framework pre-installed

After installing the bootstrap framework to my angular2 project through npm, I noticed that it appeared in the node-modules folder. However, upon checking the angular-cli file, I discovered that the boostrap script and css were not included. "apps": [ ...

Troubleshooting TypeScript Modules in Visual Studio 2015 Update 2: Fixing the 'require' Undefined Error

While working in Visual Studio 2015 Enterprise with Update 2 installed, I decided to create a new TypeScript project called TypeScriptHTMLApp1 using the default template and settings. As part of this project, I added a new TypeScript file named log.ts and ...

How can I incorporate a child component into a separate component within Angular version 14?

Currently working with Angular 14 and facing a challenge with including a child component from another module into a standalone component. The structure of the standalone component is as follows: <div> <child-component></child-component& ...

Determine the specific data types of the component properties in React Storybook using TypeScript

Currently, I am putting together a component in the storybook and this is how it appears: import React, { useCallback } from 'react'; import { ButtonProps } from './types'; const Button = (props: ButtonProps) => { // Extract the nec ...

Reaching the maximum request threshold

Currently, I am facing an issue where users are able to upload files from the client side (using Angular 4) to the server (implemented with Spring Boot). The problem arises when a user attempts to upload more than 6 files at once. In such cases, Chrome uti ...

The enigma of the mysterious karma provider error

As a newcomer to unit testing in JavaScript, AngularJS, and Karma, I have successfully written passing tests for controllers. However, when trying to test services, I encountered an error: Unknown provider <- nProvider <- User. The User service is th ...

angular table disabled based on condition

I have a table in my HTML file and I am trying to figure out how to disable the onClick function if the start date is greater than the current date. <ng-container matColumnDef="d"> <th mat-header-cell ...

Is there a way to prevent Angular HttpClient from triggering preflight OPTIONS requests when making simple GET requests?

I need to send a GET request without a preflight OPTIONS, but the server is not responding with an "Access-Control-Allow-Origin" Header. Unfortunately, I am unable to modify these server settings. Here is my code: export interface HttpRequestOptions { ...

How to vertically align Material UI ListItemSecondaryAction in a ListItem

I encountered an issue with @material-ui/core while trying to create a ListItem with Action. I am looking for a way to ensure that the ListItemSecondaryAction stays on top like ListItemAvatar when the secondary text becomes longer. Is there any solution to ...

Ionic 2 hides the form input area within its input component

I set up a login page, but the input fields are not showing up on the form. Here is my current code: <ion-list> <ion-item> <ion-label fixed>Username</ion-label> <ion-i ...

Seems like ngAfterViewInit isn't functioning properly, could it be an error on my end

After implementing my ngAfterViewInit function, I noticed that it is not behaving as expected. I have a hunch that something important may be missing in my code. ngOnInit() { this.dataService.getUsers().subscribe((users) => {this.users = users) ; ...

Methods for opening ngx-daterangepicker-material outside of a button/icon when there are multiple date range pickers in the same form

Is there a way to open ngx-daterangepicker-material by clicking outside of any button or icon? I am aware that ngx-daterangepicker-material allows this functionality through the use of @ViewChild(DaterangepickerDirective, { static: false }) pickerDirective ...

Tabs justified are not constrained by width

Utilizing Bootstrap 3, I aim to have the Tabs align perfectly with the full content. The use of nav-tabs can be observed in the code below. It may seem a bit unusual due to my implementation of Angular 4 and the code being copied from Dev Tools. <ul cl ...

Do I really need to install @angular/router as a dependency in Angular CLI even if I don't plan on using it?

After creating a new Angular CLI project, I noticed that certain dependencies in the package.json file seemed unnecessary. I wanted to remove them along with FormModules and HttpModules from imports: @angular/forms": "^4.0.0", @angular/http": "^4.0.0", @a ...

Node OOM Error in Webpack Dev Server due to Material UI Typescript Integration

Currently in the process of upgrading from material-ui v0.19.1 to v1.0.0-beta.20. Initially, everything seems fine as Webpack dev server compiles successfully upon boot. However, upon making the first change, Node throws an Out of Memory error with the fol ...