Tips for restricting a type field to a power of two within a type system

When looking at certain JavaScript code snippets, one may come across the following:

function allocate(bits) {
  if ((bits & (bits - 1)) != 0) {
    throw "Parameter is not a power of 2";
  }
  ...
}

In essence, there exists a restriction on the value of input parameter bits, requiring it to be a power of two. Alternatively, instead of referring to it as a "constraint," it could be labeled as a validation that enforces the input to be a power of two.

On a side note, a similar concept of constraints can be applied in SQL as demonstrated below:

CREATE TABLE dbo.Payroll 
    (
     ID int PRIMARY KEY, 
     PositionID INT, 
     Salary decimal(9,2),
     SalaryType nvarchar(10),  
     CHECK  (Salary > 10.00 and Salary < 150000.00) 
    );

ALTER TABLE dbo.Payroll WITH NOCHECK  
  ADD  CONSTRAINT CK_Payroll_SalaryType_Based_On_Salary
  CHECK  ((SalaryType = 'Hourly' and Salary < 100.00) or
          (SalaryType = 'Monthly' and Salary < 10000.00) or
          (SalaryType = 'Annual'));

In both the SQL and JavaScript scenarios described above, the code execution happens at runtime to validate its correctness. While this behavior is confirmed for JavaScript, its occurrence in SQL might also be runtime-oriented.

The curiosity lies in exploring how a robust type system like TypeScript or another type-aware programming language can articulate the “power of two” constraint effectively. Ideally, transitioning it into a compile-time restriction presents an intriguing challenge. Is such a feat achievable? If yes, what methodologies are adopted by various languages to accomplish this? Any language example would suffice, serving primarily as a source of inspiration towards implementing this functionality within a custom language using its unique type system. Visualizing this as a compile-time constraint poses interesting questions around defining a specific “type,” denoting the “category of power of two integers.” Nonetheless, executing this task seamlessly remains a topic of exploration.

Answer №1

There isn't a single definitive method for solving this problem because there are various approaches with different tradeoffs. Here, I will discuss some of the major styles used in Haskell.

"Correct by Construction"

Instead of allowing a general type like Int and then trying to restrict it later, consider introducing a type that can only represent valid powers of two, either through encapsulation:

allocate :: PowerOfTwo -> …
... ...

One thing I appreciate about all these techniques is that they eliminate the need for repetitive validation. Once you have a proof that an invariant is true, whether it's a structural rule or an actual proof object, you can safely assume its validity and use more efficient code without risking safety.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Can you verify that the client's date and time locale are accurate in JavaScript before proceeding with processing?

For my application, I am seeking the current locale datetime. However, before retrieving the date, it is crucial to verify that the local date and time are accurate. If the user has adjusted the date and time incorrectly on their machine, I must prompt a ...

Discovering the proper method for indicating the type of a variable in the middle of a statement

In my code, there was a line that looked like this: let initialPayload = this.db.list("/members").snapshotChanges() as Observable<any[]> But then I changed it to this: let initialPayload = this.db.list("/members").snapshotChanges ...

Issue encountered in Loopback 4: Error with @repository dependency injection (TypeError: Undefined property 'findOne')

As I set up Bearer Token authentication for my Loopback 4 application, I referenced this implementation guide: https://github.com/strongloop/loopback-next/tree/master/packages/authentication. Within my src/providers/auth-strategy.provider.ts file, I encou ...

Turning an array of strings into a multidimensional array

I have a JavaScript string array that I need to convert into a multidimensional array: const names = [ "local://john/doe/blog", "local://jane/smith/portfolio", "as://alexander/wong/resume" ]; The desired output sh ...

Use an input of map<string,string> when passing to an angular component

Trying to pass an input value for a component reuse, but facing the challenge of having to use a "hardcoded" map of strings. Uncertain about how to effectively pass this information: <continue-p [additionalInfo]="{ "myString": "str ...

The use of findDOMNode has been marked as outdated in StrictMode. Specifically, findDOMNode was utilized with an instance of Transition (generated by MUI Backdrop) that is contained

I encountered the following alert: Alert: detectDOMNode is now outdated in StrictMode. detectDOMNode was given an instance of Transition which resides within StrictMode. Instead, attach a ref directly to the element you wish to reference. Get more inform ...

How can I send form data along with images from Angular to Node.js via an http post request?

When designing this template, I am requesting product information and an image to be stored. <input type="hidden" formControlName="_id"> <input type="file" formControlName="ProductImage" #ProductImage> <mat-form-field> <input for ...

How can data be typically encapsulated within Pinia stores when leveraging the composition API?

Currently, in my Vue 3 application with Pinia, I am interested in leveraging the composition API within my Pinia stores. Take a look at this example store: export const useMyStore = defineStore("my", () => { const currentState = ref(0); return ...

Input value not being displayed in one-way binding

I have a challenge in binding the input value (within a foreach loop) in the HTML section of my component to a function: <input [ngModel]="getStepParameterValue(parameter, testCaseStep)" required /> ... // Retrieving the previously saved v ...

How can I convert the >= value into an ASCII character within a TypeScript file?

Within my Angular TS file, I am attempting to identify if a string contains the characters >= and then substitute them with the corresponding ASCII character for greater than or equal to. Here is my current code snippet: @Input() public set textLabel(va ...

Incorporate a personalized add-button into the material-table interface

My current setup includes a basic material-table structured like this: <MaterialTable options={myOptions} title="MyTitle" columns={state.columns} data={state.data} tableRef={tableRef} // Not functioning properly editabl ...

When typing declarations are used, they clarify whether the entity being referenced is an Object or

I am currently working on aligning the Dockerode run typings to match the actual implementation. The issue arises when I invoke run as TypeScript consistently identifies the return value as a Promise. It seems that TypeScript is having trouble distinguish ...

Assigning to a constrained type with an indexable signature results in failure

When using typescript 4.7.2, I encountered an issue where the following code fails only when assigning a value: type IndexableByString = { [k: string]: any }; function test<T extends IndexableByString>(target: T, key: string) { var prop = target ...

When I define a type in TypeScript, it displays "any" instead

Imagine a scenario where we have a basic abstract class that represents a piece in a board game such as chess or checkers. export abstract class Piece<Tags, Move, Position = Vector2> { public constructor(public position: Position, public tags = nul ...

Methods in Ionic to call an external JavaScript file from TypeScript

Having a JSON list stored in a JavaScript file, my objective is to filter it using TypeScript before sending the filtered results to the HTML homepage. However, I encountered an issue within the HTML file. It's worth mentioning that when running the ...

Angular 4 allows you to assign unique colors to each row index in an HTML table

My goal is to dynamically change the colors of selected rows every time a button outside the table is clicked. I am currently utilizing the latest version of Angular. While I am familiar with setting row colors using CSS, I am uncertain about how to manip ...

Specialized typescript function that is compatible with extended interfaces

Is there a way to create a versatile function that can be applied to any interface derived from a top-level interface? This function should take an unpersisted interface (without an id property) and return a persisted one (with an id property). The two ma ...

create the text with double bold - adjusted pages

Is there a method to enhance the boldness of the text without adjusting the font size? Currently, the following styling is applied: numbers: { fontSize: 30, color: '#31C283', fontWeight: 'bold', }, Is there a way to m ...

Using Iframe for WooCommerce integration and implementing Facebook login within an Ionic application

I have created an Ionic application that includes an iframe from a Wordpress website. Here is the code snippet from my home.page.ts file: import { Component } from '@angular/core'; import { DomSanitizer } from "@angular/platform-browser"; @Com ...

Angular throws an error when double quotes are used instead of single quotes

How can I fix the build error in the production environment? ERROR: /home/vsts/work/1/s/src/app/app.component.spec.ts[1, 32]: " should be ' ERROR: /home/vsts/work/1/s/src/app/app.component.spec.ts[2, 30]: " should be ' All files pass lin ...