Strategies for Resolving Circular Dependencies in NestJS with GraphQL

Imagine having two different entities:

// user.entity.ts

@ObjectType()
@Entity()
export class User {
  @Field()
  @PrimaryGeneratedColumn('uuid')
  id: string;

  @Field()
  @Column({ unique: true })
  username: string;

  @Column({ select: false })
  password: string;

  @Field(() => [Task])
  @OneToMany(() => Task, (task) => task.author)
  authorOfTasks: Task[]
}

and

// task.entity.ts

@ObjectType()
@Entity()
export class Task {
  @Field()
  @PrimaryGeneratedColumn('uuid')
  id: string;

  @Field()
  @Column()
  title: string;

  @Field()
  @Column({ nullable: true })
  description?: string;

  @Field(() => User)
  @ManyToOne(() => User, (user) => user.authorOfTasks)
  author: User;
}

In order to resolve the authorOfTasks field in UserResolver and the author field in TaskResolver, you need to inject UserService and TaskService in both resolvers. This can be achieved by:

// user.resolver.ts

@Resolver(of => User)  
export class UserResolver {  
  constructor(  
    private userService: UserService,  
    private taskService: TaskService  
  ) {}  

    // Some queries using userService
  
  @ResolveField(() => [Task])  
  async authorOfTasks(  
    @Parent() author: User  
  ) {  
    return this.taskService.getTasksByAuthor(author)  
  }  
}

and

// task.resolver.ts

@Resolver()  
export class TaskResolver {  
  constructor(  
    private taskService: TaskService,  
    private userService: UserService  
  ) {}  
    
  // Some queries using taskService  
  
  @ResolveField(() => User)  
  async author(  
    @Parent() task: Task  
  ) {  
    return this.userService.getUserById(task.author.id)  
  }  
}

Injecting TaskService and UserService in both resolvers can lead to circular dependencies in your Nest application. Although you can use forwardRef to handle this, it is recommended to avoid circular dependencies whenever possible according to Nest documentation.

What can be done in this scenario? Should the app be restructured somehow to keep the code modular? The current structure is as shown below:

https://i.sstatic.net/sTLLM.png

Thank you! 🙏

Answer â„–1

Although I agree with @michel regarding the common occurrence of circular dependencies in GraphQL, I have a different perspective on the idea of "disabling NestJS" warnings for it.

In my opinion, the proper approach is to utilize forwardRef(), as highlighted in the NestJS documentation here. I faced a similar circular dependency issue when working with NestJS and GraphQL, and I was able to resolve it by addressing it at the Module level instead of the Service level.

Answer â„–2

The issue with your question is not a circular dependency as you have described it. The UserResolver relies on the UserService and the TaskService, while the TaskResolver also depends on the UserService and the TaskService. There is no circular relationship present.

If you are still facing a circular dependency warning, it may be due to a missing detail. It seems likely that you have grouped the UserResolver and UserService in a UserModule, and the TaskResolver and TaskService in a TaskModule. This setup creates a loop of dependencies since both modules need access to each other's services.

To resolve this, consider creating a separate module for the resolvers, such as the ResolversModule, which can import both the TaskModule and the UserModule.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Exporting Arrays in Ionic Angular with Typescript is an essential feature

When trying to access an exported component in Typescript, there may be issues with importing the module correctly into another component. An error message is displayed when calling the AddToArray method: Cannot read property 'push' of undefi ...

Is there a way to switch the eventHandler assigned to a particular input element dynamically?

I am facing a dilemma with my child component, which dynamically generates input fields within a parent component. <app-xxx *ngFor="let el of fieldsElements" [ngModel]="fieldsElements[el.name]" ... ... (keydown)="my ...

Error: Unable to execute NGRX selector - x is not a valid function

I'm puzzled as to why I keep encountering a TypeError with this code. Is there something obvious that I'm overlooking? export const selectAllUsers = createFeatureSelector<ReadonlyArray<User>>('users'); export const select ...

TypeB should utilize InterfaceA for best practice

I have the following TypeScript code snippet. interface InterfaceA { id: string; key: string; value: string | number; } type TypeB = null; const sample: TypeB = { id: '1' }; I am looking for simple and maintainable solutions where TypeB ...

NG8003 error: ExportAs 'ngForm' directive not found in the system

I encountered an issue with my first Angular 11 project: No directive found with exportAs 'ngForm'. Despite importing FormsModule and ReactiveFormsModule in app.module.ts, the error persists. Here is the code snippet: This is from product.compon ...

Strategies for avoiding unused style tags in React components

Expanding beyond React, I'm unsure if React itself is the culprit of this issue. In a React environment with TypeScript, I utilize CSS imports in component files to have specific stylesheets for each component. I assumed these styles would only be ad ...

Exploring the power of Typescript and Map in Node.js applications

I am feeling a little perplexed about implementing Map in my nodejs project. In order to utilize Map, I need to change the compile target to ES6. However, doing so results in outputted js files that contain ES6 imports which causes issues with node. Is t ...

Ways to restrict the values allowed in a TypeScript type?

I have a requirement: type AllowedKeys = 'a' | 'b' | 'c' ... and now I want to define a type where the key has to be one of the values in AllowedKeys. For example: type MyType = { a: number; b: string; c: boolean; d: {} / ...

Tips on displaying a spinner only when data is retrieved from an Http service

How can I ensure that a spinner is only shown during an HTTP service call and dismissed when my component receives data? To address this issue, I implemented a cache service to store data fetched from the HTTP service for future use. However, I want to sh ...

What is the best way to incorporate an external .css file into my Angular project by referencing its URL?

I'm managing a collection of CSS files online and I need to incorporate each one into my project based on its specific requirements. One component in particular is connected to different numerical IDs in the router. I am looking for a way to dynamica ...

Typescript Tooltip for eCharts

I'm working on customizing the tooltip in eChart v5.0.2 using Typescript, but I'm encountering an error related to the formatter that I can't seem to resolve. The error message regarding the function keyword is as follows: Type '(param ...

Issue encountered: NPM error, unable to find solution for resolving dependency and addressing conflicting peer dependency

I am facing difficulties deploying my project on netlify due to NPM errors. Below are the dependencies: "dependencies": { "@angular/animations": "~15.1.1", ... (list of dependencies continues) ...

Using TypeScript to define a static enum within a React functional component

Creating a React.FunctionalComponent with static props: import MyAwesomeComponent from './MyAwesomeComponent'; ... <MyAwesomeComponent mode={MyAwesomeComponent.modes.superAwesome} /> Static props defined as key-value pairs: MyAwe ...

Is it possible for Angular's `HttpClient` to use complex property types in the `.get()` generics aside from just `string` or `number`?

After spending an entire day researching the topic, I've hit a dead end. All my efforts have only led me to discover one thing—omission. None of the information I've come across mentions whether you can utilize non-simple types (such as string ...

Creating a service instance within the constructor in Angular 2

I'm new to Angular 2 and Typescript and I'm trying to wrap my head around DI. One thing that has been tripping me up is the way variables referring to a service are typed into the constructor in all the code examples I've come across. Why is ...

Discovering ways to align specific attributes of objects or target specific components within arrays

I am trying to compare objects with specific properties or arrays with certain elements using the following code snippet: However, I encountered a compilation error. Can anyone help me troubleshoot this issue? type Pos = [number, number] type STAR = &quo ...

The error message "Type 'Dispatch<SetStateAction<undefined>>' cannot be assigned to type 'Dispatch<SetStateAction<MyType | undefined>>'" appears in the code

I'm encountering challenges while creating a wrapper for useState() due to an unfamiliar error: Type 'Dispatch<SetStateAction>' cannot be assigned to type 'Dispatch<SetStateAction<VerifiedPurchase | undefined>>' ...

Guide to dynamically resizing the Monaco editor component using react-monaco-editor

Currently, I am integrating the react-monaco-editor library into a react application for viewing documents. The code snippet below showcases how I have set specific dimensions for height and width: import MonacoEditor from 'react-monaco-editor'; ...

Strategies for Handling Errors within Observable Subscriptions in Angular

While working with code from themes written in the latest Angular versions and doing research online, I've noticed that many developers neglect error handling when it comes to subscription. My question is: When is it necessary to handle errors in an ...

Ensuring that an object containing optional values meets the condition of having at least one property using Zod validation

When using the Zod library in TypeScript to validate an object with optional properties, it is essential for me to ensure that the object contains at least one property. My goal is to validate the object's structure and confirm that it adheres to a sp ...